Soupywolf5
Any/All- 6,127
- 885
Since the fight takes place in an oxygenated area of space then why wouldn't Luffy's flight work? (Since his flight's apparently just kicking off of air)
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
My argument was, and is, "OOC actions are not automatically grounds to call something not a stomp, especially if unlikely."MrKingOfNegativity said:2. You're arguing that "a character not being willing to do something should exclude it as a wincon for them" by using an example of someone's OOC action being a wincon for the other guy. That's a flawed argument at launch.
3. It's not treated as "OOC in general is not a stomp", and whoever's telling you that needs a slap in the head. We recurrently decide based on how unlikely something is to happen, to the point that I can recall more than one occasion where an admin had to make that known because someone was trying to farm a win based on "wincons" a character isn't even smart enough to think of on their own.
And yes, one of the admins in those situations was me.
Anyway, I'm not necessarily saying you're wrong. But supporting your argument by using an example unfathomably more ludicrous than the situation posed in this thread is not making your case look good.
I don't know shit about Medaka, but it's the last line that concerns me, along with the rest of this debate. I've seen it thrown around that "Well, Peridot can do it, so she's fine, it's not a stomp" with less discussion of "Alright, but how reasonable is it for her to do it?"MrDrProfessorPatricio said:If OoC characters are considered a stomp, then all of Medaka's losses should be removed because she always let the enemy take the first move. But I agree that OoC matches are not stomps because they still have options to win
Unfortunately, if you feel like it's too common, that's because it is.Moritzva said:If it's a wiki standard to decide based on how unlikely, well, good. But, perhaps it's a personal opinion, but that's felt lost on me as of late. As if any remotely possible way to win is treated as a way for it to be fair. Just as you mentioned- someone actually tried to farm a win based on wincons. And I imagine that isn't the only time it's happened. And I feel like it's too common.
I'm at school anyways, and I'll be working today, so that'll be fine by me.MrKingOfNegativity said:We can do it after I get back home. I have real-life business I'm about to take care of, and I'll be gone for the next few hours.
Alright.MrKingOfNegativity said:Sure. I'll be much more free then.
Link?WeeklyBattles said:Gems can and have been knocked out.
Gems have been knocked out and have both willingly and unwillingly fallen unconscious, therefore Luffy can knock peridot out.The Calaca said:I'm sorry but I don't get the reasoning behind your self-debunk. May you elaborate, please?
This is not how grace works, and you know it.WeeklyBattles said:Seeing as the issues with the arguments are still being debated this cannot be added
Then do that. If everyone else has to run through the same rigmarole, you can as well.WeeklyBattles said:And ive already said that if this is added i will immediately take it to the removal thread and post the same arguments, which i will
She can control the ship remotely with her Limb Enhancers, and it only requires her to use one hand, so she can hold Luffy with the other.WeeklyBattles said:She cant throw luffy into space as he can fly and she has to remain immobile to pilot the ship