• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

DEATHBATTLE! Accuracy Scale [READ RULES FIRST!] (Limit Reached)

Dragonmasterxyz said:
Renamon vs Lucario is odd.
It's accurate...but both mons were downplayed. For one, they used feats from Rika's Renamon who has fought and absorbed Champion level Digimon consistently, meaning that she was in the 6-B range. Also, they used feats from Sir Aaron's Lucario who iirc is High 6-A. This isn't even mentioning abilities. So accurate in the result, but the research wasn't the best. Of course they were going by a random Renamon vs a random Lucario, but still.
Click to expand...
 
That's on ground, can't Lex only keep up with Superman due to him weakening him? Sure, DC blitzes Marvel overall, but Lex cheats.
 
Greymon vs Charizard downplayed both and wanked both. They used the Digivice's feat of stopping Apocalymon as a power feat for WarGreymon when it isn't (the Apocalymon fight is an outlier regardless). They also scaled Red's Charizard to that guy from X/Y/Z who fought the Weather Trio which would be an outlier (And...well....is not his Charizard).
 
And Brainiac scales to Superman see the problem in that?

Considering Brainiac scales below it and Lex needed prep to kill him but still had the speed to keep up.

No, geniuenely don't see a problem
 
TitanCrusher101 said:
He scales to Brainiac? Oof. I didn't know that. Also, why?
Click to expand...
Killed one of his clones and snapped his neck.

Took prep, but he still has the speed
 
Why is that relevant again?

Not like it matters since Brainiac even without prep blitzes and Hax stomps Iron Man.
 
Peter "Quicksilver" Maximoff said:
Read my previous reply to this in the comments above us please.
Click to expand...
They're not changing my mind until the file is fixed

Though Yobo is correct
 
Doesn't Lex Luthor regularly keep up and go toe to toe with Shazam and Wonder Woma? Iron Man also isn't even on Hulk or Thor's level technically speaking. Braniac is also technically stronger than Superman, but he does have a tendency to not go all out for plot reasons.
 
DarkDragonMedeus said:
Doesn't Lex Luthor regularly keep up and go toe to toe with Shazam and Wonder Woma? Iron Man also isn't even on Hulk or Thor's level technically speaking. Braniac is also technically stronger than Superman, but he does have a tendency to not go all out for plot reasons.
Click to expand...
I have yet to see Lex take on Shazam and wonderwom without the aid of prep. What do you mean? Tony's Hulk Buster has decent feats against the Hulk and his model prime suit even hurt fin fang foom.
 
Hulk held back severely throughout the fight, and Lex Luthor's Warsuit makes him physically comparable to them as well as able to somewhat fight against Darkseid's avatars. Fin Fang Foom is a legit feat, but Hulk and Thor are both way stronger than IM or FFF.
 
Let me summarise Sorvoe551 's scale first. Correct me anyhow.

TLDR
Great research we actually need SA to do this
Akuma vs Shang Tsung: Correct then, correct now. Reasoning kind of made sense, even the "plot" of the fight did. Animation 6/10

Goomba vs Koopa: Don't know, don't care, it was a joke. Animation 3/10

Mike Haggar vs Zangief: These two are basically equal since they're in the same universe, so their idea that Zangief's experience would win him out makes sense (Mike's the mayor, not really a combatant anymore) Animation 7/10

TMNT Battle Royale. Right outcome, reasoning was sound. Animation 6/10

Chun-Li vs Mai Shiranui: Correct outcome, decent reasoning. Animation 7/10

Felicia vs Taokaka: Felicia doesn't have a page here, but based on how low Felicia is on the Darkstalker totem pole, I think the fight is correct. Animation 7/10

Master Chief vs Doomguy: Halo 3 Chief vs Doomguy (not Doomslayer), yeah it would be close, but their reasons for Chief would be correct, since Doomguy's strategy basically makes him a Brute. Animation 6/10-He-Man vs Lion-O: Accurate result, really enjoyable fight dialogue. Animation 8/10

Shao Khan vs M. Bison: It would be close, but once Shao Khan start's eating Bison's soul, it would be over. Animation 6/10

Fox McCloud vs Bucky O'Hare: We don't have info on Bucky, but I agreed with their analysis. Animation 6/10

Pokémon Battle Royale: Considering their rules and the probability they showed at the end, it made sense to me that Blastoise would win most of the time. Animation 9/10

Batman vs Captain America: While Cap hits a lot harder, I think their argument for the smarter and more skilled Bats could win. It's up in the air for me. Animation 7/10

Ryu vs Scorpion: Correct outcome, finding out "Cooking with Scorpion" exists was great. Animation 7/10 (Anyone else think Scorpion looked off?)

