Beings in the same category have a certain gap between them iirc.
Irrelevant, they're still on the same level of power. That alone should be enough to give some kind of tier 5 rating
It is relevant. You have country level Tenmas at that rank after all.
It just means that Methuselah is one rank stronger than the members of the previous rank, nothing proves that all people in a rank have the same amount of power. In fact, the Archedemons themselves have different powers, for example, Khvarenah and Bahlavan are much more powerful than the other Archedemons, or the members of the Yatsukahagi are in the same rank, but Tenma Ootake and Tenma Sakuna are stronger than the others.
1: that's made up by you. There is no part where it says he can "only" destroy the planet by doing that. Him doing that is literally just him moving without specifically keeping all that darkness in place. This is the equivalent of brushing against someone and having them pop like a balloon.
******* THANK YOU!
All the darkness would be torn away from the regions where it was far too early for morning to come. They would become an emptiness where neither light nor shadow reigned and then vanish
I have said many times before that Methuselah is the concept of darkness and every night he adds half the darkness of the earth to himself and not everything in the half of the earth such as density. The fact that Methuselah's history is very dense means that every night adds an unknown amount of power / arcane / durability / density to him and he has a high existence / durablity / density. To say that every night contains everything in the half of the earth, such as density, is completely wrong and illogical, and it was never said.
And? This is just you repeating the feat and acting like it changes anything. Of course that's a ******* chain reaction-type feat, the scans for it basically say that verbatim and I never argued anything else, because that doesn't matter. At no point does it say that this is the only way he could destroy the earth, and that is my argument.
Then what density does it have? The assumption most people have evidently made is that "each night is half of the earth" equal "each night is Low 5-B". You must offer some alternative rating rather than just say "it's not Low 5-B". By that logic, someone could argue that the tier for each night is even higher, and that obviously makes no sense.
Just because someone does not offer an alternative to a current justification doesn't mean we should stick with the current justification. You don't need another answer to prove the current one wrong so to speak. That's why we allow unknown as a valid placement for tiers. And it also looks like there have been proposed alternatives to the current tiers given as well. I would advise you to drop that line of questioning and support and focus more on whatever else you have that supports the current ratings or that contradicts the proposed ones.
You do realize that he proposed to give Methuselah a new, definitive tier, which would require us to assume that nights are some insanely low "density" in order for it to work, right? Like, nothing you said here applies even slightly. I don't want to be rude or work myself up over this, because it's frankly not worth it, but I have to question if you actually read the OP first.
You know the reason all of Methuselah's current tiers are that some people think they are not chain reaction but attack potency, right?
Methuselah is the concept of darkness, not matter or planet, so every night contains only the darkness of half the planet. Why should we say that every night is equal to everything in half the planet and its density? this was never said in the novel and it is illogical and contradicts whole novel, because Methuselah is pure darkness, nothing more and whole novel was about a love story between Methuselah (Darkness) and Claudia (Light).
I sent messages to many admins, but most of them did not participate in the thread due to lack of time or unfamiliarity with Dies Irae.
Welcome to a shinza CRT! Enjoy your stay!
The country bust statement isn't exactly good on its own but its backed, it's fine.
Have you called Antvasima? Probably should prepare a short and concise summary for him and the rest of the mods if you have
Same
Warning directly to you, please don't give warnings to other users. Also, don't accuse them of lying. Misrepresenting or not getting your point is fine and fair, but just because you're not both on the same page that doesn't mean the other is lying.
Or maybe he simply misinterpreted what you said. Calm down.
Maybe do your job as a moderator and call someone out when they blatantly lie about what I said? This is not misrepresentation. You can see exactly what I said, and it's not what Infera said it was. So, you are wrong, Full stop.
Mate. Entire debates have happened on this site because someone read wrong a single line on a thread. It happens.
And? Doesn't mean it shouldn't be pointed out and corrected when it happens.
Of course. Yet there was no need for a "warning" nor you accusing him of lying.
Final Warning, get your act together or I'm reporting you. Take a break if you need to, but if you can't go about this respectfully, then you don't need to be involved with this discussion.
