Bump. A month without any updates. Hope this is not considered derailment.
Few questions:
1. Mewni has multiple moons. Some are huge in size, others are smaller. Does that not make the rotating spell/lasso feat even more impressive? I can post pictures of the moons if needed.
A serious scientific answer to an absurd hypothetical, and the first chapter of Randall Munroe's upcoming book.
www.esquire.com
According to this article, our Moon would get the Earth spinning again if it stopped rotating suddenly. So the spell was strong enough to negate the moons' influence.
2. Moon Butterfly creates a storm when casting the immortal killing spell. We can hear thunder and see wind being created. Does this count for AP in anyway? There's weather manipulation spells in this verse; Star once created a cloud that went rouge.
3. What would it take for the laser spells and laser dodging to be considered light speed in this verse? There are no light speed statements, but we have seen lasers that move in straight lines being deflected by Marco's sword. The wand can be used as a light source, Star has used it to light up a room. It can fire firework spells, actual laser spells, create laser puppies, spider that shoot lasers, create rainbows, project time like a clock, can be used as thermal imaging camera etc. The wand can create weapons made of light as well. The book states Moon's sword is made of light. Yes, I know a magic wand isn't realistic, but inverse it kinda is?
In the first intro of the show, we see Star and Marco evade a laser that is coming from a machine with light as well
Image intro hosted in ImgBB
ibb.co
Regarding tiers, if it were up to me, this is how I would put it.
Keep in mind, it's only my opinion and taking the feats/statements at face value.
Base:
Varies Usually
High 8-C (Destroyed a watchtower) to
8-B (Easily overpowers monsters like Lobster Claws who destroyed four city blocks. Stronger than regular Mewmans/River Butterfly who can survive atmospheric re-entry, Whispering spell destroying Ludo's Castle,
Potentially 7-A (Skywynne destroying mountains and hills),
Potentially 5-C (Lasso feat),
Potentially 5-B ( with Mega Explosive Crystal Laser stated to neutralize entire planets, stronger than Zedlord who blew up a planet, one-shotted Helios, a living sun, who threaten to consume the Earth, stopping the planet from rotating spell)
Butterfly form:
Varies.
At least 8-B (Stronger magic in this form). Same as above.
Dip Down:
At least 2-C (Skywynne dimension busting, killed Toffee who one shot Omnitraxus+defeated Moon Butterfly+killed Comet Butterfly (possibly Solaria Butterfly as well), broke Glossaryck's arm), merging Earth and Mewni universes, re-creating the Realm of Magic etc),
Possibly higher (Eclipsa's Total Annihilation spell-stated to be able to destroy every dimension in the multiverse over time. Can possibly destroy the multiverse with time loop)
This way you get a decent escalation of tiers. I don't think going by seasons keys is a great idea myself.