- 983
- 742
Two reasons:
1. There are more justifications for the "possibly 2-A" than there are for the 2-C, and only one of them (The "maybe infinite iceberg") is just a possibility. The rest are pretty clear cut, and it being separately stated to exist on all planes of reality provides justification that the "maybe infinite iceberg" theory was correct. So I think there is enough that indicates Yggdrasil being a 2-A structure.
2. During his fight with Seth, there are a few things that can support 2-A. Silver Surfer says that "forces powerful enough to rock our entire continuum are in conflict," the battle is "simultaneously waged on every plane of existence," Seth "causes a massive shockwave which ripples across every plane of reality", and Doctor Strange describes it as an "upheaval which is tearing at the very fabric of the multiverse." These to me seem like they meet the "significantly affect" criteria for 2-A, especially the shockwave one.
So in conclusion, between the consistency of Yggdrasil being infinite, Odin's battle with Seth on all planes of existence, and all the other stuff already in the 2-A justification, I think there is more than enough to justify solely 2-A and remove the 2-C and "possibly" entirely.
This would affect all Skyfather tier characters.
I know that there is another Odin CRT going on, but since they said they weren't going to talk about tiering I figured it would be best to make a separate thread.
1. There are more justifications for the "possibly 2-A" than there are for the 2-C, and only one of them (The "maybe infinite iceberg") is just a possibility. The rest are pretty clear cut, and it being separately stated to exist on all planes of reality provides justification that the "maybe infinite iceberg" theory was correct. So I think there is enough that indicates Yggdrasil being a 2-A structure.
2. During his fight with Seth, there are a few things that can support 2-A. Silver Surfer says that "forces powerful enough to rock our entire continuum are in conflict," the battle is "simultaneously waged on every plane of existence," Seth "causes a massive shockwave which ripples across every plane of reality", and Doctor Strange describes it as an "upheaval which is tearing at the very fabric of the multiverse." These to me seem like they meet the "significantly affect" criteria for 2-A, especially the shockwave one.
So in conclusion, between the consistency of Yggdrasil being infinite, Odin's battle with Seth on all planes of existence, and all the other stuff already in the 2-A justification, I think there is more than enough to justify solely 2-A and remove the 2-C and "possibly" entirely.
This would affect all Skyfather tier characters.
I know that there is another Odin CRT going on, but since they said they weren't going to talk about tiering I figured it would be best to make a separate thread.