Dragon Ball Z: Broly Triple Threat is canon to Dragon Ball Z Anime

[JohnCenaNation]

So I saw Dragon Ball Z: Bio-Broly like few days ago and there was a scene where Android 18 confronted Hercule Satan about paying her up about regarding to letting him win a fight over her in 25th World Martial Arts Tournament which is a scene they showed from the Dragon Ball Z Anime. Don't believe me? Here is the proof:

So yeah we are going to update Broly to Tier 3-B: Multi-Galaxy level, might as well update the Cell Saga characters and Buu Saga characters in Dragon Ball Z Anime accordingly lol. If not, might as well just separate Dragon Ball Movie from Dragon Ball Anime and do separate power scaling all together.

 

[JohnCenaNation]

B
U
M
P

 

[LephyrTheRevanchist]

B
U
M
P

Wait at least 12-24 hrs before bumping

 

[LuffyRuffy46307]

So I saw Dragon Ball Z: Bio-Broly like few days ago and there was a scene where Android 18 confronted Hercule Satan about paying her up about regarding to letting him win a fight over her in 25th World Martial Arts Tournament which is a scene they showed from the Dragon Ball Z Anime. Don't believe me? Here is the proof:

So yeah we are going to update Broly to Tier 3-B: Multi-Galaxy level, might as well update the Cell Saga characters and Buu Saga characters in Dragon Ball Z Anime accordingly lol. If not, might as well just separate Dragon Ball Movie from Dragon Ball Anime and do separate power scaling all together.

A while ago I just updated Broly Toei to solid 3-B, he devastated the entire Southern Galaxy (which confirmed having countless of them inside) and later if not stopped he would destroy the entire universe, Brolly's feat is greater than any Z anime in scale

I don't remember much about the third Broly movie, but if that's right I completely agree.

 

[JohnCenaNation]

A while ago I just updated Broly Toei to solid 3-B, he devastated the entire Southern Galaxy (which confirmed having countless of them inside) and later if not stopped he would destroy the entire universe, Brolly's feat is greater than any Z anime in scale

I don't remember much about the third Broly movie, but if that's right I completely agree.

Yeah you could just look up the movie online for free.

 

[Thelastmlg]

don't see why this makes it canon to the anime, and not make the anime canon to it, it is referencing something from the anime, not the other way around

 

[Fezzih_007]

I have to agree with the thelast, i don't see how that makes canon to the dbz anime.

 

[JohnCenaNation]

don't see why this makes it canon to the anime, and not make the anime canon to it, it is referencing something from the anime, not the other way around

I am confused by what you meant by that.

 

[AnAverageUsername]

I am confused by what you meant by that.

The movie references the anime, but the anime does not reference the movie, therefore there is doubt for canonicity

 

[JohnCenaNation]

The movie references the anime, but the anime does not reference the movie, therefore there is doubt for canonicity

Wouldn't that be the same for Dragon Ball Z: Fusion Reborn? The movie reference the anime, the anime didn't reference the movie.

 

[AnAverageUsername]

Wouldn't that be the same for Dragon Ball Z: Fusion Reborn? The movie reference the anime, the anime didn't reference the movie.

Idk I was just summarizing what was said

 

[Eseseso]

That just shows the anime is canon to the movie, not the other way around.

Disagree with OP.

 

[omegabronic]

So I saw Dragon Ball Z: Bio-Broly like few days ago and there was a scene where Android 18 confronted Hercule Satan about paying her up about regarding to letting him win a fight over her in 25th World Martial Arts Tournament which is a scene they showed from the Dragon Ball Z Anime. Don't believe me? Here is the proof:

So yeah we are going to update Broly to Tier 3-B: Multi-Galaxy level, might as well update the Cell Saga characters and Buu Saga characters in Dragon Ball Z Anime accordingly lol. If not, might as well just separate Dragon Ball Movie from Dragon Ball Anime and do separate power scaling all together.

problem with this is, the broly movies have no way to fit into the cannon timeline

like, there is no place to put them to make sense

 

[Reiner04]

That just shows the anime is canon to the movie, not the other way around.

Disagree with OP.

I also Disagree for @Eseseso reason.

 

[Fezzih_007]

problem with this is, the broly movies have no way to fit into the cannon timeline

like, there is no place to put them to make sense

Well, If you could stretch a little, you could say that between the 2 days that Trunks and Goten are training fusion, 18 decides that her wants the money mr satan promisses her, and Goten and Trunks stop they training to tag along, the movie happens, and they come back to the lookout after that.

 

[Eseseso]

Nothing says Bio-Broly is canon to Toei, and even then we don't scale Bio-Broly to the OG Broly.

 

[omegabronic]

Well, If you could stretch a little, you could say that between the 2 days that Trunks and Goten are training fusion, 18 decides that her wants the money mr satan promisses her, and Goten and Trunks stop they training to tag along, the movie happens, and they come back to the lookout after that.

and everyone forgot about majin buu? what about the other 2 movies? those can't connect either

 

[Fezzih_007]

and everyone forgot about majin buu? what about the other 2 movies? those can't connect either

Yeah, the timeline don't make sense, i just stretching.

