THE HYPE PAYED OFF

[LordXcano]

Anime finally gives us a time for the Boros kick, and it's less than 1.4 seconds B)

FTL kick to the Moon, this scales to Saitama for obvious reasons B))))))))))))))))))))))

 

[SomebodyData]

Is the anime even the primary canon?

Bruh the cinematic timeing in there is well very abusable

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

Is the anime even the primary canon?
Bruh the cinematic timeing in there is well very abusable

Its actually tertiary cannon but we are uing composites for opm until there are massive contradictions

 

[LordAizenSama]

it's not even the primary canon and you are justifying it with cinematic time.. It won't be happening

 

[SomebodyData]

Is the anime even the primary canon?
Bruh the cinematic timeing in there is well very abusable

Its actually tertiary cannon but we are uing composites for opm until there are massive contradictions

Wasn't there a sub rel calc for that feat for the manga?

 

[TheArcosian]

the Primary Canona is Ones Story get it into your Head pls. We need evalute from him since it his his first draft on how things play out

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

Is the anime even the primary canon?
Bruh the cinematic timeing in there is well very abusable

Its actually tertiary cannon but we are uing composites for opm until there are massive contradictions

Wasn't there a sub rel calc for that feat for the manga?

I think there was it came out to sub relativistic

 

[LordXcano]

it's not even the primary canon and you are justifying it with cinematic time.. It won't be happening

Cinematic time is the only time we have tho

@Somebody That calc literally just estimated the time it took to get from the Moon to Earth without any justification for it, they just went "Eh, this amount of minutes looks good"

 

[SomebodyData]

it's not even the primary canon and you are justifying it with cinematic time.. It won't be happening

Cinematic time is the only time we have tho
@Somebody That calc literally just estimated the time it took to get from the Moon to Earth without any justification for it, they just went "Eh, this amount of minutes looks good"

considering that dbz isnt gonna use cinematic timing either, I doubt that it'll be implemented

 

[LordXcano]

the Primary Canona is Ones Story get it into your Head pls. We need evalute from him since it his his first draft on how things play out

The first draft gives no time-frame nor any means to tell the time

 

[LordXcano]

considering that dbz isnt gonna use cinematic timing either, I doubt that it'll be implemented

Yeah but they also had a way to calc the time using the manga

Had it just been the anime they would've used it

 

[LordAizenSama]

Cinematic time is the only time we have tho

we have the manga for this. And i'm certain the sub-rel is for this feat already, you would need strong proof to debunk the calc until then it would stay as legit

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

it's not even the primary canon and you are justifying it with cinematic time.. It won't be happening

Cinematic time is the only time we have tho
@Somebody That calc literally just estimated the time it took to get from the Moon to Earth without any justification for it, they just went "Eh, this amount of minutes looks good"

considering that dbz isnt gonna use cinematic timing either, I doubt that it'll be implemented

They are still arguing whether to use the 4 or 17 seconds?

 

[LordXcano]

we have the manga for this. And i'm certain the sub-rel is for this feat already, you would need strong proof to debunk the calc until then it would stay as legit

Strong evidence: They literally just make up a figure

"Not sure of the circumstances, but yeah.
I heard about that one.
Like I said though, doesn't appear that it's feasible for more than a minute to have passed in total, if that, on account of the sheer strain of Boros' transformation and the sheer stupidity of keeping it up when he's just wasting precious stamina he might need.
Also, anyone able to be ****** enough to get the DC for this feat, or is that going to fall on me?"

"Yeah, as far as time frames go, a minute is pushing it contextually (the **** is Boros doing in a form that he notes is so ******* taxing a minute later, right?)
Which would mean up and back would be about 30 seconds a piece."

In fact, both of the quotes the calc gives for evidence for their speed agree that it would've been a short-ass timespan

 

[LordAizenSama]

If you have a problem with the calc and wanted the timeframe looked at again that is much more reasonable, but what you're trying to do (cinematic timing off of non-primary canon) is never going to happen unfortunately.

