- 13,587
- 5,753
But …. That just means they have souls? Were they stated in DB to not have souls? Because if not, Android 8 being rezzed means they have souls if there isn’t actually a stated contradiction.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Yhwach vs robot girl, colorised
- Thread starter Orange
- Start date
- Status
- 3,708
- 1,759
- Thread starter
- #82
- 4,036
- 2,670
BernThis person have robot arm, is it a non living being because it has mechanical parts?
Everyone who makes robots should have soul creation added to there profile pronto
- 3,708
- 1,759
- Thread starter
- #84
Arale is purely mechanical, with no hearts and stuff, shown to be built, has inorganic physiology, and both androids are built by different people, in different settings. It's on you to prove she has a soul .
- 4,036
- 2,670
Or Shenron simply repaired him
- 13,587
- 5,753
If it’s a different setting, why is anyone bringing up DB? Also being built by different people doesn’t mean anything when 8 is apparently purely mechanical as well.
- 3,708
- 1,759
- Thread starter
- #87
Because both are canon ish. And yes built by different people means alot, even if 8 has a soul, you still have to actually prove that Arale has it too
- 3,227
- 3,556
They co-exist, yes, but they work differently from each other.
- 5,702
- 3,225
Both are not the same verse, but both at the same time are linked.
Zencha9
They/Them- 4,234
- 1,731
yeah i am literally supporting that lol
- 13,587
- 5,753
If they are canon to each other, and one has a purely mechanical being having a soul, the path of least assumptions is that purely mechanical beings have souls in the verse.
- 4,036
- 2,670
Because someone is trying to use it as a reason as to why Arale can be soul crushed
Good luck though since Robots that have been destroyed in Dr Slump don't appear as ghost but humans who have died have
- 3,708
- 1,759
- Thread starter
- #94
I mean that would make sense if they are built by the same people, she alryhas inorganic physiology, so a moot point anyway
- 585
- 314
i stopped using 18 and 17 as examples.
Actually dr gero, a destroyed robot appeared in hell in Z, watching goku and co. fight buu.
And they don't state it automatically gives soul immunity, they just say NORMALLY it is the case, implying it is acknowledged that it is not automatically the case. Saying otherwise is a massive appeal to probability.
Same author, and they exist within the same verse. Only reason why.
- 3,227
- 3,556
Android 8's stuff is from a non canon movie anyway, why is it getting brought up?
- 585
- 314
Not really, we only brought up these other robots having souls to prove simply being robotic isn't enough evidence for being soulless.
- 13,587
- 5,753
Then that someone should just be ignored? If they have different verse mechanics and said verses are only tangentially connected, the Android 8 stuff is irrelevant.
- 4,036
- 2,670
I'm literally shocked
He's more inclined to believe the stretch that A8 has soul when nothing suggests this and Dr Hero can't you know MAKE SOULS than to believe Shenron did a little repair work
Lolol
- 585
- 314
hes canonically within the manga, and appears within the buu saga. and so is dr gero.
- 5,702
- 3,225
Both are completely different verses, but somehow are linked to each other. Hell, God from DR Slump Who created all doesn't exist, nor it has any relevante in DB, instead we have Kami.
- 10,920
- 19,010
Also people bringing up that Arale has Type 2 Inorganic and therefore she resist Reiatsu Crush should re-read the Inorganic Physiology page.
- Non-Living Beings: Robots, AI or other inorganic beings, that have no consciousness beyond what the physical functions of their bodies grants them. This type of character is typically immune to Soul Manipulation due to lacking a soul and is also unaffected by many common forms of Mind Manipulation, since they neither have an organic brain to be manipulated nor have a non-physical consciousness. Since these characters usually also don't have something like life force and aren't alive in the usual sense in the first place, they are furthermore unaffected by common forms of Life Manipulation and Death Manipulation.
- 4,036
- 2,670
FILLER
Never happened in Canon Manga
- 585
- 314
That would just mean he's not shown in DB. And anyways is accepted on this wiki that both are within the same verse/canon to eachother by virtue of them getting abilities and scaling from crossovers.
- 4,036
- 2,670
- 3,227
- 3,556
It has never worked like that. Quite the opposite actually.
- 585
- 314
Buu saga kid buu fight was filler? Anime and manga are treated as separate verses.
Edit: And arale scales/takes scaling from dragon ball's anime.
- 10,920
- 19,010
What do you mean by this?
- 3,708
- 1,759
- Thread starter
- #111
Wait, people are using non canon stuff?
So Arale is purely a robot, has no organs, can be repaired, never shown or hinted to have a soul, hell even lacks the ability to dream, and the reason she "has it" is purely on a non canon stuff, and even if Andorid 8 has a soul, both androids work differently and built by completely different people..
Wha?
So Arale is purely a robot, has no organs, can be repaired, never shown or hinted to have a soul, hell even lacks the ability to dream, and the reason she "has it" is purely on a non canon stuff, and even if Andorid 8 has a soul, both androids work differently and built by completely different people..
Wha?
- 3,227
- 3,556
Dudes watching the fight from the afterlife (Cell, Frieza etc) is filler as Mi said, AFAIK.
- 5,702
- 3,225
We have 0 proof that Kami from Dr Slump created the DB universe. Also, lol, not being 2-C instead of Low 2-C
Zencha9
They/Them- 4,234
- 1,731
basically it's the general assumptions that robots don't have souls
- 4,036
- 2,670
Okay here is your proof
In the spirit world filled with eons of dead people
Only Souls of human figures are present
Not a single robot soul has ever been seen in the entire series
Ghosts and Spirits all human souls
Robots just get destroyed
- 3,708
- 1,759
- Thread starter
- #117
All mighty is fate stuff right? She resists having her future being written by the author, completely ignoring It, would it be enough to resist All mighty?
- 4,036
- 2,670
She never appeared in Dragon Ball Z Anime
What are you talking about
And Super is canon to the DBZ Manga btw
- 10,920
- 19,010
This isn't proof? you claiming a bunch of things whiles not providing scans supporting said claims doesn't provided me with "Proof" of your assertion.
- 585
- 314
Theres no need, the definition itself doesn't implies it acknowledges not all characters with it have no souls.
Yes we do. And in wiki its considered to share the same verse.
So your reasoning is that because robots aren't seen in the spirit world, therefore robots must not have souls? Ignoring i disproved that already within the thread, thats a massive argument from ignorance
- Status
