- 20,083
- 10,871
So some of the abilities for Sonic kinda throws me off, especially with either the lack of evidence or arguments that don't make sense. If there's any further explanations on these abilities I'd be happy to see them.
Classic Sonic:
Toon Force and elasticity: Is this considered toon force for being flattened? This looks more like body control unless being squashed flat is enough to get toon force and elasticity? This applies to everyone else with this ability. (ACCEPTED)
Mind restoration: Is this actually restoring minds cause the clip just shows Tails getting his body back, as opposed to his mind being lost and being restored. (REMOVING)
Super Forms:
Acausality type 4: So uhh, what part of the scan here implies that turning into a Super makes you function on a completely different set of laws/cause and effect rules? Because all I see is Sonic floating around until he activates the emeralds to go super, and is able to move fine, which just looks like resistance to Gravity Manipulation more than type 4 Acausality unless there's some context I'm missing here. (ACCEPTED)
Modern Sonic:
Extrasensory perception: Isn't this just enhanced senses or just his precog kicking in? Cause that's already being used for those and it doesn't mention he's using a sixth sense here. (ACCEPTED)
Immortality Negation: The types of immortality that's being negated should be in his page. (DONE)
Power Nullification: Is breaking magic barriers with the sword stated to nullify its power? Because this sounds more like an AP thing than a Power Null thing. (REMOVING)
Holy Manipulation: I don't know how it being called miracle gems or causing miracles to happen is enough for Holy Manipulation, the Shadow statement might help but that should be elaborated on as that looks like the good ending and Shadow's just fighting off random demons that appeared, nothing mentions it being a divine power that can strike down all evil in the way the Master Sword from Zelda is. (ACCEPTED)
Space-Time Manipulation and offensive time travel: So this is a bit confusing, wasn't this used for immeasurable speed to argue Sonic Silver and Shadow is able to move across time itself to fight Solaris in different points in time? Doesn't this feel redundant especially when the normal chaos emeralds already have these abilities, albeit not the offensive time travel part. (RANGE AT BEST)
Death hax resistance via Void affecting Nature Zone: The link isn't loading anything here, so I'd like to see. (REMOVING)
Muketi Monitor Power Null: Isn't this just more invulnerability if he becomes immune to other attacks with this? (ACCEPTED)
Shadow:
Greater Cold resistance: Does he break out of it like a QTE in this clip because it just looks like he just takes damage and it wears off, which doesn't look like a resistance feat to me if he doesn't break out of it easily. (ACCEPTED)
Void Manipulation: Is the only thing going for it based off the name? Cause we don't give abilities based on the name of an ability unless stated it can control a literal void. (POSSIBLE VOID HAX)
Concept hax (type 1): This is just NPI, interacting with an abstract concept would just be that, Concept hax would work if he literally kills a concept itself. Also why would attacking Solaris' Conscious be considered concept hax? That just seems like NPI as well. (REMOVING)
Chaos:
Mid-High regen: Isn't this High-Mid? Being able to come back from being shattered is High-Mid, Mid-High is for when you're completely vaporized a la Majin Buu. (POSSIBLY MID-HIGH)
Resisting Ifrit's abilities for anyone in Sonic Rivals: Is this remotely stated or shown to be passive abilities? Cause the one clip on "binding one's soul" doesn't really tell me that it's passive, let alone something he does a lot in a fight and the cast resisting it. (ACCEPTED)
The Chaos Emeralds:
Life Manipulation: How exactly is this life manipulation? Its just giving energy to any living being, it's not creating life itself. (REMOVING)
King Arthur:
What exactly is the explanation for his type 8 immortality? Cause nothing is explained there. (ACCEPTED)
Void:
Death Manipulation: It mentions the corrosion of the forest is causing them to die, not some supernatural spell that just inflicts death, this should be just corrosion inducement at best. (REMOVING)
Mephilis:
Low godly regen: This isn't regeneration, it's just shapeshifting. The fact he's forming his body into Shadow's well... shadow and just pops up after his minions die is just shapeshifting at best, it's only regen if his body gets destroyed and all that was left was his spirit and regenerated all of that. (ACCEPTED)
Iblis:
Low godly regen: Stating to resurrect while being an energy being doesn't really give me Low-Godly vibe, just that its incorporeal in its true state and that it comes back to live, which is type 4 Immortality at best. (ACCEPTED)
Solaris:
Type 4 Acausality: What part of this explanation gives type 4? Cause I don't see how hitting him in all points in time means it functions in a different set of laws and not just being temporally omnipresent. (REMOVING)
The End:
Abstract Existence and Nonexistent physiology: Being the embodiment of death is type 2 AE, not type 1 since embodiment means being a physical form of something, also is it remotely elaborated on by "infinite and nothing" cause that seems too vague for NEP. (POSSIBLE TYPE 2 ABSTRACT STAYS, NEP GOES AWAY)
Concept (type 1) and Perception Manipulation: What makes this type 1? Cause I don't see any scans that imply it's independant of reality, also perception manipulation sounds more like shapeshifting if it changes its form based on how people perceive it, also also the link has like no translations on what the devs are saying so that would be nice to see. (PERCEPTION STAYS, CONCEPT IS REMOVED)
