- 1,056
- 619
Do not derail
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
there is a current staff thread reviewing this. you can check it outI never found this particularly convincing either tbh.
Also, last I checked, we were only calculating the dimension being recreated because the destruction bit was EE, right? Or did the standards on that change while I was away.
I don't think this is the same logic.Funny, I was just considering making a thread that uses the ‘Destroy the Sun from the Earth’ calc to upgrade the ETSB, but you beat me to it
Please linkthere is a current staff thread reviewing this. you can check it out
I’m aware, I just had my own idea for 4-B, but this also works is all I’m sayingI don't think this is the same logic.
Please link
Lets finish up this CRT first then you can create another one to tackle that part.Wouldn't Kaguya telekinesis scale to it ? She is literally holding ETSO the size of a solar system
I was just asking a question based on what we already know.Lets finish up this CRT first then you can create another one to tackle that part.
I was just asking a question based on what we already know.
As far as I'm aware the current interpretation for ETSO is not that it explodes as there's no evidence that it does so. Instead we go by the interpretation that the TSO completely engulfs the dimension which destroys it and then the TSO recreated it.The Databook is talking about the power contained inside the orb, that when it explodes, can destroy the dimension.
Like I said previously, idrc. It's on OP to justify the mechanics of the jutsu.
Edit: @DavidTPPM do your job.
Yall know you can't tag other members right? You should have DMed me instead
David, please come and address these issues..
I know I can't ping you. I was under the impression that you would be checkingYall know you can't tag other members right? You should have DMed me instead
No that's the diameter. The diameter of the dimension is the distance between the planet and sun + the size of the planets (I ignored the planets and suns size since they would do like a 0.001% difference lmao).I have a question. Correct me if I'm wrong, but the planet to star distance should be the radius right? Why is half of it the radius in your calc? The yield should be 8x above what it is.
Why would that be the diameter? The star needs to be at the center of the dimension and the planet needs to revolve around it. Otherwise the planet will get sucked in due to gravitational pull from the star.No that's the diameter. The diameter of the dimension is the distance between the planet and sun + the size of the planets (I ignored the planets and suns size since they would do like a 0.001% difference lmao).
But the formula for volume uses radius so I had to divide the diameter by 2.
Oh yeah that makes sense. Especially given how the ice dimension was shown to have a day night cycle meaning the dimensions aren't just stationary.Why would that be the diameter? The star needs to be at the center of the dimension and the planet needs to revolve around it. Otherwise the planet will get sucked in due to gravitational pull from the star.
Why haven't we given her a rating for this?She can, but I think it counts towards Environmental Destruction or something like that.
We probably should.Why haven't we given her a rating for this?
Personally I think using the blatant statement of her having enough power to destroy the dimension is the most straightforward approach but since that seems to have been rejected in the past because we don't know if she actually blows up her dimension, this should be the best alternativeI am pretty much neutral to the method. On a glance it seems fine, but I would like to see counters from knowledgeable members.
This one's just high-key Kishimoto's fault tbf. Calling it the Expansive Truth Seeking Ball, and saying that it's continuously expanding is kind of a shot in the foot for the whole "it explodes" idea.but since that seems to have been rejected in the past because we don't know if she actually blows up her dimension
Does EE erase space? Or just matter.This one's just high-key Kishimoto's fault tbf. Calling it the Expansive Truth Seeking Ball, and saying that it's continuously expanding is kind of a shot in the foot for the whole "it explodes" idea.
Yeaaah that's why I'm not exactly fighting the idea rn. But if we go with that interpretation my calculation should be perfectly usable.This one's just high-key Kishimoto's fault tbf. Calling it the Expansive Truth Seeking Ball, and saying that it's continuously expanding is kind of a shot in the foot for the whole "it explodes" idea.
Yeah, EE can potentially apply to anything if the story specifies, even concepts and other crazy stuff.Does EE erase space? Or just matter.
Edit: Nvm. Just checked. It's not just matter.
If we are not going to award it a quality from the standard TSO aka being an explosive, then I don't think we should give it the same restrictions as a standard TSO so the EE should be removed no? Or am I missing somethingThis one's just high-key Kishimoto's fault tbf. Calling it the Expansive Truth Seeking Ball, and saying that it's continuously expanding is kind of a shot in the foot for the whole "it explodes" idea.
Nobody is saying it can't explode. Slayer is saying it casts doubt on the notion that it was gonna destroy the dimension by exploding instead of expanding. It can do both. We just don't know which one it was gonna do.If we are not going to award it a quality from the standard TSO aka being an explosive, then I don't think we should give it the same restrictions as a standard TSO so the EE should be removed no? Or am I missing something
You are missing something.If we are not going to award it a quality from the standard TSO aka being an explosive, then I don't think we should give it the same restrictions as a standard TSO so the EE should be removed no? Or am I missing something
What do you think of the proposal in the OP?You are missing something.
Nobody is taking away from the ETSB's qualities. It is objectively the same as a regular TSB. This isn't up for discussion.
But the fact is nobody actually knows how it was going to destroy the dimension. However, my interpretation has some support to it. Yours has none. Which is why mine is the widely accepted interpretation, and yours is not.
The idea that if a fist sized TSB has forest level energy, then a Sun sized one has 4-B energy? I think it's fine in theory, but I'm kinda waiting for the opposition to make their arguments before I commit to an official vote.What do you think of the proposal in the OP?
Btw its theoritical final size is way bigger than Sun(doesnt really matter, just saying)The idea that if a fist sized TSB has forest level energy, then a Sun sized one has 4-B energy? I think it's fine in theory, but I'm kinda waiting for the opposition to make their arguments before I commit to an official vote.
I know, I was just oversimplifying the premise.Btw its theoritical final size is way bigger than Sun(doesnt really matter, just saying)
Fallacies. I will take my time to attack this.I don't have a lot of time to commit to the thread right now; in a nutshell though I just don't buy the premise that because a Truth-Seeking Orb of a certain size contains a certain amount of power (a laughably low forest-busting amount) that means that means we can assume anything made of "Truth-Seeking Orb" substance contains a proportional amount of power to size. So assuming that Kaguya creating an Expansive Truth-Seeking Orb with an assumed radius 149 million kilometers over an assumed timeframe of 15 years means that she'd be constantly outputting Brown Dwarf Star levels of chakra or Attack Potency every second.... (Which happens to be a level of power never displayed by anyone else in the verse before or after this by a considerable margin)
All in all, there seem to be too many assumptions to me for it to be workable.
I don't have a lot of time to commit to the thread right now; in a nutshell though I just don't buy the premise that because a Truth-Seeking Orb of a certain size contains a certain amount of power (a laughably low forest-busting amount) that means that means we can assume anything made of "Truth-Seeking Orb" substance contains a proportional amount of power to size. So assuming that Kaguya creating an Expansive Truth-Seeking Orb with an assumed radius 149 million kilometers over an assumed timeframe of 15 years means that she'd be constantly outputting Brown Dwarf Star levels of chakra or Attack Potency every second.... (Which happens to be a level of power never displayed by anyone else in the verse before or after this by a considerable margin)
All in all, there seem to be too many assumptions to me for it to be workable.