- 43,111
- 37,253
- Thread starter
- #121
DonePut me here
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
DonePut me here
Is it GoW going down to 8-C? Cause the matches there would be basedI've got a good compromise solution, getting back here in some hours. Just wait a bit, okay?
Nah.Is it GoW going down to 8-C? Cause the matches there would be based
This is still happening regardless of whatever end of the stick SK gets guysSK Kratos would be merged with canon Kratos and here is what it'll be like:
An SK key where Kratos is basically Norse Kratos, Innate powers (Demigod and Norse), Resistances (Demigod, GoW and Norse) and All, but none of his Norse equipment (That includes the Leviathan Axe, Draupnir Spear, the Shields, Weapon Handles, Runes, Enchantments, Talismans, Amulets, Berserker Hilts and then some).
That might work with Shovel Knight but not with Kratos as per the above data.My idea is simple. Can't we simply split Shovel Knight in two keys, one for canon and the other for GoW?
A bit like Buzz Lightyear and other Toy Story characters have keys for a Movie and KH key for the exact same reason.
I have suggested this for SK in fact, not Kratos.That might work with Shovel Knight but not with Kratos as per the above data.
What about option A then?Well, that obviously changes things. Thank you for the information.
However, the underlying point, and everything else with it, still applies. We've established a strong precedent in CRTs in the past that, even with explicit statements, we do not take things such as responses to fan questions on Twitter as adequate proof for profile revisions. The old DMC 3-A ratings based on Kamiya's Twitter comments come to mind - we do not give ratings based off of author social media comments even when the depiction in the media is tenuous, let alone contradicted like this.
And furthermore, the problem regarding Death of the Author still applies. The depiction of Kratos in Shovel Knight provably is not the same as the Kratos that would be present at the purported point in the timeline. The media contradicts the author's claims, and in this situation, we would take the media. Without an explanation for these contradictions, we cannot simply take this at face value.
Hmmmmmm, that would be similar to Option B in a sense.I have suggested this for SK in fact, not Kratos.
I don't endorse the canonicity here, and I don't endorse the merger either.What about option A then?
And what do you think on the SK Kratos merge with Canon Kratos?
Would this mean SK resists conceptual manipulation lol
No, it's not a "likely", but a straight up new key.Hmmmmmm, that would be similar to Option B in a sense.
Do I put you in Agree with nothing being canon and nothing being done?I don't endorse the canonicity here, and I don't endorse the merger either.
Classy, you’re almost as annoying as I am nowYou don't know what death of the author means. I'm not debating with someone of your level of intelligence. Staff that accept this are wankers. Not sorry.
Yes.Do I put you in Agree with nothing being canon and nothing being done?
Only the Type 3 stuff, and that is a big IF.Would this mean SK resists conceptual manipulation lol
I see.No, it's not a "likely", but a straight up new key.
Shovel Knight | God of War
Former counting just the SK stuff, latter also canon GoW lore, a bit also how SCP handles it.
DoneYes.
Already tagged a lot of staff, let's just wait for them to voice their opinion. If they disagree, CRT is rejected. If they accept it, we hash out which option they accepted.I am 50% sure that this is gonna become a staff discussion thread so I’d just like to ask for speaking privileges in advance
So I’m guessing this is a staff only thread now? If not, then I haven’t broken any rules here (Zamasu was the one calling the agreeing people low IQ wankers), so I don’t see why you’re telling me I can’t speak. It’s gonna have to either become a staff thread or continue being open for discussion.Also @Zamasu_Chan and @ZillertheBucko, stop ******* bickering, agree to disagree, voice your votes and move the **** on. You've done what you can, let staff handle it now.
Done@DaReaperMan Put me up as neutral for all choices.
GoW isn't canon to Shovel Knight
If you keep bickering, yes, it will be a staff-only thread soon.So I’m guessing this is a staff only thread now? If not, then I haven’t broken any rules here (Zamasu was the one calling the agreeing people low IQ wankers), so I don’t see why you’re telling me I can’t speak. It’s gonna have to either become a staff thread or continue being open for discussion.
Option D then?Honestly, just give Shovel Knight a God of War key, like Strym says. Seems the most sensible way to do this.
AddedFor now, yeah.