The fact it's timeless so time shouldnt pass?
The World of Living still has a flow of time, one, so that legitimately doesn’t work.
And? If bro is in Other World, any time he spends there should be, comparatively, INSTANT, relative to the living world.
If time passes in both, 1:1, it isnt timeless.
It’s also not like time “stops” for Goku.
It SHOULD if it's timeless.
All that occurs is time moves naturally in the Mortal Universe while Goku ***** off. Like, that line of thinking doesn’t apply unless specified by the story.
No thats actual standards and what timeless indicates..if it doesnt follow that, it's just yapping that means nothing.
If Goku goes to other world, and to him 5 minutes has passed. And then he goes to living world, and 5m ALSO passed, whole thing falls apart. Zero minutes shouldve passed, in much the same way time in the rosat and living world isnt uniform and the discrepancy is actually reflected in perceived time, the same would also apply here.
It doesnt, it's the exact opposite, so it aint.
Two, all of the means that Goku watches Otherworld are through the Gods. Crystal Orbs, King Kai’s Clairvoyance, etc. Essentially, magical powers. This means no one actually views them in the normal way to achieve that effect.
Bro, we are LITERALLY given exact timeframes down to the minute at multiple points. And some cases months. It's uniform. Time passes the same between, if it timeless, no time shouldve passed.
Except that isn’t necessary?
Nothing says that Otherworld can’t be:
0 -> 0 -> Goku blips in (still 0) -> Training (still 0) -> Leaves (still 0) -> 0
The entire Saiyan Saga, Cell exploding in other world time passing and coming back like 10m later despite that whole time he was in other world, goku ******* off to king kai to train for a few weeks in super, the numerous times Goku blips there, does stuff, comes back and time has passed, the 7y time skip. Like jesus man there's actually like a hundred.
You're straight up wrong, we KNOW that isnt what happens.
While the Universe is
1 -> 2 -> Goku leaves from MU (exiting time, 3) -> 4 -> Goku enters MU (entering Time, 5), -> 6
See above.
Except the RoSaT doesn’t operate based on the Earth?
And neither would other world if it has no time?
Like dog, you either have time or you dont, there's no inbetween. It does, we know it does. If youre arguing it's tied to earth, that still means it effectively has time.
It’s just conveniently moving at a speed specifically a year’s worth. Just like how other versions move at their own time rates.
Yes, because it has a different time. Time in there, and time out, differ, because time flows differently.
This proves and acknowledges DBZ can and will show time discrepancies.
Other World, explicitly shows otherwise.
Furthermore, again, I have no idea why Time can’t just pass linearly while the people outside time enter and exit time.
For the exact same reason why a year in the ROSAT aint the same outside? They have different time flows, in other worlds case, it'd have NONE.
What sense does this make? The only one whose time perception should be ****** is the guy in the timeless dimension, not those in normal time around him. Just because time doesn’t pass in another realm doesn’t suddenly make another reality stop having its own flow.
The fact Goku's and everybody's time perception isnt ******. The very fact DBZ follows these rules hence why the ROSAT aint useless, with a perceived year in there, being only a day out, precisely due to said time difference.
Other World is cooked lad, it literally doesnt work with both common sense, our standards, and even the verse itself.
Also not that it matters, but do note this would downgrade the cosmology as if otherworld lacks time, it evidently wouldnt be a separate space time and lack a defining trait of what makes a dimension, dimensionsal, that being TIME. U7 would basically lose a uni.