 

[AnAverageUsername]

Might have already been discussed but I'd like to throw in this video

 

[Eseseso]

The only canon ones are Fusion Reborn, the one with Hindugarn, the Garlic One, and the first Cooler Movie

 

[JohnCenaNation]

problem with this is, the broly movies have no way to fit into the cannon timeline

like, there is no place to put them to make sense

The first Broly film could easily fit into the timeline, like they fought Broly while waiting for Cell Games after their HBTC training. This is evident when the prove are easily given with their transformations. The second Broly film I am guessing takes place before the 25th World Martial Arts Tournament, and the third Broly film takes place after the 25th World Martial Arts Tournament.

 

[Fezzih_007]

The first Broly film could easily fit into the timeline, like they fought Broly while waiting for Cell Games after their HBTC training.

It really could't trought, for 3 reasons.
1- Gohan and Goku are not Super Saiyans in the movie, even trought in that period they are training constatly to stay in that forma for longe period of time.

2 - Cell give them 10 days to prepare for the tournament, and the movie take atleast 2 days to get done, so It should be able to take place... But, during that week, some Characters are training in the Room of sprit and time for atleast a Day, Goku goes searching to restore the Dragon Balls, the anime include some fillers during that time, and the plano of erradicate the Saiyans also occur during that time (Goku references Broly in the Movie).
The week as packed with events, so i really can't see where in the hell they save time to Broly.

3 - After the fight, the Z Warriors have taking a beating by Broly and spend ALL they energy too beat him, so they couldn't be in Full health to fight Cell, and Senzu Bean is not exactly a options since they are Very hard to make, they couldn't have a bunch of them.

 

[omegabronic]

The first Broly film could easily fit into the timeline, like they fought Broly while waiting for Cell Games after their HBTC training.

in which goku and gohan stayed super sayan during the entire time, that was kind of the point of their training, yet they are in base form in the movie

This is evident when the prove are easily given with their transformations. The second Broly film I am guessing takes place before the 25th World Martial Arts Tournament

yet videl knows how to fly, goten and trunks know how to fuse

, and the third Broly film takes place after the 25th World Martial Arts Tournament.

which still gives problems like i said above

 

[y3p_owo]

I disagree fra.

It's not referenced in either the anime or manga so why should we use it for them.

 

[LephyrTheRevanchist]

don't see why this makes it canon to the anime, and not make the anime canon to it, it is referencing something from the anime, not the other way around

Agreed

 

[Eseseso]

don't see why this makes it canon to the anime, and not make the anime canon to it, it is referencing something from the anime, not the other way around

Basically what I said.

 

[denisnic55]

I agree with omegabronic.

 

[JohnCenaNation]

Might have already been discussed but I'd like to throw in this video

So the conclusion is that we couldn't fit the Dragon Ball Movies in the same timeline as Dragon Ball Anime, therefore we need to do a separate profiles altogether.

 

[JohnCenaNation]

Who wants to create a Son Goku (DBZ Movie) profile to separate from Son Goku (DBZ Anime) profile? Give me a show of hands.

 

[omegabronic]

Who wants to create a Son Goku (DBZ Movie) profile to separate from Son Goku (DBZ Anime) profile? Give me a show of hands.

the thing is, some of the movies are even contradictory to eachother, plus is there any reason to assume any of them is in canon to the other?

 

[Damage3245]

Others already explained why this isn't valid. I disagree with the OP.

 

[JohnCenaNation]

the thing is, some of the movies are even contradictory to eachother, plus is there any reason to assume any of them is in canon to the other?

Multiple movie villains appeared in Dragon Ball Z: Fusion Reborn. Also according to Toriyama or what it somebody stated in a interview, the movies takes place in a alternate dimension timeline from the anime. Which makes the movies in a way canon to each other.

 

[omegabronic]

Multiple movie villains appeared in Dragon Ball Z: Fusion Reborn.

so what? doesn't change the fact that they don't fit in the story, those are merely references at least and at most that just means that there is versions of those character in toei continuity

Also according to Toriyama or what it somebody stated in a interview, the movies takes place in a alternate dimension timeline from the anime.

toryama didn't made the movies, he has little to no say in this case, plus as said before, some of the movies contradict each other so they can't be in the same continuity

Which makes the movies in a way canon to each other.

explain the numerous contradictions to the cannon of the show then

 

[Maverick_Zero_X]

I disagree with the OP for reasons stated.

 

[JohnCenaNation]

so what? doesn't change the fact that they don't fit in the story, those are merely references at least and at most that just means that there is versions of those character in toei continuity


toryama didn't made the movies, he has little to no say in this case, plus as said before, some of the movies contradict each other so they can't be in the same continuity


explain the numerous contradictions to the cannon of the show then

So if we can't scale the movies to each other nor can we scale the movies with the anime, then we have only one option. Either hakai the movie character profiles which no one wants or we scale the movie characters based off what we know from their movies. I really hate cherry picking here.

 

[Thelastmlg]

Why hakai the profiles if the anime is canon to them + they usually have their own feats anyway like broly or movie goku