A certain Magical Index vs One piece

[Dekoshu]

Let's reach a conclusion in a way that doesn't mention "plot armor", or any other literary terms or anything of internet slang or shortening the words, shall we? I think we can also agree in layman's terms, that Touma's side overwhelmingly wins against Luffy's side and we, not just me, made it clear on why they win. Remember, no internet slang. Superior abilities that go beyond simply blasting their opponents (durability negation, effortlessly bypasses convenient durability), an ability that involves exploiting the bloodthirstiness of any opponent that isn't immune to it, an ability that involves making their opponents' favorite weapons useless and if overspecialized in the weapons and not much else, they're more likely to get defeated or killed even sooner, etc. You get where I'm going with this?

 

[LazyHunter]

I think it's pretty obvious they are outclassed in terms of hax here, and the few of us who have contributed to the thread seem to agree on that. Either nobody is willing to argue about One Piece's chances here or most likely they don't care about this match since Toaru is not a super popular verse like Naruto or Bleach, two matchups which would probably attract more attention than One Piece vs Toaru.

 

[Dekoshu]

Well...simply put, and I am fully aware of all the possibilities, Luffy and the other aren't going to defeat/kill everyone from the other side who fought people with annoying things before, especially if the latter (Index's/Touma's side) have abilities that show how serious they are that they don't want to have a needlessly long, pointless match. Instead of simply having a long, pointless fight where they should know regular guns and normal physical blows aren't going to cut it, what are they going to do? They don't literally "hack/hax" with computers. They don't want to laugh for too long and monologue, knowing they would get some Busoshoku Haki-enhanced blows if they aren't watching. They make their enemy's defining characteristics no good here. They're fully hostile and want to kill them right away? This is where going all out that way in certain ways can make it even worse, by using it against them (Divine Punishment or some other means). They can overpower Luffy and the others in one way or another, and it's clear where this is going. In other words, Luffy's side has limited to no chance against their enemies here.

 

[Aurasuke]

Now that I think about it Vento's divine puishment is pretty op lol. She kind of single handedly defeated anti-skill. The only reason she kind of lost was due to Kazikiri and Touma's convienient presence.

BTW did anyone else notice that Vento had kind of saved Accelerator and Index from Kihara's rocket launcher? Did she do that on purpose or by accident lol.

If i were to guess, Academy city would probably respond with technology first, though the numbers may not be in their favor, technology would give them an edge in terms of destructive output. Then again I just realized how OP Index's dragon breath is.

The main problem is that one piece will be using ancient guns vs railgun model cases. Still in such a battle, I can't see Academy City coming out unscathed, even if they are ancient, cannons are cannons, and they don't really discriminate against high tech buildings/labs. I suppose the average magician is stronger than the average pirate.

The only real advantage One Piece has is speed and AP for their top tiers. Still with the massive gap in technology, those HsB bombers will make a huge difference.

 

[Dekoshu]

Overpowering enemies not only by brute force, but outwitting them with intelligence as well...and of course, they have actual technology, not just their superhuman abilities.

 

[DontTalk]

Ok, so are we finished with the thread now or something?

If we just further list the reasons why toaru wins, without anyone arguing back, this will just become more and more spite.

 

[Dekoshu]

Yes. We need to finish this and have it locked if necessary.

 

[Aurasuke]

lol, I also notice that no one in one piece reallly does fatal attacks, they just get knocked out most of the time. (or at least if they do die it dosn't get too messy, the exact opposite of Akame ga kill lol)

It's funny though how Academy city is probably the most imprenetrable fortress and could probably easy take on the rest of the world excluding the magic side. Even High Priest wasn't able to destroy it despite being a magic god. And niang just so happened to get caught by world rejecter lol.