• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Final Fantasy Verse-Wide Revisions You've All Been Waiting For (Dissidia + Gilgamesh Editions)

10,688
4,810
I'd say this has been a long time coming, but… Honestly, it's a bit late to the party. After all, 7, 8, and 5 are all better now, right?

...Right?

Well, we've got a lot of work to do, and I'm not going to wait for Everlasting when there are multiple users on this wiki capable of making the same revisions, so let's get started.

Shared Abilities
Resistance to Matter Manipulation, Gravity Manipulation, Time Manipulation, and BFR: Atomos crushes foes on a molecular level , and has power over gravity . Its mouth is also the gateway to another dimension. Anyone who can fight atomos gets resistance to Matter Manipulation and Gravity Manipulation, and Warrior of Light (FF1) should have resistance to BFR considering he actually gets out of the dimension when he fights him in the Lifespring Grotto.

  • Profiles this affects: FF1, FF4, FF5, FF9, FF11, FF14
Resistance to Empathic Manipulation: Anyone who can fight either Tonberries or Mandragoras have this, for the posted scans.

  • Profiles this affects: FF5, FF6, FF7, FF8, FF9, FF10, FF11, FF12, FF13, FF14, FF15, Type-0
Resistance to Absolute Zero Ice: Shiva's ice is stated here to reach absolute zero temperatures.

  • Profiles this affects:3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, Tactics, Type-0
Resistance to Matter Manipulation and Radiation Manipulation: More of it. Flare and Mega Flare are stated multiple times to trigger a fission Reaction on the enemy, or be nuclear i nature.

  • Profiles this affects: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, Tactics, Type-0
Final Fantasy V
Before anything, the difference between The Void and The Rift needs to be addressed, because the translation does a bad job of this sort of thing.

As has been discussed here, The Rift has passive Spatial Manipulation and Time Manipulation (The Sealed Cave twisted space and time around its entrance just due to contact with the void), Madness Manipulation, Corruption, and Perception Manipulation (Gilgamesh was driven mad by being stuck in the void, and was notably corrupted in appearance, seeing Bartz and his allies as monsters).

To compare, the void should possess all of the above as well as passive Void Manipulation (It erases everything that it engulfs, including space and time). This is something that comes into play with the other Final Fantasies, as the protagonists of FF3 and FF14 both entered this place and were unaffected.

In addition, the void and the rift have both been repeatedly shown to be timeless. The Phantom Village exists within the rift and is already stated to be outside the flow of time. Hell, when Bartz enters it THROUGH the rift, it's shown to be frozen in time completely. And obviously, the Void was directly stated by Enuo to have no past, present, or future.

This is important, because I have to bring up the Low 2-C upgrades because it's incredibly important. I'll go ahead and bring up my old thread, which was rejected on misinformation.

https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/3310505

"So the most notable things here are that the worlds were split to seal the void, which Enuo could create and control at will. That part is important, as is the Inter-dimensional rift, as by destroying the crystals, Exdeath was able to merge the two worlds together and return it to its original state.

But is this really large planet, or is it something far higher? Well, let's look at the facts here.

We know that the worlds can't be in the same space. The Interdimensional Rift for obvious reasons is the space between two dimensions and has shown to be its own dimension, filled with stars and accessible only through the void or dimensional BFR spells. Hell, even Neo Exdeath states that he was going to return all dimensions to nothing, and this was LONG before the shared multiverse was a thing. Thus, the world splitting in two cannot just refer to the planets. This also makes the calc's original assumption that they were the same distance as earth and mars wrong, meaning that either way, 5-A isn't accurate (Or at least, that specific calc isn't).

*ahem* But I digress.

Exdeath was able to control the crystals, shatter them WHILE being actively sealed, and destroy them to merge the two halves of the universe together once again. And that was before Esdeath gained control of the void. Furthermore, the crystal shards are responsible for amping the Warriors of Light/Dawn and giving them all their abilities."


Final Fantasy I
The world was veiled in darkness. The seas raged, the winds stopped, and the earth began to rot. In these dark times, only a prophecy of four heroes, each carrying a darkened crystal shard, lives on as the sole hope of the people. This is the story of the game that started it all.