Deadpool vs Deathstroke: Correct outcome, amazing fight, loved Takahata as Wade. Animation 9/10

Chuck Norris vs Segata Sanshiro: Since we have no info on either of them and the idea of their characters, the way it went was the only acceptable answer. Ridiculously awesome fight. Animation 9/10

Beast vs Goliath: We don't have info for Goliath, so I'd say their argument makes sense. Really boring fight. Animation 5/10

Iron Man vs Lex Luthor: Correct outcome, unless the Warsuit absolutely wrecked his base armor immediately. Once Hulkbuster's out though, it goes like they showed. Animation 9/10

Solid Snake vs Sam Fisher: Accurate, great fight, loved the pacing and Christopher ************* Sabat as Snake. Animation 9/10

Darth Vader vs Doctor Doom: Accurate, entertaining fight. Found out Doom is way more overpowered then I thought. Animation 6/10

Hercule Satan vs Dan Hibiki: Fun battle of the losers. Although Hercule's durability should be upped because he took a pimp slap from Cell and lived, but whatever. Animation 7/10 (Hercule's model always seemed choppy and rough to me)

Ratchet & Clank vs Jak & Daxter: This was the one battle I was super pissed at until I read up on this site. Jak & Dax are my boys, but I get why they lost. Animation 7/10

Ken vs Terry: Close fight, their analysis made sense to me. Animation 7/10

Hulk vs Doomsday: Since these guys are pretty much equal, the idea that Doomsday could wear him down made sense. Animation 8/10 (That Hulk model was as ugly as the MvC ones)

Naruto vs Ichigo: Absolutely correct. Awesome pixel art for Ichigo's newer forms. Animation 9/10

Doctor Strange vs Doctor Fate: Fun fight, analysis seemed better than their usual affair. Animation 8/10

Thanos vs Darkseid: Yep, completely accurate, even their research was spot on. Animation 8/10 (I really didn't like Thanos' Fortnite model)

Screwattack as expected

Zitz vs Leonardo: Stomp only because the 4Kids timeline existed at the time of the video. Animation 5/10

Yoshi vs Riptor: Huuuuuge stomp, funny fight animation. Animation 4/10.

Kratos vs Spawn: Considering at the time it would have been GoW3 Kratos vs Hell King Spawn, I'd say it was about right, but would have been a really long fight. Considering only holy weapon decapitation can kill Spawn and his suit feeds off Kratos' sins, he should be able to outlast him. Animation 2/10

Luke Skywalker vs Harry Potter: Holy shit, what a stomp (even in the fight, Harry only hit Luke twice) Animation 6/10

Starscream vs Rainbow Dash: We have two profiles for Starscream, none of which really matter for this fight, but she would still be stronger and faster than him since he's cannon fodder. Animation 5/10

Zelda vs Peach: Peach stomps hard, so they were right. Animation 5/10

Thor vs Raiden: Even they recognized it was a stomp. Animation 6/10

Ivy Valentine vs Black Orchid: Orchid stomps, even the fight showed that Ivy couldn't really keep her down. Animation 7/10

Fulgore vs Sektor: Massive stomp for Fulgore, they were right. Animation 6/10

Godzilla vs Gamera: 4-B Composite Gojira vs 7-A Gam-Gam. Hmmmm... Animation 8/10 (Love that dropkick leading to surfing on a turtle)

Terminator vs RoboCop: The T-850 (9-A) vs an 8-C Alex Murphy. Super fun fight to watch. Animation 8/10

Green Arrow vs Hawkeye: Yep, purple wins and steals your girl. Animation 8/10

Pokémon vs Digimon: Yep, my childhood was brutally murdered and absolutely deserved to be: Animation 8/10

Flash vs Quicksilver: Conclusion: no shit. Animation 6/10

Joker vs Sweet Tooth: Someone who can keep up with and outsmart Batman against a psycho ice cream man. Hm... Animation 8/10

Tracer vs Scout: Went exactly how I thought it would. Animation 8/10

Amy Rose vs Ramona Flowers: Holy shit speed stomp. Animation 7/10

Venom vs Bane: Yep, a stomp like they said it'd be. Animation 7/10

Power Rangers vs Voltron: While we don't have a profile for the original Voltron, even the 2016 one is so much stronger than the Dino Megazord, though it's a lot slower. It'd probably go as it was shown. Animation 8/10 (Loved the Voltron voice cast of MatPat, PeanutButterGamer, Lanipator, and KaiserNeko)

