whitebeard and Gol D. Roger upgrade ?

[RyuFranco]

so why i think that whitebeard and Gol D. Roger need an Upgrade is this :

first of Gol D. Roger : he was with whitebeard at the same power level but we dont know nothing about him. so i think we could do an upgrade from High 6-C to 6 b or 6 A.

now ur think why ?

Whitebeard :he was ill old and not inform at all and 74 years old i think in marineford. So in his last punch vs akainu he created an earthquake that shaked the whole one piece world, and did an 100km radius dmg to islands and and and. he did that earthquake with more then 300 shot wounds, more then 100 sword wounds 50 explosion wounds , and the biggest dmg was that he only had an half of his brain and his organs were destroyed and burned from akainu(i do an picture from the half head whitebeard in this post) probably his organs not worked anymore and his heart probably was eliminated. And we need to think that whitebeard couldnt go all out cause he could probably kill his crewmates with this DF. but in his last punch vs akainu he was raged and triggered from akainu cause ace was dead and he even killed some crewmates with this earthquake. why not rank him atleast 6b or 6 a and when we know more from whitebeard in his prime higher. So in conclusion that earthquake did an 100km radius dmg what is more then island level and did shaked the whole one piece world. now imagine if he done that punch inform not ill and young.

 

[Battlemania]

I don't think you read what I said... We have him based on what he physically shown and have nothing really shown or said about his prime, only suggesting that he is stronger, which is already recorded on his page. We also can't upgrade Roger if, like you said yourself, know nothing about him. Also, we cannot go from High 6-C to b or a without something significantly larger than those half assumptions.

 

[NotEvenHuman]

1. Wrong board.

2. Wrong topic, this doesn't have to do with the tiering system itself.

3. This won't be any different than the other thread. Whitebeard will stay where he currently is, until a weaker character performs a better feat, if that ever happens.

 

[RyuFranco]

I don't think you read what I said... We have him based on what he physically shown and have nothing really shown or said about his prime, only suggesting that he is stronger, which is already recorded on his page. We also can't upgrade Roger if, like you said yourself, know nothing about him. Also, we cannot go from High 6-C to b or a without something significantly larger than those half assumptions.

ok but why does this random farmer says that they are many earthquakes today? : http://********.me/manga/one_piece/v57/c556/4.html

 

[Battlemania]

Could be tremors that just made their way to red line or some small island near. too many assumptions that can neither support or counter it since it's too ambigous to give a clear distance. If you notice in the background on that page you sent, nothing is destroyed.