STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

[AtomicSekiro]

Metal Bat clearly doesn’t scale to Garou’s speed. Garou is extremely casually jogging in this chapter most of the time and it’s also very gag-y so it’s hard to find what is a serious feat or not.

Saitama’s Punch created light?

Wonder how big the punch’s shockwave compares to Psykorochi’s first god beam.

 

[Lightning_XXI]

I know you guys like the debate and all but, yeah, the reason for being closed wasn't because it was stomp for her, be careful with this type of stuff because it can cause some stress for the mod who closed

 

[AtomicSekiro]

”it has already been proven that she has no passive barriers”

Plugging your ears and going “LA LA LA NO ITS NOT TRUE TATSUMAKI DOESNT HAVE PASSIVE BARRIERS TATSUMAKI GETS STOMPED BECAUSE SHE ISNT ALLOWED DURABILITY LALALALAL PLATINUM SPERM ALWAYS WINS LALALALAL” isn’t proof. Lmao.

Go to Reddit and make those claims. It’d be funny seeing the entire sub laugh at you. Final response. Go to Reddit if you want to continue being wrong.

 

[Dienomite22]

If we assume SG is the same as EC, then its humanoid face's dura isn't comparable to the dura of its mandibles and carapace. Metal Bat could damage the humanoid face, but he shook his own bat against EC's carapace.

Doesnt Bang and bomb scale to EC for punching its face?

 

[Lightning_XXI]

Doesnt Bang and bomb scale to EC for punching its face?

They shattered its carapace aswell

 

[Dienomite22]

They shattered its carapace aswell

wasnt that because WWICF semi-hax?

 

[Muuuuh]

”it has already been proven that she has no passive barriers”

Plugging your ears and going “LA LA LA NO ITS NOT TRUE TATSUMAKI DOESNT HAVE PASSIVE BARRIERS TATSUMAKI GETS STOMPED BECAUSE SHE ISNT ALLOWED DURABILITY LALALALAL PLATINUM SPERM ALWAYS WINS LALALALAL” isn’t proof. Lmao.

Go to Reddit and make those claims. It’d be funny seeing the entire sub laugh at you. Final response. Go to Reddit if you want to continue being wrong.

I'm not on reddit, I'm here, talking to you who can't stand anything and make up a bunch of things that aren't even on the webcomic


I want proof that she was bad before being hit by GS


because this is what happened: She before being attacked is fine

she being blitz

After being attacked, she is covered in blood and Zombieman says that she is in a state of damage.

You are free to prove your point. Now you should stop this whining saying to go to reddit or ask if anyone has read the webcomic

 

[AtomicSekiro]

I have no idea how we’re going to get ”absolute evil” Garou at this point…

 

[Magmag]

Might be against the rules for calcs but can u get a rough size for EOW since he is technically on the edge of earth and there’s a curve.

 

[Swagoorago]

Is that from the calcs from last chapter? Cuz this chapter has much more clear shots for an exact size

SC kept changing in size whenever there is a human near him , plus i doubt we're seeing like a 1/3 of him out side of the hole if not less considering how long EC was

 

[AtomicSekiro]

Might be against the rules for calcs but can u get a rough size for EOW since he is technically on the edge of earth and there’s a curve.

That’s iffy at best considering now Murata draws scale.

Tatsumaki’s world spear would be in the same boat due to one panel, yet that’s clearly not true.

Using the same panel, Garou is the size of a building.

 

[Peter1129]

So Chinese translation has started. Sage Centipede said Garou was really strong when he attacked him. And he told Garou not to move otherwise Evil Ocean Water will shoot down the helicopter with the kids in it. Basically taking a hostage. Guess Evil Ocean Water took Black Sperm’s hostage role.

 

[Magmag]

That’s iffy at best considering now Murata draws scale.

Tatsumaki’s world spear would be in the same boat due to one panel, yet that’s clearly not true.

Using the same panel, Garou is the size of a building.

It’s a leveled panel, as in like no curve for EOW, Garou is closer so he seems bigger but EOW is eye level with the panel.

 

[NikHelton]

We don't have an English translation yet, but the new chapter is full of surprises. And despite a number of disadvantages, it did not disappoint me, unlike the last chapter of Kengan.

Damn, Bita's power surge is way too big and doesn't seem to be justified. We don't even have a long beating like in the first fight with Garou. What if the punch that his sister stopped was already a 6-C, lmao?
Although at the beginning of the chapter, the Beat just gets in the way, but he grows in strength in ten-mile steps without any of the damage that he needed before.

He also blocks blows with the antennae of the Centipede, moves faster than the antennae, jumps to a height of tens of kilometers and catches up with Garou. On the last page, he does damage to her along with Garou.

Hell, I was expecting the Bat to reach about the speed of the Flash and give a little fight to Garou, but I never expected him to be faster than the Flash and possibly Platinum and already 6-C. What crazy shit is he going to do with Fighting Spirit?

 

[AtomicSekiro]

Why does Tatsumaki have a “feats” section on her profile with only 2 feats?

