STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

[CosmicWreck]

To be honest, I never understood Garou's feat with the black hole in this chapter. An explosion from a combination of gravitational brass knuckles and nuclear decay covered IO and briefly swallowed all the light?

Was someone talking about a black hole in this chapter? This kind of seems like it's coming out of nowhere but you're talking like it's a forgone conclusion that we've discussed before

The presence of a black hole near Jupiter should have destroyed it, but even on IO there was no destruction. Or did he create this black hole somewhere very far away?

Bringing enough geothermal energy to warp the plates should have been enough to do more damage to the planet than what was seen there. A gamma ray burst so close should have been more than enough to destroy the planet even if it didn't directly hit it. This is a common thing in fiction and thus these kinds of arguments ignore attack potency for destruction capacity which results in a type of fallacy in the argument.

And I also wonder why they used the calculation of a black hole for a gamma-ray burst, if the term black hole never appeared there?

It works on the assumption that Gamma ray bursts that are formed by evaporating black holes are being copied by Garou as evidenced by onscreen suctions of the surroundings surrounding the sphere. I honestly don't like it either.

To be fair, there was a calc for the actual gamma ray burst but the calculation member deleted it for unknown (and probably stupid tbh) reasons.

 

[RinneItachi]

Need a list of every series 3-B garou solos
this is very important

Coming back to this for a sec.

He solos almost any non-action series out there, obviously.

He could probably solo most mainstream anime. Demon Slayer shouldn't be mentioned, MHA would get obliterated, One Piece is a hard W for Garou, probably Fairy Tale but I've never seen it (I've just heard enough to say that they probably stand 0 chance), he should have enough hax in addition to the raw physical stat gap to solo the Naruto verse (I'd even say comfortably). Bleach, JoJo's, and JJK are too haxed, although an argument could still be made for Garou in regards to JJK, but only with verse equalization of course. Naturally, he shitstomps AoT, Death Note, and other fodder verses anywhere around those tiers. He could reasonably take most of DB out, stopping only around DBS in all likelihood.

With the exception of Dormammu, he probably solos the MCU, hard to say. Could likely solo any animated DC or Marvel series.

Naturally, he also solos all the verses you mentioned, such as The Boys and Invincible, and could do so easily.

At this point I'd place Garou as a mid-tier in fictional powerscaling, even without putting him as high as 3-B, albeit fairly on the low-end of mid-tier.

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

With the exception of Dormammu, he probably solos the MCU

The MCU has quite a few Tier 2s like Infinity Ultron and The Watcher. As well as Alioth. That and Arishem, who's 3-A.

 

[RinneItachi]

The MCU has quite a few Tier 2s like Infinity Ultron and The Watcher. As well as Alioth. That and Arishem, who's 3-A.

I know it's technically canon to the MCU but I don't usually count What-If when talking about the MCU. Don't know the last two.

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

I know it's technically canon to the MCU but I don't usually count What-If when talking about the MCU. Don't know the last two.

Alioth is from the Loki TV show. Basically a mindless 2-A beast but who's slow as **** (MHS+ lmao). And Arishem is the stongest Celestial from Eternals.

 

[RinneItachi]

Alioth is from the Loki TV show. Basically a mindless 2-A beast but who's slow as **** (MHS+ lmao). And Arishem is the stongest Celestial from Eternals.

Oh pog a Celestial actually shows up in Eternals? Is it a flashback thing or an actual active character? Cause I remember a Celestial planet wiping in GOTG but they never really got brought up after that iirc. The Living Tribunal also got referenced once in Doctor Strange. The MCU still has so much unexplored stuff to cover based on the source material, they've barely tapped into what Marvel has produced over the many years.

And yeah makes sense I missed those two. I haven't watched either show yet. I've mainly focused on the movies. The MCU movies have been great but I kinda lost faith in comic-book adapted reality shows, I only ever paid attention to the animated ones.

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

Oh pog a Celestial actually shows up in Eternals? Is it a flashback thing or an actual active character? Cause I remember a Celestial planet wiping in GOTG but they never really got brought up after that iirc. The Living Tribunal also got referenced once in Doctor Strange. The MCU still has so much unexplored stuff to cover based on the source material, they've barely tapped into what Marvel has produced over the many years.

Actual active character. He shows up in intro and at the end of the movie.

The one in GOTG is being revised currently. But normal MCU celestials are 4-C. I think Eternity is in Thor Love and Thunder but is featless afaik.