 

[LordXcano]

If you have a problem with the calc and wanted the timeframe looked at again that is much more reasonable, but what you're trying to do (cinematic timing off of non-primary canon) is never going to happen unfortunately.

The entire calc is a problem because they based it on a variable that they just made up.

It's like if I said "Well Spider-Man must've crossed this distance in 0.0000000000001 seconds because it looks fast and he says it's fast"

This is literally the only timeframe we have, so it's the only one we can use

And it's the only timeframe we'll EVER have because you literally cannot calc the kick speed

 

[LordAizenSama]

"a variable they just made up" is exactly what Madhouse did..

and again this is not the primary canon so it wouldn't be acceptable anyway.

 

[LordXcano]

"a variable they just made up" is exactly what Madhouse did..
and again this is not the primary canon so it wouldn't be acceptable anyway.

I mean the people doing the calc made up the variable

Also, we're using composites because there aren't any contradictions

And the anime is canon because both ONE and Murata had heavy involvment in it

 

[Kagemaru_Kurosuke]

Can someone make a Law of Ueki page?

 

[AllanSaiyan]

"a variable they just made up" is exactly what Madhouse did..
and again this is not the primary canon so it wouldn't be acceptable anyway.

I mean the people doing the calc made up the variable
Also, we're using composites because there aren't any contradictions

And the anime is canon because both ONE and Murata had heavy involvment in it

It doesn't matter if its canon or not the Manga timeframe>Anime timeframe because of what @Aizen said abuse of cinematic timing.

 

[CHILLVIBEZZ]

The manga has no time frame what are you talking about?

 

[LordAizenSama]

"a variable they just made up" is exactly what Madhouse did..
and again this is not the primary canon so it wouldn't be acceptable anyway.

I mean the people doing the calc made up the variable
Also, we're using composites because there aren't any contradictions

And the anime is canon because both ONE and Murata had heavy involvment in it

One Punch man is completely gauged off the manga iirc, we are not going off the web comic or anime at all, regardless of whether there is contradictions or not. it is not a composite profile

 

[AllanSaiyan]

The manga has no time frame what are you talking about?

Well they used the Manga to find the speed which is always more accurate and consistant most of the time.

 

[CHILLVIBEZZ]

it's an assumed timeframe...

 

[SomebodyData]

Can someone make a Law of Ueki page?

Why are you saying this here?

 

[LordXcano]

The manga has no time frame what are you talking about?

Well they used the Manga to find the speed which is always more accurate and consistant most of the time.

No, they didn't. They gave 2 quotes to support the timeframe both of which literally said "it was short so let's say 30 seconds".

Plus, that's with Saitama's jump not the kick anyway, you're providing wrong evidence.

The anime is the most accurate timeframe was have because it's the only timeframe we have, there is literally no reason to not use it.

 

[LordXcano]

"a variable they just made up" is exactly what Madhouse did..
and again this is not the primary canon so it wouldn't be acceptable anyway.

I mean the people doing the calc made up the variable
Also, we're using composites because there aren't any contradictions
And the anime is canon because both ONE and Murata had heavy involvment in it

One Punch man is completely gauged off the manga iirc, we are not going off the web comic or anime at all, regardless of whether there is contradictions or not. it is not a composite profile

A little while ago there was a discussion and it was settled that we'd use composites because there aren't any contradictions. That's why the Lightspeed Flash page has stats rather than "Unknown Unknown Unknown Unkown"

 

[AllanSaiyan]

The manga has no time frame what are you talking about?

Well they used the Manga to find the speed which is always more accurate and consistant most of the time.

No, they didn't. They gave 2 quotes to support the timeframe both of which literally said "it was short so let's say 30 seconds".
Plus, that's with Saitama's jump not the kick anyway, you're providing wrong evidence.

The anime is the most accurate timeframe was have because it's the only timeframe we have, there is literally no reason to not use it.

Ignore that i though we were talking about saitama.

 

[SomebodyData]

A little while ago there was a discussion and it was settled that we'd use composites because there aren't any contradictions. That's why the Lightspeed Flash page has stats rather than "Unknown Unknown Unknown Unkown"

Isn't the sub rel calculation a contradiction to the ftl one? Also, there are a few differences already.

