- 7,108
- 2,593
uh no,is not bad,is actually better
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 7,897
- 3,857
king
- 22,774
- 49,551
not really
but im not gonna waste my time on this shit this arc was mid
Webcomic version was better than pandering to Vs nerds so they could could splooge over DBZ esque feats
- 7,108
- 2,593
God, again with the web comic is better argument
- 22,774
- 49,551
yes it was and its facts
in terms of story and development it was far handled better
Garou vs Saitama had more meaning in it Seeing Saitama doing shit like this to Garou
was far better than wannabe DBZ spectacle
- 7,108
- 2,593
there's god ******* again, when basically the one who made the web comic was the same one who made the arc story.yes it was and its facts
in terms of story and development it was far handled better
Garou vs Saitama had more meaning in it Seeing Saitama doing shit like this to Garou
was far better than wannabe DBZ spectacle
Also, why? Otherwise I would hate if it was a copy and paste of the web comic,i hate series that are copy paste of they original work(copy paste in a totalyty)
- 3,949
- 5,761
I feel like it’s absolutely fair to compare the pros and cons of the story written by the same mangaka.
Especially considering how amazing the monster arc was written in the web comic it’s fair to point out how the manga doesn’t reach the same writing level
- 22,774
- 49,551
Why the **** not it doesn't have to copy to a T but could've follow the main points that made the arc so much fun to read thru then this mid shit
what exactly we got that was worth this?
oh i see "THE FEATS" that wat made it worth it
seeing folks jerking off Saitama Debatable Star feat or him ******* up Jupiter and its moon up was much better
Oh Garou development getting tossed aside for Him pulling "a monkey see monkey do" gimmick with Baldy
truly worth it
- 7,897
- 3,857
You hate nearly half the manga?
- 7,108
- 2,593
me,i don't hate the manga,you is the one who hate the manga,i like this manga,i hate the web comic because looks like bad(literraly,looks like HXH manga in the lastest chapters)You hate nearly half the manga?
- 7,108
- 2,593
puts his face hitting your face with his face Do you think the manga is bad just for that, what about the story, what about the dialogues, none of that matters? It's practically the same as the web comic, Garou says he's the bad guy, when he's not, he's just someone that thinks that he is evil
- 7,897
- 3,857
10/10 reasoning
- 7,108
- 2,593
I don't know if it's sarcasm or it's sarcasm.
- 22,774
- 49,551
Manga had needless redraws, pointless filler and the story feels incoherent when compared to the webcomic of the same arc
to say its the same is disingenuous Garou ordeal with the heroes had more oomph in the WC,His fight with Saitama had more Oomph in the WC
we lost this for Darkshine getting rekt by an ugly acid man
- 793
- 367
The story of the manga is terrible. They straight up had zero development for any of the characters. Nothings even been brought up to counter garous ideology (if anything cement it at the end). Other than gaslighting him on being a hero a bunch.
Even when they had the opportunity to do something with saitama having everyone around him die they just decided to kill of his memories and make everything that happened pointless.
Idk about the webcomic writing if its anything special. The only saving grace for the manga is art.
Even when they had the opportunity to do something with saitama having everyone around him die they just decided to kill of his memories and make everything that happened pointless.
Idk about the webcomic writing if its anything special. The only saving grace for the manga is art.
- 7,897
- 3,857
it’s sarcasm
- 2,926
- 1,399
The real thing is that after Garou rose to the surface, from that point on the manga is rubbish compared to the webcomic, I said it lightly.
- 19,367
- 16,991
Literally my signature.
- 13,903
- 5,405
Wow, that really must have come from the heart
anyways be patient like everybody else sir adult
- 206
- 71
IO calculations have been obtained, right? then there is no reason to delay CRT
Sniper670
He/Him- 6,409
- 1,365
What's wrong with it
- 19,367
- 16,991
It needs to be evaluated.
- 7,108
- 2,593
at least that how i view thatWhat's wrong with it
- 7,108
- 2,593
bro,ya vi esa batalla bro,ya la vi,la vi hace años(4 años)que crees que no lo se
- 13,903
- 5,405
I don’t see why we can’t just use Garou’s actual reactions that’s listed for ftl character
seriously if we have the values right there for his reaction speed then why do we need to care about that timeframe?
- 25,023
- 27,038
That last panel makes a good reaction imageyes it was and its facts
in terms of story and development it was far handled better
Garou vs Saitama had more meaning in it Seeing Saitama doing shit like this to Garou
was far better than wannabe DBZ spectacle
- 7,897
- 3,857
I guess we could but I think using FTL perception reaction would be calc stacking but I’m not sure
- 25,023
- 27,038
It's not approved. I asked some of the calc guys to evaluate it. Hopefully it'll be quick
- 13,903
- 5,405
If it’s considered calc stacking and that’s a reason against it being used then I hate this place so much
But Yknow what the high end from before with the shockwaves being frozen might at least compensate for it if it ends up not being used for that reason
- 487
- 476
Wow the new chapter sucked lol
- 206
- 71
yes because the arch just finished, hopefully in the ninja village arch there will be a small surprise like the ninja village leader doesn't meet saitama too soon so we can see the fight with flesy flash and sonick after a while it never appears
- 7,108
- 2,593
Reread the last couple chapters, and im lowkey disappointed. Been waiting for this for well over a year at this point just for a worse version of the original storyline
well its still better than the shingeki no kyojin ending
Recon1511
He/Him- 7,357
- 6,400
Didn't this or most of it already happened in chapter 136 though?Reread the last couple chapters, and im lowkey disappointed. Been waiting for this for well over a year at this point just for a worse version of the original storyline
- 656
- 663
Everything from the beginning of MA arc until Garou comes out to the surface + chapter 153 is better than the webcomic, no one can deny that