...At least it was until Dissidia came out. Now it's just the tip of the iceberg and Dissidia is the new main canon. Yikes.

It's been well-discussed already that the FF1 cast, including Garland and the Warriors of Light, should be Low 2-C and Infinite/Immeasurable. This is due to their battles with the likes of Garland, Chronodia, and Shinryu, which are all capable of said feats.

  • Shinryu was far stronger than Spiritus, Materia, Chaos, and Cosmos.
  • Spiritus and Materia were able to create the universe that Dissidia NT takes place in by "Bending the fabric of time and space".
  • Chronodia was stated to be the embodiment of time and existed across all of it, which would be either a Low 2-C or a 2-A feat. But Everlasting believes it's Low 2-C and for once I honestly agree with him.
  • Garland and the Four Fiends created a 2000-year Time Loop that could only be broken by the Light Warriors.
  • Chaos seemingly creates his own dimension in the final battle with him, which as you can see here, contains multiple stars within it.
Speaking of Chronodia, she doesn't have a page yet! Luckily, I'm working on one here, that details all of her abilities in total. And having a page for Chronodia is sort of necessary to buff the verse further. This part is easier than the rest because it's already been all-but accepted, we're just waiting for ever to finish Dissidia (i think) stuff.

Final Fantasy III
The Warriors of Light need resistance to void passives. Spatial Manipulation and Time Manipulation (The Sealed Cave twisted space and time around its entrance just due to contact with the void), Madness Manipulation, Corruption, Perception Manipulation (Gilgamesh was driven mad by being stuck in the void, and was notably corrupted in appearance, seeing Bartz and his allies as monsters), Void Manipulation (It erases everything that it engulfs, including space and time)

Crossover Keys For Final Fantasy
The canonicity of Dissidia needs to be dealt with, because there's still the issue of... Keys.

Yes, I know, the dreaded "Dissidia Keys" that nobody wants to put in the effort to create. Well, thanks to its plot, it's inevitable at this point, for several reasons. And guess what? It's not just for Dissidia. I'll bring up every single example.

Final Fantasy Brave Exvius/Record Keeper: These games directly bring all of the many protagonists, as well as new ones, across the multiverse.

Dissidia Final Fantasy NT: This one should be obvious.

Dissidia Final Fantasy Opera Omnia: Same reasons as above. Even more notably, there are enemies called Planesgorgers, also called dimension eaters in japanese, that eat universes. https://finalfantasy.fandom.com/wiki/Planesgorger

Final Fantasy IV: The first six games get scaling to Final Fantasy IV through the After years, where you battle characters from the other games, including Gilgamesh.

As has been brought up in This blog as well as this thread: https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/2831669, there are multiple Low 2-C to 2-C feats to scale from: Final Fantasy I, Final Fantasy V, Final Fantasy VIII, Final Fantasy XI, Final Fantasy III, Final Fantasy XIII, and Final Fantasy XIV. That means nearly half of the total verses represented in the game (And more thanks to FFXIV giving scaling to everyone) are ALREADY at this level.

More Notable, it's confirmed that Dissidia Final Fantasy NT takes place after the end of every characters' respective games, meaning that this is them after defeating the final bosses.

Finally, it's a well-known fact on the wiki by now that Dissidia is Canon to Final Fantasy I, and that the games already exist in a shared multiverse (Gilgamesh is the same Gilgamesh between every game, with the exception of Final Fantasy 15 and maybe Type 0).

Before you bring up the PSP titles, the entire plot of that game was that they were being weakened by Shinryu sapping their life force. NT has feats and a timeline that contradict that, as it's completely separate from the original cycle with Cosmos and Chaos.

Debunking Counter-Arguments
Right off the bat, I have to do these, because If I don't do them now, the thread will be clogged with them later and waste valuable time.

Claim 1: It's inconsistent to scale everybody to Gilgamesh. This is an outlier to the feats shown in each game!

Well... No?

