- 13,905
- 5,421
I don’t see why we can’t just use Garou’s actual reactions that’s listed for ftl character
seriously if we have the values right there for his reaction speed then why do we need to care about that timeframe?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
seriously if we have the values right there for his reaction speed then why do we need to care about that timeframe?
- 26,441
- 30,781
That last panel makes a good reaction imageyes it was and its facts
in terms of story and development it was far handled better
Garou vs Saitama had more meaning in it Seeing Saitama doing shit like this to Garou
was far better than wannabe DBZ spectacle
- 7,897
- 3,859
I guess we could but I think using FTL perception reaction would be calc stacking but I’m not sure
- 26,441
- 30,781
It's not approved. I asked some of the calc guys to evaluate it. Hopefully it'll be quick
- 13,905
- 5,421
If it’s considered calc stacking and that’s a reason against it being used then I hate this place so much
But Yknow what the high end from before with the shockwaves being frozen might at least compensate for it if it ends up not being used for that reason
- 487
- 477
Wow the new chapter sucked lol
- 206
- 71
yes because the arch just finished, hopefully in the ninja village arch there will be a small surprise like the ninja village leader doesn't meet saitama too soon so we can see the fight with flesy flash and sonick after a while it never appears
- 13,211
- 4,817
well its still better than the shingeki no kyojin ending
Recon1511
He/Him- 8,194
- 8,296
Didn't this or most of it already happened in chapter 136 though?
- 656
- 664
Everything from the beginning of MA arc until Garou comes out to the surface + chapter 153 is better than the webcomic, no one can deny that
Jibz
He/Him- 3,111
- 2,507
Didnt have nearly the same impact. It was way more action orientedl the webcomic was limited in that regard due to sucky art so they had to compensate with writing.
L take + Wash yo ass + Ratio + YB better
- 13,905
- 5,421
manga art outclasses webcomic 1 trillion times over honestly
- 23,433
- 21,176
- 13,905
- 5,421
Where’s the calc blog
- 16,274
- 24,986
One-Punch Man: Saitama and Garou Jump Around Io
vsbattles.fandom.com
Looks like travel speed is stuck at 10 x FTL
- 23,433
- 21,176
Not necessarily. Their concerns aren't really valid, so until they respond again, it's up in the air.One-Punch Man: Saitama and Garou Jump Around Io
Looks like travel speed is stuck at 10 x FTL
- 656
- 664
- 23,433
- 21,176
YB still betterSILENT
- 2,266
- 1,085
yes
My Opinion:
I like:
-Much of the fight between Bang and Garou, along with the past is good
-I like chapter 155, 161 and 162 a lot,
-And there are a good amount of moments here and there, both in dialogue and in action (something already common in One Punch Man)
The arc overall is very good (albeit with a noticeable drop off towards the end), and if we stick to just after Garou comes up from the surface, there's still a fair amount of work well done.
I don't see how this arc could be trash, although I can notice serious problems in some parts (Golden Sperm only appears to finish destroying Darshine's pride | The water monster does basically nothingin his Ocean form | Platinum sperm steals phrases that fit him better to Garou | Garou is inconsistent | too much foreshadow for future arcs that interrupt the current one | exaggerates by emphasizing Garou's good side [although being fair since Garou first appeared this happens] | special techniques that end doing nothing, etc.)
- 656
- 664
- 190
- 108
The 1.3 millisecond timeframe is indeed the only one that makes the most sense, we can't deny it, even this timeframe is still relatively low, due to the accelerating garou that continues to increase
- 2,619
- 1,348
manga monster was going okay until the time travel shit came in and erased his memories. the messages between both versions are entirely different.
Can we just shut the **** about WC better when there's zero shit to compared them othe thanr "it was written better" no the **** it wasnt. It was written differently to tell something different. that's it.
Can we just shut the **** about WC better when there's zero shit to compared them othe thanr "it was written better" no the **** it wasnt. It was written differently to tell something different. that's it.
- 7,199
- 7,583
The manga version of the Psychic Sisters Arc is probably gonna be very, very different. I don't envision the manga going back to being like the webcomic just cause this arc ended tbh. Especially when Tatsumaki's character is very different already in the manga, more sympathetic and relatable.
I also think Psykos will have a lot more to say than what she did in the webcomic, considering the Psykorochi thing.
We might get good feats during the Saitama Vs. Tatsumaki fight. I know Coomander will be praying for something to scale Tatsumaki to CF Garou.
I also think Psykos will have a lot more to say than what she did in the webcomic, considering the Psykorochi thing.
We might get good feats during the Saitama Vs. Tatsumaki fight. I know Coomander will be praying for something to scale Tatsumaki to CF Garou.
- 7,897
- 3,859
tatsumaki will be possessed by god
- 2,619
- 1,348
and brainwash her to think manga bad and wc good
- 656
- 664
WC Tatsumaki is a *****, Manga Tatsumaki is a likeable superhot ***** that's the only difference + Tatsu still want to kill Psykos for everything she did and Fubuki won't let her
- 2,619
- 1,348
wtf does a third eye have to do anything.
- 7,199
- 7,583
Both good.
Tbh, the manga is pure eye candy and entertainment injected into the reader's retinas, but the webcomic has a better written and much more investing story, also better humor.
Manga is for Dragon Ball type fans. Webcomic is for Hunter X Hunter type fans. It just facts.
- 2,619
- 1,348
i will give you that but i disagree. i think they are just written differently.
- 23,433
- 21,176
In the webcomic, she saw the future similar to Shibabawa, which is why she was traumatized and can not speak anymore.
- 656
- 664
That will happen in the next arc + Fubuki vs Psykos
- 16,286
- 17,801
Agreed.
- 7,199
- 7,583
Manga writing mid tbh. I don't hate on it as much as others do but it definitely lacks a lot of the investment and meaningful tones/messages that the WC gave/gives. Right now the manga has been reliant on fan service given either through interactions with big mysterious characters, namely God, or through simple action. In recent times, and by that I mean a vast portion of the late Garou/Monster Association arc, the manga's writing hasn't been unique, meaningful, or even very relatable. I can barely even care about the story right now.
Similar threads
