Heaven's Feel ~ Shirou Emiya vs Sakura Matou

[Scarletmoon56]

The Hero of Justice
vs

The Black Grail : 3 (Lu Bane, Gargoyle, Promestein)

Today (or in my country at least) is October 14th, the day the anime adapdation of Fate/stay night ~ Heaven's Feel is released in theaters. In celebration of the last route getting an adaptation and that it features best girl Sakura (come and fight me), this is a battle of the two protagonists.

Conditions:

+ Unlimted Blade Works Shirou (FULL POWER)

+ Dark Sakura (FULL POWER)

+ Win via Death

 

[Schnee_One]

Let's see, Heaven's Feel Shirou, someone vastly superior to his UBW self, was afraid of Dark Sakura.

Hmm....

 

[Scarletmoon56]

I thought UBW Shirou was more potent compared to Fate and HF routes?

 

[Schnee_One]

You're right it's more potent then his Fate self.

Heavens Feel against UBW? Not even close.

Heavens Feel Shirou is FAR superior to his UBW self, better CQC, better tracing, far more skilled, he's better in literally every conceivable way except for less stamina.

UBW Shirou is also completely incapable of killing someone who can regen from the torso.

 

[Lu_Bane]

I don't believe HF, Fate, or UBW Shirou would beat Dark Sakura. The only one I see doing that is Fate/Kaleid's Emiya, y'know, the one who took out all of the servants in the war one after another in a single night.

Giving this one to Dark Yandere-chan.

 

[Schnee_One]

Agreed.

Only master stronger then Dark Sakura is Welt Ende Rin

 

[Promestein]

Shirou could break her connection to Angra Mainyu with Rule Breaker and return her sanity.

And he can kill people who can regenerate from just their torso. Gae Bolg inhibits Regenerationn significantly, as do a lot of other Noble Phantasms.

That's not to say Shirou wins; Sakura spams Shadow Giants which keep him from ever getting close enough, and the Shadow swats away any Noble Phantasms that get close enough to threaten her.

 

[Schnee_One]

UBW Shirou can trace Rule Breaker?

 

[AguilaR101]

UBW Shirou can't trace Rule Breaker

He saw the dagger, that means he must have it stored in UBW even if we do not see it being used.

Edit: Not like it makes a difference though, he will be overwhelmed by Sakura's shadow giants as his casual output doesn't match Rin w/ zelretch which was likened to a Excalibur spam.

 

[Promestein]

HF Shirou can use it even though he only saw it once, for a brief period of time, right before Saber immediately killed Caster.

UBW Shirou saw it several times. In action.