 

[Pepsiman25th]

Anything think the chapter will come out by Wednesday?

 

[RinneItachi]

Anything think the chapter will come out by Wednesday?

Probably. Nothing has suggested otherwise and Murata is popping off even more than usual lately. So not only will it probably be Wednesday again (Thursday for Murata), but it's probably gonna be an even bigger chapter than the regular ones.

 

[MarvelFanatic119]

I think Eternity is in Thor Love and Thunder but is featless afaik.

I think Eternity there would scale above all the gods in the MCU including the Celestials at least, as Gorr wanted to wish for him to wipe out all the gods and Thor was convinced Eternity could do that.

 

[Recon1511]

I was re-reading manga Garou vs Saitama and man, Saitama really is just ******* with him before Cosmic Garou.

He sees that Garou wanted to be a hero but instead of dissecting his ideology and giving him a reality check he just teases and makes fun of Garou further aggravating him. Saitama ends up being counterproductive with his lazy and careless approach.

This then results in God being able to trick Garou and Saitama only realizes his mistake when it's too late.

I actually really like it, the webcomic fight was about Garou but this one is about both, which doesn't mean the wc fight is any lesser mind you. I think next chapter might be the finale of the fight itself? Murata has done like 70+ pages already...

 

[Nehz_XZX]

Uh, slightly off topic, but should large size type 0 be added to Fuhrer Ugly's profile? He already looks twice the height of a normal human being before mutating and growing larger.

He does seem to be noticeably large.

 

[Epiccheev]

Garou can't solo Fairy Tail because Zeref exists.

 

[Kachon123]

Garou can't solo Fairy Tail because Zeref exists.

Stalemate

 

[RethPo]

Oh guys, I feel bad for you

Zhoniin's last Q&A

He debunked the feat

Cope + L + ratio + not based + didn't ask + don't care + malding + stay mad + skill issue + unfollowed + blocked + you fell off + cancelled + quote tweet + cry about it + seethe + pound sand + bad take + unsubbed + disliked + cope harder + spelling error + basic + tarnished + redpilled + bluepilled + triggered + the audacity + ok and? + touch grass

Saitama and garous punch just bent the light. The irrefutable bobsican argument

 

[Hajun]

You are repeating yourself and there is no point in being repetitive if the person you are talking to can still recall the first time you've said it just fine. The fact that I can see the first time you've said these almost exactly identical words just by scrolling up a little bit makes this even more redundant.

These are obviously rather extreme examples and show a certain degree stubbornness and a willingness to simply stretch logic to suit their purposes. People like that would most likely get their threads closed and if they display toxic behavior in their efforts to prove their opinions, get banned. I don't see any of that as a reason to make a joke and I feel like as if the only reason why you would make one in this situation would be to mock them. At the very least it's the only reason that I could personally think of and it makes me think that it would be a really obnoxious thing to do that would sour future interactions.

I did it with a rimuru fan now he is a good friend of mine not always they will your debating with will feel bad about their Statment is just being mock that has nothing to do with them it's just they think thier character win but mocking them will not harm them in anyway cause thier is nothing toxic in mocking their if they don't understand when you tell them about scaling and tiering just mock thier Statment thier is nothing bad about mocking someone Statment

 

[Hajun]

You are repeating yourself and there is no point in being repetitive if the person you are talking to can still recall the first time you've said it just fine. The fact that I can see the first time you've said these almost exactly identical words just by scrolling up a little bit makes this even more redundant.

These are obviously rather extreme examples and show a certain degree stubbornness and a willingness to simply stretch logic to suit their purposes. People like that would most likely get their threads closed and if they display toxic behavior in their efforts to prove their opinions, get banned. I don't see any of that as a reason to make a joke and I feel like as if the only reason why you would make one in this situation would be to mock them. At the very least it's the only reason that I could personally think of and it makes me think that it would be a really obnoxious thing to do that would sour future interactions.

I am not saying you mock his Statment right at the moment he said something wrong I said after explaining to him several times still didn't want to understand . Then just mock his statement and then give exaple if he said that Statment was wrong means if someone said tanjiro can win against Saitama for example ok and you explained to him several times about scaling then just say a normal human solos tanjiro if he said he can't then say then how can you think tanjiro can defeat Saitama with no feat just example ok.

 

[SuperStar]

I am not saying you mock his Statment right at the moment he said something wrong I said after explaining to him several times still didn't want to understand . Then just mock his statement and then give exaple if he said that Statment was wrong means if someone said tanjiro can win against Saitama for example ok and you explained to him several times about scaling then just say a normal human solos tanjiro if he said he can't then say then how can you think tanjiro can defeat Saitama with no feat just example ok.

