- 15,614
- 7,054
I thought Eficiente hadn't voted yet?
Regardless, this is pretty clearly still being discussed.
Regardless, this is pretty clearly still being discussed.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
ShakeResounding
He/Him- 7,996
- 6,248
Last thing I wanna do is play the "FRA" game, but... Jesus. I've read through this thread for the past ten minutes and I can't say anything that hasn't already been argued or brought up.
Chara FRA.
Chara FRA.
- 8,668
- 2,780
I agree with Azyy on that one, this is still being debated and with some good arguments the votes may change.
- 47
- 2
Chara FRA.
- 47
- 2
9-10 I think.
- 15,431
- 5,023
No idea who the hell Eficient or Efficiente is, but I never voted anyone before my previous vote.The Wright Way said:
- 3,642
- 258
current score right now?
- 3,642
- 258
did you place a vote yet, btw? just curiousWokistan said:
- 26,160
- 3,652
Why not make this more inconclusive? Switching to Chara fra.
- 1,867
- 36
alright inconcoming
- 26,160
- 3,652
Remove my vote for gira.
- 1,867
- 36
I cant i didnt rite the votes
- 26,160
- 3,652
I meant nicc, he added me to both.
- 3,642
- 258
Ricsi-viragosi said:
- facepalm*
- 26,160
- 3,652
I don't see why chara can't slap giratina till he dies?Epsilon R said:
- 63,522
- 8,487
There is literally zero reasons for GiratinaEpsilon R said:
Zero
He can't interact or hit Chara, or affect him
- 6,011
- 2,117
Wew
too many comment, lazy to read everything
too many comment, lazy to read everything
- 3,642
- 258
This thread has dragged on for quite some elongated time because one side got gassed up more than the other side to the point where there was a separate thread for the former. At this point, in my opinion, I'd close the thread and call it inconclusive or a win for Giratina, preferably the former at this point.Epsilon R said:
- 63,522
- 8,487
There is literally zero reasons for Giratina
Zero
He can't interact or hit Chara, or affect him
Why?
I already said why
Giratina can't even interact with him
@Dragon Why would Giratina win when there are zero reasons he does?
Zero
He can't interact or hit Chara, or affect him
Why?
I already said why
Giratina can't even interact with him
@Dragon Why would Giratina win when there are zero reasons he does?
- 8,375
- 3,043
AP and interacting with Dialga and Palkia Wait, if they can interact with each other, why don't these guys have Concept manip?
- 3,642
- 258
There is literally zero reasons for Giratina
Zero
He can't interact or hit Chara, or affect him
Why?
I already said why
Giratina can't even interact with him
@Dragon Why would Giratina win when there are zero reasons he does?
Why isn't this a STOMP, then? If Giratina supposedly can't do anything or even touch Chara, then by Versus Thread rules, the matchup is automatically a Stomp, cause one particular side can't do anything to the other.
Zero
He can't interact or hit Chara, or affect him
Why?
I already said why
Giratina can't even interact with him
@Dragon Why would Giratina win when there are zero reasons he does?
Why isn't this a STOMP, then? If Giratina supposedly can't do anything or even touch Chara, then by Versus Thread rules, the matchup is automatically a Stomp, cause one particular side can't do anything to the other.
- 63,522
- 8,487
They can't
That's the entire discussion above between Azzy and Cal
That's the entire discussion above between Azzy and Cal
- 3,642
- 258
Whhhhhhhhhhhhhheeeelllpp. That's unfortunate, I guess. This kind of situation isn't too unfamiliar to me when my GS vs Violet Evergarden thread was closed as a Stomp despite them being 9B, due to former having far more AP and thus being mostly "untouchable" to the latter.
- 4,594
- 2,429
If you forgot which is very normal in Pokémon Multiverse the fact that normal as Togekiss, Typhlosion and others Pokémon can touch and harm non-physical beings like Gengar, Haunter and Ghastly, and Giratina is capable of touch Chara, that is, at least research before you say anythingSchnee One said:
- 26,160
- 3,652
Aren't all those, well, ghosts?
Chara has no soul, so hitting does means nothing.
Chara has no soul, so hitting does means nothing.
- 1,867
- 36
Its beeen going lon g enuf. can we do dis inconclusive?
- 3,642
- 258
I wish that was easier said than done :/Inksaness said:
- 1,867
- 36
... yee
- 3,642
- 258
Looked up Chara's profile again, and here's what I saw in Durability:
"(Completely unaffected by their own destruction of the game, Exists as an abstract concept that will be brought back as long as someone with enough Determination exists), likely much higher (Ability to SAVE and LOAD makes them extremely difficult to destroy even in physical form. In their true form, Chara exists as an abstract concept capable of manifesting no matter what as long as someone experiences the drive, will, and feelings they embody, thus making them nearly impossible to actually destroy or get rid of)."
"As long as"?
I thought this was 1 v 1. Or does Determination and SOUL apply to Giratina as well? Even though it's an existence not from the Undertales verse? I don't remember if this was mentioned already, but SOULs and Determination are mentioned to be applied to humans and monsters from the verse. According to the Undertales wiki (which I may admit, might not be 100% accurate), monsters in the Undertales verse are weaker than humans because they're mostly made of magic. I can't imagine Giratina being treated as a normal Monster, or even a normal entity, if it enters the Underground. Also, idk about how a SOUL from an entity existing on a near conceptual level would be handled the same way.
"(Completely unaffected by their own destruction of the game, Exists as an abstract concept that will be brought back as long as someone with enough Determination exists), likely much higher (Ability to SAVE and LOAD makes them extremely difficult to destroy even in physical form. In their true form, Chara exists as an abstract concept capable of manifesting no matter what as long as someone experiences the drive, will, and feelings they embody, thus making them nearly impossible to actually destroy or get rid of)."
"As long as"?
I thought this was 1 v 1. Or does Determination and SOUL apply to Giratina as well? Even though it's an existence not from the Undertales verse? I don't remember if this was mentioned already, but SOULs and Determination are mentioned to be applied to humans and monsters from the verse. According to the Undertales wiki (which I may admit, might not be 100% accurate), monsters in the Undertales verse are weaker than humans because they're mostly made of magic. I can't imagine Giratina being treated as a normal Monster, or even a normal entity, if it enters the Underground. Also, idk about how a SOUL from an entity existing on a near conceptual level would be handled the same way.
- 26,160
- 3,652
He has no DT.
That does not matter for chara's immortality because frisk is around, and the dude is pretty hard to kill.
And let's not even talk about The Anomaly.
That does not matter for chara's immortality because frisk is around, and the dude is pretty hard to kill.
And let's not even talk about The Anomaly.
- 3,642
- 258
So this is really 3 v 1Ricsi-viragosi said:
LMAO
- 26,160
- 3,652
Yep. Chara has this nice thing about taking control over people and all.
- 3,642
- 258
and I thought this was supposed to be a fair 1 v 1 with no one else involved....RIPRicsi-viragosi said:
yea, more reason for me to believe this thread shouldn't drag on any further. Apparently, Chara can never be included in a match without a third party involved, even with SBA.
- 63,522
- 8,487
Comparing Ghosts to an abstract idea?
Yes, I did research, did you?
Yes, I did research, did you?
- 40,457
- 12,924
I'm still completely against Chara being an abstract idea. Hell, if we wanna get to "Giratina can't affect abstracts", neither can Chara. Giratina's an abstract too.