 

[AllanSaiyan]

That kick is probably Relativistic if were using the anime.

 

[CHILLVIBEZZ]

Also the web comic is primary canon btw not the manga.......

 

[LordXcano]

A little while ago there was a discussion and it was settled that we'd use composites because there aren't any contradictions. That's why the Lightspeed Flash page has stats rather than "Unknown Unknown Unknown Unkown"

Isn't the sub rel calculation a contradiction to the ftl one? Also, there are a few differences already.

Have you not been reading the thread? The calc is based on a timeframe that they (the calc makers) literally explicitly assumed. The calc has such little evidence for it I'm surprised it was accepted at all.

The only "contradiction" thus far is Tatsumaki throwing a meteor at a dinosaur which isn't really a difference in stats more just Tatsumaki using her powers differently.

"That kick is probably Relativistic if were using the anime."

No, I counted. It's less than 1.4 seconds.

 

[LordXcano]

Ignore that i though we were talking about saitama.

The thing I'm using here is that Boros' kick was FTL and Saitama scales from that for obvious reasons

 

[SomebodyData]

Have you not been reading the thread? The calc is based on a timeframe that they (the calc makers) literally explicitly assumed. The calc has such little evidence for it I'm surprised it was accepted at all.

The only "contradiction" thus far is Tatsumaki throwing a meteor at a dinosaur which isn't really a difference in stats more just Tatsumaki using her powers differently.

"That kick is probably Relativistic if were using the anime."

No, I counted. It's less than 1.4 seconds.

"Only"? you forgot 'black hole' gravity level attack, different name for Boro's big attack, and the cinematic timing

 

[LordXcano]

"Only"? you forgot 'black hole' gravity level attack, different name for Boro's big attack, and the cinematic timing

Boros' big attack was actually translated properly, it is Collapsing Star in the Webcomic IIRC

Also, you keep saying "cinematic timing" but there's no evidence they slowed down/sped up Boros' kick

 

[ChaosTheory123]

Have you not been reading the thread? The calc is based on a timeframe that they (the calc makers) literally explicitly assumed. The calc has such little evidence for it I'm surprised it was accepted at all.

It's an informed assumption based on screwing around with a projectile motion sim to give me a rough idea of a time frame for the debris the kick hurtled into the air along with Saitama

Said debris was still well into the sky when he came crashing back down

Its only an assumption in so much that I can't bother getting a precision time frame for the debris seeing as I can't be bothered to measure the apex of the debris' travel into the air and its end point of free fall by the time we pan back to Boros and Saitama lands

 

[Thebluedash]

Also the web comic is primary canon btw not the manga.......

We're basing our profiles here mostly off the manga.

 

[SomebodyData]

Have you not been reading the thread? The calc is based on a timeframe that they (the calc makers) literally explicitly assumed. The calc has such little evidence for it I'm surprised it was accepted at all.

It's an informed assumption based on ******* around with a projectile motion sim to give me a rough idea of a time frame for the debris the kick hurtled into the air along with Saitama
Said debris was still well into the sky when he came crashing back down

Its only an assumption in so much that I can't bother getting a precision time frame for the debris seeing as I can't be bothered to measure the apex of the debris' travel into the air and its end point of free fall by the time we pan back to Boros and Saitama lands

• cough language filter pls

 

[LordXcano]

It's an informed assumption based on ******* around with a projectile motion sim to give me a rough idea of a time frame for the debris the kick hurtled into the air along with Saitama

Said debris was still well into the sky when he came crashing back down

Its only an assumption in so much that I can't bother getting a precision time frame for the debris seeing as I can't be bothered to measure the apex of the debris' travel into the air and its end point of free fall by the time we pan back to Boros and Saitama lands

No, they literally say "Well Boros was tired so it couldn't have been long plus there's debris still in the air"

Even then they're supporting a short timeframe? That'd make this even more consistent lol

 

[CHILLVIBEZZ]

We're basing our profiles here mostly off the manga.

I see