Natsu vs Ace: Man who eats fire eats man who is fire. Shocking. Animation: 7/10

Metal Sonic vs Zero: Yeah, Game Metal is absolutely destroyed by Zero and Comic Metal is beat once Zero stops time. Animation 8/10

Balrog vs TJ Combo: Stomp all around. Despite the downplay, their analysis was pretty good. Fun math to see. Animation 8/10 (Balrog's model was ugly as sin)

Shredder vs Silver Samurai: Since it was composite Shredder, it was more of an even "first hit wins" fight. I thought their analysis made sense. Animation 8/10

Smokey the Bear vs McGruff the Crime Dog: Bear murders dog. In other news, the sky is blue. Decent hand animation. Weird style, but it was energetic at least. Also Chris Sabat and Chris Rager killed it. Animation 8/10

Black Panther vs Batman: Don't you hate it when nigh-invulnerable armor keeps you from beating a man? Animation 8/10 (Batman is a weeb and I love it)

Raven vs Twilight Sparkle: Really close, but friendship can't save you from giant murder bird. Animation 8/10

Leon Kennedy vs Frank West: Yep, superhuman zombie killer defeats duct tape survivor pretty easily. Animation 6/10

Samurai Jack vs Afro Samurai: Yeah, Jack stomps pretty handily. Animation 9/10 (really good handdrawn animation)

Optimus Prime vs Gundam: Oh that poor Japanese teenager. Animation 9/10 (kickass fight music)

Crash vs Spyro: Yeah, Legend Spyro destroys Composite Crash with a beam that can rip apart molecules. Shocking. Animation 7/10 (My boy Edward Bosco as Spyro was great. Love him on The Unexpectables)

Sora vs Pit: You know what, this fight's validity flip flops so often, I don't care anymore. The analysis was okay, they got Deku to be Pit, so I'm happy. Animation 7/10

Ultron vs Sigma: Sure, they downplayed Sigma a bit, but it wouldn't have mattered. Animation 8/10

Roshi vs Jiraiya: Man who blew up moon beats man who can, but never did, destroy a mountain, surprising no one. Animation 7/10 (They still should have gotten Lanipator for Roshi)

Mega Man Battle Royale: .exe file who destroys universe for ***** and giggles murders four bad cosplays of him violently. Yep, sounds about right. Animation 9/10

Black Widow vs Widowmaker: Angry Russian whose best friend is the best sniper in the world murders Sniper Smurf. In all seriousness, I do believe that Natasha would defeat WM since she's used to fighting snipers, has better CQC, and has better gadgets. Animation 8/10

Research with controversial verdicts but cannot say it's wrong - or not

Mario vs Sonic: Since it was composite and Galaxy wasn't a thing yet, it was correct at the time. Animation 6/10

Batman vs Spider-Man: Considering it was a no prep-time fight, it was accurate. With prep, who knows? Animation 6/10

Luigi vs Tails: Close fight, but Tails hits harder, is regularly faster, and is way smarter. Animation 7/10

Wolverine vs Raiden: Is it wrong? Probably. Is it correct? Maybe. Do I care? God no. Animation 9/10

Meta vs Carolina: This site says it's wrong, but I personally bought their reasoning. Animation 8/10

Lara Croft vs Nathan Drake: Extremely close battle, but their analysis seemed to make sense. Fun fight, too bad Nathan looked terrible. Animation 8/10

Scrooge McDuck vs Shovel Knight: One of the weirdest themes that somehow worked. While SK is stronger, Scrooge is much faster and those gadgets of his screw over Shovel. Animation 7/10

Android 18 vs Captain Marvel: Guess it all depends on whether 18 destroys Carol before she goes Binary. Still, they got 18's voice actress from TFS, so that was good. Animation 7/10

Ryu vs Jin: This site says Jin wins, I say it's a 50/50 shot between the two. Animation 8/10

Carnage vs Lucy: I know lots of people say Carnage should win, especially Jasonsith, but I would still make an argument that she could win with her durability-ignoring vectors and the fact she can cause a nuclear explosion and boil his blood. Animation 7/10

Nightwing vs Daredevil: Even this website says it's a coin toss, like they did. I believe that Nightwing could figure out Daredevil's weaknesses and exploit them. Animation 0/10. Cinematography 8/10

Mario vs Sonic 2: This Time, It's Personal: Yeah, as much as I hate to admit it, Mario would win when using purely the games. Animation 8/10 (they picked a good animation studio)

Research with room for improvement but still having a right verdict

Boba Fett vs Samus Aran: Completely wrong, weak reasoning, started the whole thing off. Animation 4/10