 

[AtomicSekiro]

It’s a leveled panel, as in like no curve for EOW, Garou is closer so he seems bigger but EOW so eye level with the panel.

Again, it’s iffy at best. Scale gets REALLY weird in small panels. Especially with Murata.

 

[NikHelton]

But actually I'm frustrated with scale issues. On some pages, the Centipede is larger than the hole, on others it is of great height, and on others it is 10 meters wide.
Should I do a Downgrade?


Also, Saitama's serious punch is not very impressive and looks superfluous. Moreover, Natural Water survived it, which is not very cool.

 

[Phoenks]

Might be against the rules for calcs but can u get a rough size for EOW since he is technically on the edge of earth and there’s a curve.

Can't be used because the curvature of the planet is obviously greatly exaggerated.

 

[Magmag]

Can't be used because the curvature of the planet is obviously greatly exaggerated.

Why would u say that.

 

[Magmag]

But actually I'm frustrated with scale issues. On some pages, the Centipede is larger than the hole, on others it is of great height, and on others it is 10 meters wide.
Should I do a Downgrade?


Also, Saitama's serious punch is not very impressive and looks superfluous. Moreover, Natural Water survived it, which is not very cool.

Perspective and warping angles cause that, and u have to forget about size to see characters fighting.

 

[AtomicSekiro]

Unless he was gaining fighting spirit the entire time he was in hospital, there is no way in hell Metal Bat scales to anything in speed here. He somewhat scales to the Centipede but the Centipede doesn’t scale to Garou at all.

He’s not going from Human Garou level to Faster than Flashy Flash sitting on his butt for a few days.

 

[DarthSpiderr]

Most likely it will be recalculated, but the attempt is not torture

 

[DarthSpiderr]

Well, this proverb in English sounds very strange

 

[CheatHydra]

Most likely it will be recalculated, but the attempt is not torture

EWO being High 6-A is surprisingly consistent especially if it survived a Saitama Serious Punch. I don't think it will get accepted tho, could be ruled as an outlier.

 

[M3X_2.0]

what the **** was this chapter, simply amazing

anyway, what's the conclusion about new ratings and feats from the new chapter? We have some stuff to calc.

 

[Kin201]

We are thinking that Metal Bat's feats are outliers or PIS, so we can forget about him for now. However; if next chapter after they beat SC, and have a one-on-one fight, we can continue to discuss this.

We should focus about calculating stuff.

 

[M3X_2.0]

Hmm cool, though his bat can get some durability upgrade

 

[Lightning_XXI]

His Bat surely deserves one

His AP and speed, however, shouldn't scale for now

 

[M3X_2.0]

If we get more context we could maybe add "X with Metal Bat", that is, only if it's confirmed that ge gets stronger with the bat, just like Flashy with his sword

 

[Muuuuh]

I don't know, Bat didn't do any real damage to Elder Centipede, he couldn't beat even the weakest version, and he didn't have time to evolve because he just arrived in battle

 

[M3X_2.0]

In english dude.

 

[DarthSpiderr]

Hm. If the evil water has a width of 1400 kilometers, then from such a height the Earth must be round


OH YES, OROCHI'S FEAT THE LEVEL OF A LARGE PLANET BECAUSE THE PLANET IN THE ONE PUNCH MAN IS A THOUSAND TIMES BIGGER IN THE DIAMETER OF OURS

 

[M3X_2.0]

Your link isn't working

 

[DarthSpiderr]

Your link isn't working

I edited

 

[DarthSpiderr]

Most likely it will be recalculated, but the attempt is not torture

Can someone send this calculation to the thread where the calculations are checked?

 

[Ourosboros]

what the **** is going on with the powerscaling...

I figured it would happen, Murata's writing most of this right now and he's on the "whoever is participating in the fight right now will scale to whoever I need them to scale to train". High 6-C Metal Bat I guess

 

[M3X_2.0]

Most likely it will be recalculated, but the attempt is not torture

You can calc Lifting Strength for jumping feats. Assuming your distance is correct, we do the following for Metal Bat:

38.425871km is 38425.871m

PE: 38425.871 * 9.8 * 67.3 = 25343398.9593 Joules

LS: 25343398.9593/0.56 (1/3 of his height) = 45256069.5702 newtons or 4614.834 metric tons, this is Class M iirc

 

[DarthSpiderr]

You can calc Lifting Strength for jumping feats. Assuming your distance is correct, we do the following for Metal Bat:

38.425871km is 38425.871m

PE: 38425.871 * 9.8 * 67.3 = 25343398.9593 Joules

LS: 25343398.9593/0.56 (1/3 of his height) = 45256069.5702 newtons or 4614.834 metric tons, this is Class M iirc

Metal Bat Class G, but that's interesting, I'll add it. But my question is, why do we divide his KE by 1/3 of his height?

 

[M3X_2.0]

G

It's M.

 

[M3X_2.0]

Metal Bat Class G, but that's interesting, I'll add it. But my question is, why do we divide his KE by 1/3 of his height?

It's the distance his legs "crossed" in order to perform the jump.