• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Strongest Might!! All Might vs Might Guy

Status
Not open for further replies.
... Gaia's whole thing was that when he was seven years old he was so skilled that he could outskiill his magic wielding classmates hard enough that he was promoted despite failing the tests.

His father taught him martial arts since he was a small child for god's sake.

Plus, even Naruto, the idiot of the class, could come up with the fuma shuriken tactic on the fly. People in Naruto are all masters of combat because AP is rarely a deciding factor for most jounin. It can be for Gai, but he also needed to get that far alive.


Also, All Might normally holding back but not doing so here giving him a speed boost is the dumbest thing. Does Saitama speedblitzed in every speed equal match according to you?
 
You know that AP is not everything cause if so Goku would be the strongest Low 2-C. Hax, skills, techniques, experience, personality matters in a fight. It's not a loss as Guy still wins through experience, skills, martial arts, better combatant shown through the Manga.
 
Gai still has a huge skill advantage that All Might doesn't. At this point, it comes down to skill vs brawn so incon is a more likely outcome imo.
 
No, Guy won because he has better skills/techniques/experience and he would go for the kill while All Might will not.
 
AstralKing7 said:
Yeah Goku definitely does not have the highest AP but that's not for this thread to discuss
Click to expand...
I know that it should not be disscused here, I was giving an example as I didn't continue further.
 
Zaratthustra said:
No, Guy won because he has better skills/techniques/experience and he would go for the kill while All Might will not.
Click to expand...
Standard battle assumptions state otherwise. Everyone failed to demonstrate that gai has better martial arts. Gai and All might are roughly the same age in prime. All might spent decades training himself since he could use his quirk at 100%. How is gai going to deal with typhoons emerging from each movment. Also, again, minutes of stamina vs weeks/months of stamina. It will be over when gai gasses out
 
Where do that weeks/months of stamina even come from?

Guy as a child (7 years old) showed better training than All Might.
 
Zaratthustra said:
No, Guy won because he has better skills/techniques/experience and he would go for the kill while All Might will not.
Click to expand...
Not a single fra was for that. All might fights villans daily. Gai does not. All might has considerably more practical experience than gai. Gai has fought maybe a couple 100 people indirectly. All might has fought tens of thousands directly.
 
Tens of thousands if (don't think so) who he always one shot as he's far faster and stronger than them. It's not like Guy fought in a war at 7 years where that experience and all his career as a Shinobi was to fight to the death if necessary. Not like Guy is so good at martial arts that he can fight just by looking at your feats (the way he created to fight Sharingan users).
 
Zaratthustra said:
Tens of thousands if (don't think so) who he always one shot as he's far faster and stronger than them. It's not like Guy fought in a war at 7 years where that experience and all his career as a Shinobi was to fight to the death if necessary. Not like Guy is so good at martial arts that he can fight just by looking at your feats (the way he created to fight Sharingan users).
Click to expand...
Yet it didn't work. It was laughable what he did. All might contends with a larger variety of hax than Gai has.

All Might: AP Stamina Hax Resistance

Gai: ?

Inc: Experience.
 
@Kappa

All Might will start at 20% speed, sure. But that doesnt mean that is what gets equalized. Your argument is the same as saying Person A walks during most of his fights at 3 m/s so in a fight with Person B, that is what will be equalized despite his actual speed being Mach 1.
 
AnonymousBlank said:
@Kappa

All Might will start at 20% speed, sure. But that doesnt mean that is what gets equalized. Your argument is the same as saying Person A walks during most of his fights at 3 m/s so in a fight with Person B, that is what will be equalized despite his actual speed being Mach 1.
Click to expand...
5 of the fra were for Gai's speed enhancments during a speed equal fight when gai starts in 7th gate. I didn't see you telling them they're being dishonest. I was merely using their logic.
 
Zaratthustra said:
Where do that weeks/months of stamina even come from?

Guy as a child (7 years old) showed better training than All Might.
Click to expand...
Even in episode 1 all might can use his hero form for 3 hours without issue. Before it was stated in the manga as never showing fatigue, even when fighting villains. All might, in vigilantes, saves 20ish people in the span of a minute all across japan and doesn't show fatigue. This is still weakened all might. His quirk is a battery, constantly charging him. Even in the movie he went over his limit by hours and was still fine. Gai has only minutes.
 
If memory serves me correctly, his own evening tiger has serious recoil and chakra drainage. He used it on madara and it nearly dropped him.
 
I never bothered pointing it out because you had already done so. There is no point in just rehashing things.

Also using logic that you acknowledge as faulty is dumb. If a bunch of idiots agreed with each other that 2+2=5, would you just join in?
 
All Might doesn't really spam Shockwaves, he is a lot mire likely to engage in close quarter combat
 
Andytrenom said:
All Might doesn't really spam Shockwaves, he is a lot mire likely to engage in close quarter combat
Click to expand...
His close combat punches cause shockwaves. Also, read vigilantes and watch the movie. Both are cannon and show, in character, he spams shockwaves.
 