Classic Sonic:
Toon Force and elasticity: Is this considered toon force for being flattened? This looks more like body control unless being squashed flat is enough to get toon force and elasticity? This applies to everyone else with this ability. (ACCEPTED)
Mind restoration: Is this actually restoring minds cause the clip just shows Tails getting his body back, as opposed to his mind being lost and being restored. (REMOVING)
Super Forms:
Acausality type 4: So uhh, what part of the scan here implies that turning into a Super makes you function on a completely different set of laws/cause and effect rules? Because all I see is Sonic floating around until he activates the emeralds to go super, and is able to move fine, which just looks like resistance to Gravity Manipulation more than type 4 Acausality unless there's some context I'm missing here. (ACCEPTED)
Modern Sonic:
Extrasensory perception: Isn't this just enhanced senses or just his precog kicking in? Cause that's already being used for those and it doesn't mention he's using a sixth sense here. (ACCEPTED)
Immortality Negation: The types of immortality that's being negated should be in his page. (DONE)
Power Nullification: Is breaking magic barriers with the sword stated to nullify its power? Because this sounds more like an AP thing than a Power Null thing. (REMOVING)
Holy Manipulation: I don't know how it being called miracle gems or causing miracles to happen is enough for Holy Manipulation, the Shadow statement might help but that should be elaborated on as that looks like the good ending and Shadow's just fighting off random demons that appeared, nothing mentions it being a divine power that can strike down all evil in the way the Master Sword from Zelda is. (ACCEPTED)
Space-Time Manipulation and offensive time travel: So this is a bit confusing, wasn't this used for immeasurable speed to argue Sonic Silver and Shadow is able to move across time itself to fight Solaris in different points in time? Doesn't this feel redundant especially when the normal chaos emeralds already have these abilities, albeit not the offensive time travel part. (RANGE AT BEST)
Death hax resistance via Void affecting Nature Zone: The link isn't loading anything here, so I'd like to see. (REMOVING)
Muketi Monitor Power Null: Isn't this just more invulnerability if he becomes immune to other attacks with this? (ACCEPTED)
Shadow:
Greater Cold resistance: Does he break out of it like a QTE in this clip because it just looks like he just takes damage and it wears off, which doesn't look like a resistance feat to me if he doesn't break out of it easily. (ACCEPTED)
Void Manipulation: Is the only thing going for it based off the name? Cause we don't give abilities based on the name of an ability unless stated it can control a literal void. (POSSIBLE VOID HAX)
Concept hax (type 1): This is just NPI, interacting with an abstract concept would just be that, Concept hax would work if he literally kills a concept itself. Also why would attacking Solaris' Conscious be considered concept hax? That just seems like NPI as well. (REMOVING)
Chaos:
Mid-High regen: Isn't this High-Mid? Being able to come back from being shattered is High-Mid, Mid-High is for when you're completely vaporized a la Majin Buu. (POSSIBLY MID-HIGH)
Resisting Ifrit's abilities for anyone in Sonic Rivals: Is this remotely stated or shown to be passive abilities? Cause the one clip on "binding one's soul" doesn't really tell me that it's passive, let alone something he does a lot in a fight and the cast resisting it. (ACCEPTED)
The Chaos Emeralds:
Life Manipulation: How exactly is this life manipulation? Its just giving energy to any living being, it's not creating life itself. (REMOVING)
King Arthur:
What exactly is the explanation for his type 8 immortality? Cause nothing is explained there. (ACCEPTED)
Void:
Death Manipulation: It mentions the corrosion of the forest is causing them to die, not some supernatural spell that just inflicts death, this should be just corrosion inducement at best. (REMOVING)
Mephilis:
Low godly regen: This isn't regeneration, it's just shapeshifting. The fact he's forming his body into Shadow's well... shadow and just pops up after his minions die is just shapeshifting at best, it's only regen if his body gets destroyed and all that was left was his spirit and regenerated all of that. (ACCEPTED)
Iblis:
Low godly regen: Stating to resurrect while being an energy being doesn't really give me Low-Godly vibe, just that its incorporeal in its true state and that it comes back to live, which is type 4 Immortality at best. (ACCEPTED)
Solaris:
Type 4 Acausality: What part of this explanation gives type 4? Cause I don't see how hitting him in all points in time means it functions in a different set of laws and not just being temporally omnipresent. (REMOVING)
The End:
Abstract Existence and Nonexistent physiology: Being the embodiment of death is type 2 AE, not type 1 since embodiment means being a physical form of something, also is it remotely elaborated on by "infinite and nothing" cause that seems too vague for NEP. (POSSIBLE TYPE 2 ABSTRACT STAYS, NEP GOES AWAY)
Concept (type 1) and Perception Manipulation: What makes this type 1? Cause I don't see any scans that imply it's independant of reality, also perception manipulation sounds more like shapeshifting if it changes its form based on how people perceive it, also also the link has like no translations on what the devs are saying so that would be nice to see. (PERCEPTION STAYS, CONCEPT IS REMOVED)
Last edited: