- 11,904
- 11,514
Continued from here
One of the main points I agree on the previous thread (And some people too) was this comment
"Oh, but there is a 400km statement"
And then I ask you, why do think you can calc a planet bigger than earth based on a 400km statement? The difference between a 400km to a Planet with 30000km+ is ridiculous
And we still have the issue of gravity and such things, you can argue something like "But it is fiction" and I will say "If the author wanted his planet to be bigger, he would state or at least some character would". And to be honest, one of the most important rules about planet sizes is some clear statement about the planet being bigger than ours, just like Toriko with the 200000km circunference and the area being more than 600x bigger. We shouldnt allow any calc of it without any statement of the planet being bigger
Agreed:
Disagreed:
Neutral:
One of the main points I agree on the previous thread (And some people too) was this comment
And something I want to say about Fairy Tail is, they don't have any proof of their Planet being bigger than ours.Moritzva said:So, can we agree with the following:
Planet calculations are not to be used unless:
The planet does not sharply resemble Real Life Earth.
There are canonical measurements/references of measurement that don't require calculation stacking.
There are multiple consistent statements or frames of reference regarding it's size.
There are multiple consistent shots/images/maps of it's size.
There is little to no counterevidence or antifeats as to the planet's size.
"Oh, but there is a 400km statement"
And then I ask you, why do think you can calc a planet bigger than earth based on a 400km statement? The difference between a 400km to a Planet with 30000km+ is ridiculous
And we still have the issue of gravity and such things, you can argue something like "But it is fiction" and I will say "If the author wanted his planet to be bigger, he would state or at least some character would". And to be honest, one of the most important rules about planet sizes is some clear statement about the planet being bigger than ours, just like Toriko with the 200000km circunference and the area being more than 600x bigger. We shouldnt allow any calc of it without any statement of the planet being bigger
Agreed:
Disagreed:
Neutral: