-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Gods of Future Manipulators: Yhwach vs Nafta
- Thread starter ImmortalDread
- Start date
- Status
- 391
- 109
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #47
Thanks. Seems Nafta is better future manipulator
- 5,220
- 3,346
Not really?
Yhwach can actually rewrite futures, from what I was told above, Nafta can only choose between them
Yhwach = choose and change
Nafta = choose
Yhwach loses because of things unrelated to the future manip
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #49
Change…? He can alter it, I assume.
- 391
- 109
There is no difference
As there is infinite futures with infinite possibilities
They can choose that result directly instead of changing one to make it like that
And yhwach change it with probability manip if im not wrong
Nafta have probability manip too
- 5,220
- 3,346
There is a difference in mechanics and application, Yhwach can alter futures and choose between existing ones, Nafta can only do the latter, although the results are the same one is clearly superior
No Yhwach doesn't change it with probability manip, no idea where you got that from
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #52
Ya, but he does not change the future either. He explicitly alters it.
- 5,220
- 3,346
That's blatantly not the case as he rewrote the future so that he didn't die after he died
And of course, he broke every Bankai in the future, literally changing those futures
He can choose between pre-existing futures and also modify them
- 391
- 109
Rewrote the future of his death by changing his future with the future where he didn't die
This just choosing another future to happen
Idk about the bankai ones
I need to read the manga again to confirm it
I kinda remember him saying that he choose the future where the bankai is broken ( remember there is infinite possibilities so this is possible too )
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #56
He explained there is a drain of sands (which presents “infinite” possibilities”) and he picked one of them and alter reality with it.
But he never really modifies the future. I am sure he picks the existing possibility and replaces it. Also, why modify them if they are already infinite? Is that not anti-feat to his 2-A range right now?
This is called fate manipulation. He alters the future by choosing the existing future/possibility (which is physical; the reason he got the 2-A range with it).
But he never really modifies the future. I am sure he picks the existing possibility and replaces it. Also, why modify them if they are already infinite? Is that not anti-feat to his 2-A range right now?
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #57
Again, why modify the future if there are infinite existing possibilities?
- 5,220
- 3,346
Or he rewrote the future by making it so that he just didn't die in that future...? This is the problem with this argument, distinguishing between changing from one of an infinite futures and altering one are impossible, as technically every event has and not happened so he could just pick from them instead of changing it.
No he never said he chose a future where Bankai was broken, he very clearly says he broke it in the future, he's not choosing a future where Bankai are already broken, he's actively altering the future so that they're already broken.
Though this doesn't matter, it's not changing that this match is a stomp.
azontr
He/Him- 39,445
- 49,530
Yhwach's nose in this scan is rigid afOr he rewrote the future by making it so that he just didn't die in that future...? This is the problem with this argument, distinguishing between changing from one of an infinite futures and altering one are impossible, as technically every event has and not happened so he could just pick from them instead of changing it.
No he never said he chose a future where Bankai was broken, he very clearly says he broke it in the future, he's not choosing a future where Bankai are already broken, he's actively altering the future so that they're already broken.
Though this doesn't matter, it's not changing that this match is a stomp.
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #60
Makes sense but again, I wanna know if I am not understanding wrong if there is infinite pre-existing possibilities, why he is needed to modify the future by himself? Is he capable to modify ones that did not exist..?
- 5,220
- 3,346
Oversight by Kubo maybe? idk
There's quite a bit of evidence for there being infinite futures in Bleach though, and Yhwach is stated to be able to manipulate all of them
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #62
Again, I am not disagreeing with it. But like, this is just evidence that he can modify an impossible event, tho?
I am sure he just chooses the future from infinite futures, avoiding his death. Unless, the argument is, that he is even able to modify an impossible future which is impressive…
- 5,220
- 3,346
I'm not really sure what you mean tbh
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #64
Alright, I will rephrase it, tho.
Why does he need to change a future if there are already an infinite number of futures already existing?
