Let's see where this goes: God of Thunder vs. Man of Steel

[LordUrien935]

Looks like it was removed. The match was on both Superman and Thor's pages when I checked earlier. I was right about it being removed very shortly after

 

[DeathstroketheHedgehog]

Superman isn't weak to magic, he just doesn't have any natural resistance to it. It's why he can still take a beatdown from powerful magical attacks and still go toe to toe with other magical opponents such as Shazam.

 

[C2_of_Omegon]

Superman isn't weak to magic, he just doesn't have any natural resistance to it. It's why he can still take a beatdown from powerful magical attacks and still go toe to toe with other magical opponents such as Shazam.

That is semantics and downplay. That is just saying that Superman is no more weak to magic than say Batman. While true, it doesn't change the fact that using magic is way to hurt Superman far more easily than with a lot of other things. When you are proof against most forces except for specific things that can hurt you far more easily than everything else, that's a weakness. Doesn't matter if it's widespread. That's like saying it isn't a limitation that Superman can't see through lead because most people can't either.

Or, in more classical example, that's like saying that Achilles heel isn't a weakness because most everyone else has the same weak point.

Or a real world example. You wearing armor everywhere but around your neck. But it's not a weakpoint because most people aren't armored around their neck either, right? No, it's still a weakpoint because that part of your body can be easily harmed if hit unlike the rest that's protected by the armor.

Throw a playing card at Superman. It won't do a thing. Throw a magic playing card at him and it'll cut him. Even Shazam, whose not the best example as the only real magic he uses offensively, if at all, is magic lightning stil hurts like b!tch. Shoot Wonder Woman's magic tiara can cut his throat.

Besides, not only due numerous characters straight up call it a weakness, we on-site list as one due to numerous examples. Even Superman himself notes that magic is a problem for him.

 

[PapiSavitar5025]

Bump, this is honestly a hard one. Probably Inconclusive though, but I still lean towards Superman slightly.