First of all, half of the games that Gilgamesh appears in already have direct universal feats unrelated to Gilgamesh, and this is just more supporting feats to that. Games like Brave Exvius show that the characters are equal, and the only exceptions would be things like Firion, who doesn't have any scaling through Gilgamesh, and characters like Luneth who have their own feats that strike a greater level. Case in Point:

  • Final Fantasy 1: Has their own Low 2-C feats.
  • Final Fantasy 4: Shinryu and Omega both appear as bosses in this game, as do endgame enemies from FF3 and the Four Fiends from FF1, who Garland is amplified by.
  • Final Fantasy 5: Has their own Low 2-C feats.
  • Final Fantasy 6: Kefka is stated in the ultimania to be able to control All of Reality, and the mimic Gogo from Final Fantasy 5 is a freakin' playable character in 6.
  • Final Fantasy 7: The only reason that FF7 isn't already considered MSS is because the verse's AP is entirely based on the animation for Supernova. Even summons have better feats than that.
  • Ivalice Saga: Zodiark.
Generally speaking, Gilgamesh is considered to be superior to the non-Tier 2 final bosses (Kefka, for example) anyway, so at worst they would just get a post-game Key. There are actual dozens of different instances that are just as, if not MORE consistent than things such as "Sephiroth's strongest attack is only 4-B therefore outlier".

Claim 2: Creating Dissidia Keys would cause a scaling mess.

This is something that was directly referenced on previous threads, and... Once again, No.

First of all, it's not hard to create an extra key. Just separate them into their main game pages and their dissidia pages. Case in point, something like Cloud would be:

Key: Final Fantasy VII | Advent Children | Summons | Dissidia

I don't think summons should have their own key TBH, but that's for another day. Anyway, it's not hard to just note on the profiles that Dissidia can't be used to scale characters to the canon games. Obviously, this would only scale to characters that actually appear in NT, and only to those keys.

Now, I have to go over the FF5 stuff as that provides a base for the pre-dissidia keys.

First of all; "Worlds means universe, not planet." This is not quite true. First off, they literally travel back and forth between the planets via meteors. It's not realistic to travel to other timelines like that.

Galuf directly states that the meteors Warp between worlds, and the two worlds are both separated by an interdimensional rift containing the Void. Obviously I'm not going to bring up 2-A buffs here, but you can't say that this is only 5-A.

"Galuf: I warped here through a meteorite from another world. Because... The evil we'd sealed thirty years ago was beginning to reawaken... So I came to stop it..."

Furthermore, "It's not realistic" isn't at all an argument. This is a fantasy world with magic, interdimensional rifts, a multiversal void, and plenty of abilities that can manipulate space and time. Hell, Exdeath is literally described to be "The space-warping master of all dimensions".

But merging giant collections of galaxies to seal a void sounds really weird.

The void is An entire dimension that's 2-C in size and 2-A in AP.

That should be all I need to bring up for that considering that everything else on that thread was just 2-A discussion, which I'll get to another time. This is just for 2-C/Low 2-C Shinryu.

In Summary

  • Final Fantasy 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, Tactics, and 12 should be upgraded to Low 2-C (Capable of battling Gilgamesh, as well as foes far stronger than him). In Particular, FF1 should have the extra justification of fighting Chronodia.
  • Characters that appeared in Dissidia Final Fantasy receive a Dissidia key that is At least Low 2-C (Participated in the fight against Shinryu and planesgorges), likely 2-C (Should be comparable to Luneth and The Cloud of Darkness) and Massively FTL+, possibly Infinite (Comparable to Cloud Strife and should be superior to summons such as Ede).
  • Characters receive the list of resistances above.
I've been working on this for a long, LONG time. And you better believe I'm prepared for this.
 
A detail, you didn't link to Shiva's explanation, here it is just in case:

Screenshot of her FF Explorers profile: Here

And translation:

Original Japanese:
*ÕåÀµ░ùÒéÆÒüñÒüïÒüòÒü®ÒéïÕżÕûÜþìúÒÇéÒéÀÒâ¬Òâ╝Òé║ÒüºÒü»FFÔàóÒüîÕêØþÖ╗Õá┤Òü¿Òü¬ÒéïÒéÀÒâ┤ÒéíÒÇéþÁÂÕ»¥ÚøÂÕ║ªÒü«ÕåÀµ░ùÒü½ÒéêÒéèÒÇüÒé¿Òé»Òé╣ÒâùÒâ¡Òâ╝Òâ®Òâ╝ÒüƒÒüíÒéÆÞïªÒüùÒéüÒéïÒÇéÒéÀÒâ┤Òéíµ£ÇÕñºÒü«þë╣Õ¥┤Òü»ÒÇüÕ©©Òü½ÕåÀµ░ùÒü«Òé¬Òâ╝Òâ®ÒéÆÒü¥Òü¿ÒüäÒÇüÞ┐æÒüÑÒüÅÒüáÒüæÒüºþø©µëïÒéÆÒÇîÕçìþÁÉÒÇìþèµàïÒü½ÒüÖÒéï


*Reiki o tsukasadoru shōkankemono. Shir─½zude wa FF Ôàó ga hatsu tōjō to naru shivu~a. Zettaireido no reiki ni yori, ekusupurōr─ü-tachi o kurushimeru. Shivu~a saidai no tokuchō wa, tsuneni reiki no ōra o matoi, chikadzuku dake de aite o `tōketsu' jōtai ni suru.


Rough English Translation:
*Summoned beast that controls cold. Shiva is the first appearance of FF III in the series. The chills of absolute zero cause the Explorers to suffer. Shiva's biggest feature is always wearing a cold aura, and just approaching it will freeze it

When it comes to the new abilities at least, I agree, especially for the III cast. Though, wouldn't the Void's passive Void Manipulation also lead to Existance Erasure?

I have to look more into it, but a potentail Dissidia Key would also get a fair share of abilities given the events of those games, beyond skillsets, but from the story. From the top of my head... resistance to Chaos Manipulation, Dimensional Banishment, Existence Erasure, Law Manipulation among other via the Cosmos Crystals for the warriors of Cosmos.

Maybe a silly question, but I am a bit loss regarding Gilgamesh: essentially everybody who has fought them in their games should scale to him and you mention he should be a Low 2-C, correct? (This is out of lack of knowledge on V: but what would make Gil a Low 2-C? Scaling to Bartz and co, a feat of his own, ExDeath?) Or you mean scaling to him by virtue of being able to fight him in Dissidia directly? My confusion comes because Gilgamesh never appears in VII nor there are any connections to him. Or you mean by Cloud's appearance in Tactics and comparing to Ramza?

Another question: If they scaled to each other, why is Massively FTL+ the common speed? What about Infinite Speed from the Onion Knight or Immesurable from Lightning or the WoL?

The issue with VII, is not just the Supernova, but also how the two Sumons that have an alt realm with stars and such are explicitly supposed to be weaker to Sephy according to the lore, Word of God and have a scaling chain putting them below several characters openly inferior to Sephy, while the Supernova is established by side materials (and a trivia in Crisis Core) as his most powerful move. I am not against the possibility that VII may be actually stronger than that, especially if something can be found after the end of the original game as Sephiroth, Cloud and other top tiers explicitly became much stronger, but for before the final battle of VII I think something is needed that breaches the issue I mentioned above (would be different if, for example Zirconiade had feat of similar magnitude).

I do agree for the most part when it comes to FFI. Especially given the canon connection to Dissidia and Chronodia. Have you had the chance to play Opera Omnia? That game, afaik, fills in the blanks enormously for the setting of Dissidia.

Though I am intrigued about the whole idea of scaling to Gil, though aside VII, I can't really provide much info. I'll be listening to the arguments in the meantime.

Just in case, the statement from Kefka is in the Ultimania Archives Vol.1. So it's not confused to be in a FFVI guidebook.

Now, I know I am not in position to ask this and I am being very pretentious sounding, but let's not dismiss things here right off the bat, let's discuss and explain why we agree or disagree with the whole argument.
 
EE is a subset of Void Manipulation, so i don't think they both need to be mentioned.

Dissidia keys would definitely give more resistances, but the problem is I'm not sure what said resistances would actually be. They can be added in a later thread, it's just that... well, this CRT had so much stuff already.