Unless he simply chooses one of these infinite pre-existing futures to avoid his death?
Hellscream
He/Him- 1,538
- 660
idk why people think that yhwach just picks a different future when it's stated multiple times that he can alter / rewrite the future itself
also stated that he can change the entirety of fate as he wills.
also stated that he can change the entirety of fate as he wills.
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #66
The thing is that he explicitly explained the way he does it. (if you remember the example of the drain of sands and how he all need is to choose one of the grain of sands/paths and replace it)
And why does he need to modify a future if he can pick one of infinite pre-existing futures/possibilities and alter it on reality?
Unless you are saying he was altering a future where it does not exist. I am trying to understand @Purgy. Not really debating, I just simply do not remember that.
Hellscream
He/Him- 1,538
- 660
He doesn't say that he chooses them tho?
He says that all ichigo is doing by changing the future is going from one drop of sand to the other, and that yhwach has full control over every possibility / future while watching from high above
He says that all ichigo is doing by changing the future is going from one drop of sand to the other, and that yhwach has full control over every possibility / future while watching from high above
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #68
Yap, agreed, and those possibilities are infinite and pre-existing (physically as well). He got full control over it.
Going from one drop of sand to another is literally choosing one from others.
Again, we were talking about the bankai case where he modified a none-existent future. And I am asking if it is true.
Hellscream
He/Him- 1,538
- 660
He destroyed every bankai at the same time when he destroyed ichigo's bankai
- 391
- 109
Since there is infinite possibilities
This mean there is a possibility where the bankai is destroyed
Im kinda sure he just choose one of them
Especially since he explain his ability after the chapter of the scan that he shared with us
Or it might be really modifying future i don't remember
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #71
Ya, this is what I am thinking, lol.
- 5,220
- 3,346
There isn't really any need, as you said, if there are an infinite amount of futures, Yhwach shouldn't ever need to alter the specifics of a future when he can just switch to one that suits what he wants, but it's blatantly clear from his feats and from the fact that he states he broke Ichigo's Bankai in the future that he can alter the events of a future without having to change to a different one, so as I said, it's probably just an oversight/inconsistency from Kubo
I guess you could consider it an antifeat to the infinite futures thing if you want to
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #73
Ya, this is what I am stating, it is somehow an antifeat to me lol.
Hellscream
He/Him- 1,538
- 660
How is it an antifeat, having infinite futures doesn't really mean that there's always a possibility that something doesn't happen tho??
it's never stated, not even once that yhwach chooses from on of the futures, every single statement is about him rewriting / altering it.
idk where you guys are getting this information from
yhwach's statement: "i can even rewrite futures in which i have already died"
: "My power is the power to alter the future itself"
it's never stated, not even once that yhwach chooses from on of the futures, every single statement is about him rewriting / altering it.
idk where you guys are getting this information from
yhwach's statement: "i can even rewrite futures in which i have already died"
: "My power is the power to alter the future itself"
- 5,220
- 3,346
You literally cannot interpret it like this
"So I broke it in the future"
"I can even rewrite the future in which I die"
These two statements are blatantly him changing the events of a future and not just switching to a different one
- 391
- 109
The rewrite one can obviously be changing
Broke in the future is kinda hard to tell
But like i said the meaning can be that there were a future where he broke the bankai and choosed that future
In this case the word broke in future can apply
- 18,393
- 14,310
- Thread starter
- #78
Why would he need to re-write a future that already exists if it can be chosen and replaced in the present? Unless it does not exist, which means there is no infinite pre-existing future?
You are aware that “infinite pre-existing future” also means there is a pre-existing future where he avoided his death.
And there are also infinite possibilities.
- 5,220
- 3,346
Yhwach states that Ichigo jumps from future to future, and then later Yhwach states he can do the same but to every future
It's pretty clear that he can both change between futures and alter things within them
- 391
- 109
Alter things with the other futures
Thats how i understand it
If there is a bleach crt that explain it in another way
You can give me the link
Idk why were even arguing this battle already ended
- Status