Retype this bro

 

[Hajun]

Nah I can't pretty damn long and I am a lazy person

Retype this bro

 

[Hajun]

Will Saitama become 3A or low2C in the future?

 

[Nehz_XZX]

I did it with a rimuru fan now he is a good friend of mine not always they will your debating with will feel bad about their Statment is just being mock that has nothing to do with them it's just they think thier character win but mocking them will not harm them in anyway cause thier is nothing toxic in mocking their if they don't understand when you tell them about scaling and tiering just mock thier Statment thier is nothing bad about mocking someone Statment

Sorry, but that isn't my style and I still think that mocking someone is quite disrespectful which I'd rather not be. Mockery is per definition something quite negative.

I am not saying you mock his Statment right at the moment he said something wrong I said after explaining to him several times still didn't want to understand . Then just mock his statement and then give exaple if he said that Statment was wrong means if someone said tanjiro can win against Saitama for example ok and you explained to him several times about scaling then just say a normal human solos tanjiro if he said he can't then say then how can you think tanjiro can defeat Saitama with no feat just example ok.

If you want to give an example, then you can just do that, no jokes or mocking needed.

Will Saitama become 3A or low2C in the future?

That depends on his future feats which we can't know due to them occuring in the future and none of us having future sight as far as I'm aware.

 

[NikHelton]

I counted the moon jump and got High 1-C

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

I counted the moon jump and got High 1-C

Downplay

 

[DarthSpiderr]

I counted the moon jump and got High 1-C

This gives the ship durabl. This means that Boros in armor is possibly stronger than the cosmic Garou, and in blue form it is definitely stronger.

 

[Maitreya12]

Does anyone have a sandbox of what Garou’s current profile would look like along with all of his new powers and abilities?

I’m really curious to know just how much of a monster would be in vs battles now that he’s got a good amount of hax with him.

 

[Kachon123]

Does anyone have a sandbox of what Garou’s current profile would look like along with all of his new powers and abilities?

I’m really curious to know just how much of a monster would be in vs battles now that he’s got a good amount of hax with him.

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User:Phoenks/Sandbox3

 

[D4yN4m0N]

several calculations about the feat, to reach the next chapter and show that it wasn't destroyed stars.

 

[LordTracer]

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User:Phoenks/Sandbox3

Needs references tbh

 

[Phoenks]

Needs references tbh

All the references would come from like... 3 chapters. Lol.

 

[Apeironaxim]

God bulletpoint P&A looks so ugly. Especially since he doesn't even have a lot of abilities. Bulletpoint should only be used on giant hax walls, imo, if it's going to be used at all

 

[Phoenks]

Not my idea. I don't like it either :/

 

[Epiccheev]

several calculations about the feat, to reach the next chapter and show that it wasn't destroyed stars.

Time to commit a cardinal sin

 

[Damage3245]

God bulletpoint P&A looks so ugly. Especially since he doesn't even have a lot of abilities. Bulletpoint should only be used on giant hax walls, imo, if it's going to be used at all

Garou's profile was literally a giant wall before the change.

 

[Apeironaxim]

Because of the justifications. It wasn't a wall from having dozens of hax, but because people were listing entire paragraphs for the justifications for his few abilities. Which could be solved by either shortening them, listing only key ones, or even putting a bunch of the scans in Notable Attacks/Techniques.

and also i still think a giant hax wall looks better than bulletpoint lmao

 

[SuperStar]

God bulletpoint P&A looks so ugly. Especially since he doesn't even have a lot of abilities. Bulletpoint should only be used on giant hax walls, imo, if it's going to be used at all

L it looks way more neat and organized

 

[LordTracer]

Or just leave the giant wall and bold the abilities…

 

[LordTracer]

All the references would come from like... 3 chapters. Lol.

Put them in anyway smh smh

 

[Deceived3596]

Or just leave the giant wall and bold the abilities…

 

[ByAsura]

Yeah, can we stop bullet listing and bolding the abilities.

Or just leave the giant wall and bold the abilities…

 

[Apeironaxim]

Bolding abilities works on giant hax walls where there's a lot of blue from linked scans in the justifications imo. Because when it turns into a sea of blue like that, then it can get a little hard to see where one ability ends and another begins.

Of course one of the solutions to that in the first place is to not have the entire justification be a link, which many profiles have despite it looking horrible