- 12,523
- 3,490
- Thread starter
- #41
Knuckles Chaotix was retconned by Heroes so that's non-canon.Genericstickman said:
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
The Sonic Shuffle issue and by extension Sonic canon
- Thread starter ShadowWarrior1999
- Start date
- 40,457
- 12,924
Thanks buddy
- 8,836
- 9,473
Great to see you Ryu-Sama.
ShakeResounding
He/Him- 8,017
- 6,281
@Sera Funnily enough, you're probably old enough to be my mother lol.
That aside, the best answer for it being non-canon seems to be "... It's not canon?". If tjere's somwone that thinks it is canon then they'll probably share their reasons here.
That aside, the best answer for it being non-canon seems to be "... It's not canon?". If tjere's somwone that thinks it is canon then they'll probably share their reasons here.
- 6,472
- 6,557
I agree that Sonic Shuffle should be canon, but would this affect the god tiers in anyway?
- 5,464
- 794
I mean Maginary World was confirmed to be another universe in the Sonic Shuffle manual so it's a possibility
- 6,472
- 6,557
Then this might not affect anyone if there is no evidence to support that the God-Tiers scale to Illumina. Does that mean this would just be a cosmology upgrade and thats it?
- 769
- 192
There doesn't have to be a direct statement about Solaris being comparable to Illumina. Omitting Maginaryworld from Solaris' destruction takes more assumptions then including it.
- 40,457
- 12,924
By the way, Sera, while you're here, what level of 2-C is Solaris? When we upgraded the cast to scale to him, it was agreed to be 3 (past present future) by all of us, but nowadays, we're hearing he would've destroyed everything in existence. All alternate universes as well. What is your take on it?
- 769
- 192
How about a likely/possibly 2-B due to the unknown nature of the issue at hand. Or not.
- 40,457
- 12,924
Then that settles it
- 12,523
- 3,490
- Thread starter
- #59
I'll explain my take regarding Solaris and Maginaryworld. I was at first neutral, but I was convinced to agree with it.Dark649 said:
Whether or not Solaris is comparable to Illumina wouldn't matter in regarding him being able to destroy Maginaryworld. Solaris being said to have the power to destroy all of time and space would logically include the universes inside Maginaryworld, ergo 2-B. Illumina guards Maginaryworld yes, but it's akin to how a government rules a country. You wouldn't say a bomb that could destroy a country wouldn't be able to do it because a government rules over it. Solaris just needs be powerful enough to be able to destroy the multiverse, not compare to Illumina.
- 769
- 192
^^^^THIS^^^^
- 769
- 192
Why? there's no reason to omit Maginaryworld,or scaling to 2-B,but whatever,there's no contending with colored names.
- 769
- 192
So no compromise on 2-C possibly/likely 2-B?
- 769
- 192
Maginaryworld isn't a higher dimension from what Solaris was destroying though,otherwise Illumina would be High 2-A.
- 12,523
- 3,490
- Thread starter
- #65
@Dark649 Higher dimensions? Maginaryworld and Solaris are both 4D.
- 12,523
- 3,490
- Thread starter
- #67
Nah Maginaryworld isn't tier 1. That's extrapolation.
- 769
- 192
Tier 1? What the F?!
ShakeResounding
He/Him- 8,017
- 6,281
Sheesh. Tbh I thought you were in your 30s. I'm 17 so scratch that.Sera EX said:
Derailment aside, I'm neutral on 2-B Game Solaris. I will admit that Shadow makes a strong case for it though, but I just think it needs to be saved for a thread more focused on that subject alone rather than on a thread about Sonic canonicity.
- 12,523
- 3,490
- Thread starter
- #72
He tried to claim that the dreams inside 4th Dimension Space are all universes, so the stuff outside are even higher dimensional. While yes, the dreams do become universes, 4th Dimension Space is simply the world that stores the dreams.ED INFINITUM said:
- 769
- 192
Wow...
- 12,523
- 3,490
- Thread starter
- #74
Yes Eggman was in Sonic Shuffle.Dark649 said:
"Sonic and his friends must battle not only Void, but also Eggman, who learned of the power of the Precioustone and followed Sonic into Maginaryworld."
- 1,138
- 649
I say it's canon (^If my vote counts for anything)
ShakeResounding
He/Him- 8,017
- 6,281
There's gonna have to be a thread for this, peeps. A big one lol.
That aside, do we need more input here?
That aside, do we need more input here?
- 12,523
- 3,490
- Thread starter
- #78
Sera agreed that it was canon.
- 8,836
- 9,473
It's quite literally canon. You'd think that this would have been brought up before because literally nothing says otherwise.
- 769
- 192
You win some,you lose some.We may have lost 4-A,but we may gain 2-B.
Similar threads