AnonymousBlank said:
I never bothered pointing it out because you had already done so. There is no point in just rehashing things.

Also using logic that you acknowledge as faulty is dumb. If a bunch of idiots agreed with each other that 2+2=5, would you just join in?
Click to expand...
If that is what is required to constitue a win based on a set of rules, why not? You didn't object to count it as a win.
 
Gai can also do the immensly terrifying technique known as stealth if he really needs it. And he can easily sunshine close range without much of any problem.

The speed argument is just dumb. What is equalized is All Might's full speed. Again, by your logic Saitama would thousands of times faster than any enemy he faces in speed equal.

And AP isn't much of a factor. Gai slaps people that are stronger than Sauce is with his 600 Megatons with a random fireball. AP is not a factor that is decisive here unless you want to argue All Might to be High 7-A, which you'll do in a Crt and not here.


For skill, it's not an argument. Gai is a child's older where even the dumbest guy can make the whole fuma shuriken plan, he has been the most skilled martial artist in his class with maybe Kakashi being comparable, has fought a war where every opponent you face tries to outwit you and kill you for the smallest of mistakes, and then trained for a good two decades with Kakashi. All Might has nothing remotly comparable to that, with him having fought few guys actually comparable to him, and all the fights boiling down to willpowering his way through.

All in all, Guy sunshin's in close, or just manages to do it without because All Might holds back his speed, and then a few well-placed hits knock All Might out because that's getting punched in the face releases chemicals in the brain that knock you out and turn the frogs gay
 
Ricsi-viragosi said:
Gai can also do the immensly terrifying technique known as stealth if he really needs it. And he can easily sunshine close range without much of any problem.

The speed argument is just dumb. What is equalized is All Might's full speed. Again, by your logic Saitama would thousands of times faster than any enemy he faces in speed equal.

And AP isn't much of a factor. Gai slaps people that are stronger than Sauce is with his 600 Megatons with a random fireball. AP is not a factor that is decisive here unless you want to argue All Might to be High 7-A, which you'll do in a Crt and not here.


For skill, it's not an argument. Gai is a child's older where even the dumbest guy can make the whole fuma shuriken plan, he has been the most skilled martial artist in his class with maybe Kakashi being comparable, has fought a war where every opponent you face tries to outwit you and kill you for the smallest of mistakes, and then trained for a good two decades with Kakashi. All Might has nothing remotly comparable to that, with him having fought few guys actually comparable to him, and all the fights boiling down to willpowering his way through.

All in all, Guy sunshin's in close, or just manages to do it without because All Might holds back his speed, and then a few well-placed hits knock All Might out because that's getting punched in the face releases chemicals in the brain that knock you out and turn the frogs gay
Click to expand...
Stealth and Sunshine?

The former side argued it and it was accepted in this thread. I merely used their logic.

600<850. Try again.

Gai participated in two wars fighting hundreds of shinobi. All might has fought tens of thousands with more hax than ninja. All might spams shockwaves while Gai runs out of stamina. GG. All might has a win con. Gai doesnt.
 
He does know stealth, yes. He was a genin that needed to use it. And shunshin. Autocorrect, again.

Ah, can ya spell appeal to popularity... I don't care what dumb made up logic others use, it's still dumb.

First of all, 1.5 AP advantage means nothing. Secondly, Gai casually slaps someone that can easily overpower Sasuke, who can just casually sit out a 650 megaton fireball as a setup for the actual attack.

The number of enemies you fight means nothing. All Might could casually slap towards the thousands he fought and they'd be déd, and he got past the hax by blitzing or by All for One deciding that making a massive fistis a better way to win than actually haxing. Show me onetime All Might showed any skill close to what any Jounin is required to have, let alone Gai.

You also just ignored his sparring parter being Kakashi. Kakashi fought thousands himself, and they were haxed, and they were far more skilled than anyone in MHA has really shown.
 
Why would I need the respect of someone memeing out. He mentioned pointed that were already debunked. He introduced stealth and sunshine which arent things he can do.
 
>Stealth

Basic thing every ninja can do

>Shunshin

Not even needed

The stat difference isnt even x2 so Gai just outskills to a huge degree.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

OneBleachHurricane
A Demon King VS A Noble Green Beast
Replies
13
Views
729
TegamiBachi25
TegamiBachi25
BlackCloverGlazer1
Yami and Nacht vs Kakashi and Might Guy
Replies
38
Views
2K
Joshyyy_64
Joshyyy_64
Therefir
Armored All Might vs Black Adam [4-0-0]
Replies
8
Views
2K
Jamesthetaker
Jamesthetaker
Maverick_Zero_X
All Might fights the 16th President of the United States
Replies
20
Views
3K
Mapl3Sy4up
XSOULOFCINDERX
All Might vs Dalamadur [0-0-0]
Replies
1
Views
939
XSOULOFCINDERX
XSOULOFCINDERX
Back
Top