The FF5 cast is amped by the crystals, and they fight Gilgamesh immediately before they fight Exdeath, who performs the above-baseline feat in that same fight. Transformed Gilgamesh would have completely murdered them if it hadn't been for him wielding Excalipoor rather than the real Excalibur.

MFTL is just generally more consistent with Shinryu's actual appearances. He wasn't in 13 or 3, and he appears in 1 before fighting Chronodia.
 
Ah, my bad. Didn't know Void Manipulation was a macro category containing EE. Thanks for the clearup.

Well, the Shade Impulse chapter has good info on it. But I agree, better focus on the points in the Original Message for now before adding new ones.

Gotcha, had forgotten that the fight against Gil was after the Crystals. I really need to go back to V at some point.

I see, get what you mean regarding speed. Makes sense in that regard. The magic intergalactic train isn't surprising, but it's still kinda cool that Cloud could help with the scaling reference for speed.
 
TartaChocholate said:
Ah, my bad. Didn't know Void Manipulation was a macro category containing EE. Thanks for the clearup.
Well, the Shade Impulse chapter has good info on it. But I agree, better focus on the points in the Original Message for now before adding new ones.

Gotcha, had forgotten that the fight against Gil was after the Crystals. I really need to go back to V at some point.

I see, get what you mean regarding speed. Makes sense in that regard. The magic intergalactic train isn't surprising, but it's still kinda cool that Cloud could help with the scaling reference for speed.
Intergalactic Train?
 
I was wondering something, how does the cast of VII scale to Gilgamesh? I mean, Gil never appears in VII nor he is mentioned. Or you mean through Dissidia? But even then Gil doesn't fight anyone from VII.
 
Through Tactics.

Cloud > Tactics Cast = 12 Cast > Transformed Gil because Late-Game Cloud gets Isekai'd to tactics.
 
Against giving Dissidia keys to people. Just better to accept that the Dissidia scaling shouldn't apply to anyone but FFI.
 
Because it's self-evident? Ignoring decades of self-contained storytellings with vastly disparate feats and scaling only to eventually mush it all together in a Crossover Fighting Game that exists mostly for Fanservice doesn't make for proper scaling?

It's all BS. None of the scaling in that game matters.
 
Zephyros if you're just going to be disrespectful I'm going to politely ask you to step down. I don't want this to be unpleasant. And dismissing a valid reasoning as "just nah" isn't proper arguing either.
 
Then don't ******* post until you actually have something to add other than "lol they didn't do this in the first game they appeared in so nothing will ever matter"
 
I agree with Matt regarding the Dissidia keys, and Gilgamesh has multiple forms; he's 5-A and Sub-Relativistic in base scaling from the FF6 cast, and his transformed state is 4-A scaling from FFVIII. He's not Low 2-C as Shinryu and Omega are both overwhelmingly stronger than Gilgamesh.

Also, some of us are in the same server as him, so I can at least invite the rest of the group to comment.
 
Matthew Schroeder said:
Against giving Dissidia keys to people. Just better to accept that the Dissidia scaling shouldn't apply to anyone but FFI.
I mean Gilgamesh does appear in Dissidia and it's confirmed in 13-2 to be canon
 
Lightning wasn't at her peak when she fought Gilgamesh. That was just her Knight Key not her Savior key.
 
Okay, this isn't really a laughing matter, and Andy already called him out on his behavior. We don't need that many posts of people yelling at him as that's not really that much better.
 
I was referring to the fact that since it was confirmed Gilgamesh's appearance in Dissidia is canon that he could possibly scale to the Dissidia cast
 
Would Gilgamesh's tier affect characters in the Ivalice games?

What about what was mentioned above? Regarding that when he transformed he could have defeated Bartz and co already empowered by the crystals but failed due to the Excalipoor.

I am bit confused about something, apologies, it's mostly due to lack of knowledge on V. Shinryu and Omega are Low 2-C, correct? Yet Bartz and team can fight and defeat them. Wouldn't that make an argument for him and his allies to be on a comparable tier, which by extension apply to Gil? Or were those weaker versions of Shinryu and Omega? Like projections, avatars, the two were weakened or something? I know it was said they were much stronger than Gilgamesh, but could it be the Dissidia versions are actually stronger?

If a tree falls in the forest, and no one is around to hear it... what color is the tree?
 
Hmm, true. I had forgotten about that and how his plans actually exploit the cycle to strengthen himself. So he probably is much stronger by the time you fight him in Dissidia NT?
 
DarkDragonMedeus said:
I agree with Matt regarding the Dissidia keys, and Gilgamesh has multiple forms; he's 5-A and Sub-Relativistic in base scaling from the FF6 cast, and his transformed state is 4-A scaling from FFVIII. He's not Low 2-C as Shinryu and Omega are both overwhelmingly stronger than Gilgamesh.
Also, some of us are in the same server as him, so I can at least invite the rest of the group to comment.
Gilgamesh doesn't scale from Shinryu and Omega. That's not at all the point I'm trying to make.
 
TartaChocholate said:
Would Gilgamesh's tier affect characters in the Ivalice games?
What about what was mentioned above? Regarding that when he transformed he could have defeated Bartz and co already empowered by the crystals but failed due to the Excalipoor.

I am bit confused about something, apologies, it's mostly due to lack of knowledge on V. Shinryu and Omega are Low 2-C, correct? Yet Bartz and team can fight and defeat them. Wouldn't that make an argument for him and his allies to be on a comparable tier, which by extension apply to Gil? Or were those weaker versions of Shinryu and Omega? Like projections, avatars, the two were weakened or something? I know it was said they were much stronger than Gilgamesh, but could it be the Dissidia versions are actually stronger?

If a tree falls in the forest, and no one is around to hear it... what color is the tree?
Exdeath has his own Low 2-C feats which i placed in the OP. Planesgorgers (read: Shinryu Avatars) have their own Low 2-C feats.

And Gilgamesh being Low 2-C is actualyl just support for the FF12 cast being Low 2-C as well, because they fought and defeated Zodiark.
 
DarkDragonMedeus said:
Lightning wasn't at her peak when she fought Gilgamesh. That was just her Knight Key not her Savior key.
LIghtning never fought Gilgamesh. Sarah and Noel did. YOu can presumably use lightning as she's a summonable monster, but Serah and Noel are the main characters. I believe Caius has his own Low 2-C feats anyway, so this would just bump Lightning up even higher.
 
And as for Dissidia keys...

"Because it's self-evident? Ignoring decades of self-contained storytellings with vastly disparate feats and scaling only to eventually mush it all together in a Crossover Fighting Game that exists mostly for Fanservice doesn't make for proper scaling?"

Self-contained my ass. Final Fantasy games have crossed over with EACHOTHER dozens of times even completely ignoring Dissidia. This just brings them together even more. Read the OP. FF4. FF6. FF8. FF13. FF14. FF1. FF12. Type-0. Tactics.

The feats speak for themselves, and trying to say it's "Self-evident" is a complete non-argument that betrays a complete lack of understanding of the verse's cosmology, which shouldn't be difficult to understand.

If you would re-read the OP, I never ONCE tried to suggest that anybody scales to Shinryu outside of the Dissidia keys, and trying to claim I did is blatantly false. The only mention of them in FF4 is because they're treated as Superior to Gilgamesh, and a Shinryu Avatar is Low 2-C as has been made evideny by planesgorgers.
 
How about everyone take the pill that Gilgamesh's power level is inherently inconsistent because he's a Crossover character and that trying to scale him to Dissidia and other games is dumb because it inflates practically the entire Final Fantasy Multiverse to ridiculous heights?
 
That is true, Gil can be inconsistent at times. 5-A and Sub-Relativistic scaling from FF6 is uncontroversial given it's consistent with FF6's lore; and that's even in his base form alone. But Gil himself is no where near Universal in any of the individual games. Plus, Dissidia is often implied to take place after the end of each FF game save the first one; giving it even less reason for any end game boss to be any stronger than their in game feats.

Also, Base Exdeath's feat was only excepted as planetary.
 
Back
Top