Sonic Question Time: So I’ve been thinking about the whole “who deserves their own game” discussion that has been brought to the table thanks to Shadow Generations, and one thing I’ve noticed is how a lot of the ideas sorta revolve around the already existing cast. Not that that’s a bad thing or anything, but it makes me wonder what ideas could come from throwing a character into a (mostly) new setting. Think of it as the Sonic equivalent to some of the Mario spin-offs like Wario Land, Donkey Kong Country or Princess Peach Showtime.
There’s a few semi-concepts that come into my mind such as an Amy game with a magic system or something, however one slightly more fleshed out idea I have revolves around Metal Sonic. After a fight with Sonic aboard one of Eggman’s battleships, Metal finds himself knocked off and sent plummeting into the ocean and eventually washes up on some remote island. Due to the damage he’s taken he finds himself unable to leave the island (kinda like with Mecha Sonic in Scrapnik Island), so the game revolves around him exploring the island to either find someone to repair him or find something that could help him leave. Eventually he learns of the antagonists of the game who want to cause some kind of catastrophe mentioned in a legend, and he becomes fixated on preventing the catastrophe once he learns about a blue hedgehog being prophesied to stand against it.