Link vs Cloud: They are probably correct, but their reasoning was super flimsy. Animation 6/10

Ragna vs Sol Badguy: Both extremely downplayed, and unless the True BlazBlue existed in 2015, it was correct. Animation 7/10 (Would be 9/10 if the ending didn't look awful)

Kirby vs Majin Buu: Correct, despite the downgrading. Animation 8/10

Boba vs Samus 2, Electric Boogaloo: Still technically correct, still bad research. Animation 9/10

Mega Man vs Astro Boy: Only works because of Omega Factor AB. Both were extremely downplayed. Animation 8/10

Lucario vs Renamon: Incredibly downplayed, but accurate. Brutal ending, highly approve of it. Animation 6/10

Thor vs Wonder Woman: Thor was downplayed and Wonder Woman had minimum wank. Animation was super rough. Animation 6/10

Sephiroth vs Vergil: Correct, but majorly downplayed for both. At least the voice actors were good. Animation 8/10

Jotaro vs Kenshiro: Correct outcome, both extremely downplayed, the one thing that would have let JoJo win was something he never uses in combat. Animation 8/10 (They nailed Kenshiro's eyebrows)

Aquaman vs Namor: Accurate, but they downplayed both. While they trimmed Aquaman with wool shears, they just cut off Namor's legs with a chainsaw. Animation 8/10 (Again, loved Todd Haberkorn as Namor. Always love that guy)

Research with horribly wrong verdict and reasons

Rogue vs Wonder Woman: Really wrong, I don't even think Diana would notice Rogue stealing her power before she murdered her. Animation 5/10

Bomberman vs Dig Dug: Extremely wrong, weak reasoning. Animation 3/10

Vegeta vs Shadow: Once Shadow went Super, it would have been over. Animation 5/10

Dr. Eggman vs Dr. Wily: Bass would have murdered everyone before Metal could become Metal Overlord Animation 7/10

Pikachu vs Blanka: They used anime Pikachu, so Blanka would be blitzed. Animation 3/10

Goku vs Superman: With SSJ4, Superman would have been completely destroyed. Animation 8/10

Ryu Hayabusa vs Strider Hiryu: While Strider can run faster and Ryu at base is weaker, the True Dragon Sword would destroy Hiryu immediately. Animation 7/10

Tigerzord vs Gundam Epyon: Wrong, Tigerzord hits way harder and is ridiculously faster. I doubt the Epyon system could make up for that gap. Reason the fight started was hilarious. Animation 7/10

Gaara vs Toph: Gaara hits a lot harder, but otherwise I thought an argument could be made for Toph winning. Seriously, how often does Gaara use anything besides his sand? Animation 7/10

Guts vs Nightmare: While extremely wrong, I have a soft spot for it because it introduced me to my favorite manga ever. Animation 8/10

Goku vs Superman 2, The Revenge: Still wrong, still bad research. Animation 9/10

Donkey Kong vs Knuckles: Completely wrong, and I'm going to get on my soap box real quick: KNUCKLES ISN'T STUPID, AT ALL! HE'S JUST GULLIBLE BECAUSE HE LIVES ALONE ON AN ISLAND, HIS DAD TAUGHT HIM **** ALL THEN JUMPED INTO ANOTHER DIMENSION, AND THE FIRST PERSON WHO HE EVER INTERACTED WITH STOLE HIS LIFE'S CALLING AND CONVINCED HIM TO TRY AND MURDER SOMEONE! HE'S NOT THE ONE FROM SONIC BOOM, THAT SHOW CAN **** ALL THE WAY OFF! Okay, I'm done. Animation 6/10 (DK looked creepy)

Yang vs Tifa: HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA...NOPE! Animation 8/10

Dante vs Bayonetta: Yes, I know it's wrong and including the partners was dumb, but God I love this episode. The fight is so entertaining. Animation 9/10

Bowser vs Ganon: Again, wrong, but the fight was funny at least. Animation 7/10

Mewtwo vs Shadow: Bullshit all the way. Knew it then, know it now. Animation 6/10

Cammy vs Sonya: Wrong, but good matchup idea at least. Animation 7/10

Zora vs Erza: Wrong, despite my initial thoughts. Amazing fight ending. Animation 8/10

Deadpool vs Pinkie Pie: Fun joke, but Pinkie would have slapped Wade into a puddle. Animation 8/10

Sub-Zero vs Glacius: Huh, they were wrong. Didn't know that until I looked it up a few minutes ago. Animation 7/10

Batman Beyond vs Spider-Man 2099: Extremely wrong, but at least Todd Haberkorn was a fun Miguel O'Hara. Animation 7/10
 
BTW, they don't pointed out how Starscream could hurt and survive Megatron hits, who survive an explosion that have 9 Exatons of energy, aka High 6-A. While we don't have a profile for him (yet) he has shown that he can hurt Megatron, who is capable of that. Not sure if RD was in a higher tier at the time, but they are right about the speed gap, though Starscream can possibly outlast Rainbow in stamina
 
I really don't see Pokemon Battle Royale as legit. Blastoise's shell has never been as OP as it was in that DB and Venusaur easily could have ended Blastoise. And Charizard, wouldn't just forget that Blastoise is a thing either. Venusaur could have killed Blastoise and got killed by Charizard. Charizard could have gotten killed by Blastoise and Venusaur could have killed Blastoise. Blastoise has the best bulk of the 3, but evidence from the games and anime and manga proves that Blastoise's shell can be very easily overcome. Especially by a Grass type. Even if we go at their peak, Charizard's can damage a Blastoise easily. This is not even mentioning Dragon Rage or Venusaur's Leech Seed or Poisonpowder.
 
I agree, Charizard should have been the victor for that battle royale. Blastoise's defense was exaggerated, and could have easily been bypass by Venusaur's durability negating abilities. And Charizard's speed/mobility should have enabled him to dodge Blastoise' attacks if he retaliated, as well as blitz the other two.
 
They didn't allow TMs or HMs, but they didn't really need Sunny day.
 
They weren't terribly wrong, though. With their battle tactics, it would have ended that way. Charizard was too tired out to beat Blastoise, and he was chilling the whole time. Think of them as Raphael and Leonardo.
 
Anyway, since I just finished by Post-Crisis Batman revision I can probably fix Lex Luthor's File relatively quick.
 
TitanCrusher101 said:
They weren't terribly wrong, though. With their battle tactics, it would have ended that way. Charizard was too tired out to beat Blastoise, and he was chilling the whole time. Think of them as Raphael and Leonardo.
Click to expand...
No it wouldn't. Pokemon battle tactics cannot truly be assumed. Venusaur can just as easily use PoisonPowder or Stun Spore. Not just Sleep Power. The only reason Blastoise was chilling was due to Sleep Powder. Charizard could just as easily go after Blastoise while he was sleep and abuse his air mobility. He learns Air Slash by level up and thus does not have only fire, but a blade of air that he can launch.
 
Remember how with the Pokemon Battle Royale, they explicitly said that because of the nature of Pokemon, the fight could have gone over 7,000 ways and that Blastoise won the majority? There are scenarios where both Charizard and Venasaur could have won
 
@Jasonsith

Yeah, pretty much. Since this list is about accuracy, I'd say the research factor comes first and then the animation helps break ties
 
I have my reasons already stated to why Starscream vs RD don't have a right veridict, since they used only their base on that fight
 
Sorvoe551 said:
Remember how with the Pokemon Battle Royale, they explicitly said that because of the nature of Pokemon, the fight could have gone over 7,000 ways and that Blastoise won the majority? There are scenarios where both Charizard and Venasaur could have wo
Click to expand...
Issue is, I want to see these scenarios and this "majority". They did not show this hence the issue. They can say "this can go this many ways", but that's heresay without showing us this. And I doubt they really went over 7000 ways for this one fight.
 
Considering the massive movepools and move combinations to factor into this on top of their abilities, the vastly differing personalities of the pokemon in question, and environmental conditions, the fact that they ONLY had 7000 different ways this could have ended is kinda unrealistic. There would be millions of ways that fight could have played out
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

TMaakkonen
DEATH BATTLE! Accuracy Scale [Part 10, The more things change, the more they stay the same]
15 16 17
Replies
672
Views
55K
TMaakkonen
TMaakkonen
EnderLord8
The King of Death and Deathwing vs Composite God Slayer and Weiss Schnee
Replies
18
Views
754
DaReaperMan
DaReaperMan
EnderLord8
Angel of Darkness and Jack The Ripper VS Composite God Slayer and Weiss Schnee
2
Replies
43
Views
2K
azontr
azontr
EnderLord8
Master Adaptoid Supreme and An Character? vs Composite God Slayer and Weiss Schnee
Replies
38
Views
2K
EnderLord8
EnderLord8
TitanCrusher101
DEATHBATTLE! Accuracy Scale [Part 3] | Part 4: https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Thread:3692177
11 12 13
Replies
491
Views
11K
Unoriginal_Memes
Unoriginal_Memes
Back
Top