- 8,161
- 12,433
Not at all what I was implying, but okA weapon having a charging time means its not lightspeed? Since when?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Not at all what I was implying, but okA weapon having a charging time means its not lightspeed? Since when?
No, she is projecting raw light with her copy of penny's beam as penny's beam does not have a physical projectile. And no, there is no such thing as 'energy dust'So Velvet is making a hard light projection of Penny’s beam. How does that prove anything about Penny’s beam being a hard light projection itself and not just energy? Energy dust exists too if I’m correct from Weiss’s rant in volume 1.
Bro, just give the scan.No, she is projecting raw light with her copy of penny's beam as penny's beam does not have a physical projectile. And no, there is no such thing as 'energy dust'
Boyo chill im responding to Rusty's stuff then i'll grab the scanBro, just give the scan.
He’s literally asleep, wdymBoyo chill im responding to Rusty's stuff then i'll grab the scan
You must be new to seeing me and Weekly interact in any wayHey guys let’s try to simmer down here
Ah okay lol^
This is just a normal conversation for us lol
Lowkey wondering if we'd be allowed to ask one of the writers on twitter, since Penny is dead its not like it would be a spoiler, just like, if Penny and her swords use Dust and if so, what kindAlso, I just want to say that even if Penny’s lasers aren’t powered by hard light dust, that doesn’t disqualify them. Actually, it would make more sense if they were powered by lighting dust since lasers are powered by electricity.
I didn’t even bring that up tho.Also, I just want to say that even if Penny’s lasers aren’t powered by hard light dust, that doesn’t disqualify them. Actually, it would make more sense if they were powered by lighting dust since lasers are powered by electricity.
That’s fishing for an upgrade homie, don’t do that. You would be asking them that as evidence specifically for an upgrade, not a good look, even if the question is only upgrade-adjacent.Lowkey wondering if we'd be allowed to ask one of the writers on twitter, since Penny is dead its not like it would be a spoiler, just like, if Penny and her swords use Dust and if so, what kind
Is it though? I didnt say to ask if she uses hard light dust, just what kind in general as the Guidebook and RWBY wiki say she uses Dust but not what kindThat’s fishing for an upgrade homie, don’t do that. You would be asking them that as evidence specifically for an upgrade, not a good look, even if the question is only upgrade-adjacent.
I mean, its not just that by itself, its all the other factors and attributes her lasers have, only moving in straight lines, generating heat and cutting material rather than generating force, being made of natural light, etc. And its not just Velvet's laser, its literally every other laser weapon in the verse.Penny's weapon, to my knowledge, isn't powered by Hard Light or Light Dust. As such the Velvet's thing don't connect to Penny's lasers.
Being stated to be a laser isn't good enough by itself. Or else the laser rule wouldn't exist in the first place. Having light technology isn't support for her lasers, the wiki requires such proof to be on the laser itself and not something else. Just because Velvet's camera produces light, doesn't mean Penny's laser is light.
The issue with this train of logic is that Mach 380 comes from four seasons ago, and since then the cast has gone through two timeskip training arcs where they were noted to have gotten stronger and faster at the end of each. Thats like saying they cant be MHS because they only have bullet dodging feats in the Beacon Arc.Outside of possible laser feats and Penny's thing, which has no reason to scale to anything but her ability to think/perceive... Assuming it's works like that. There is really nothing else in RWBY that is on par with lightspeed. The fastest feat I'm seeing is Mach 380+, which is vastly below even Sub-Relativistic speeds.
Just a quick question but if Velvet is producing “raw light” from the copies of her weapon then wouldn’t that count as a disqualifying factor for it being light speed due to her constructs curving and such?No, she is projecting raw light with her copy of penny's beam as penny's beam does not have a physical projectile. And no, there is no such thing as 'energy dust'
Not really no, the raw form of Hard Light Dust is natural light, which is what Velvet projects in the form of lasers, while her constructs are a processed state of Hard Light dust created by her weapon to make weapon copies, similar to how Hard Light Dust in its processed state is used to make barriers.Just a quick question but if Velvet is producing “raw light” from the copies of her weapon then wouldn’t that count as a disqualifying factor for it being light speed due to her constructs curving and such?
Lol. Sad if true.INB4 we just wait for DB to do Azula vs Cinder and they confirm penny's lasers are lightspeed because Cinder dodged them
This coupled with the other Atlas laser weaponry and the fact that Atlas is literally the father of Hard Light Dust and uses it in almost everything. If their standard laser weaponry uses it why would they leave it out of the person who was created with the sole purpose of being the city's defender, as well as said scientists referring to both her beam and the hard light beams of atlas weapons like the beam turret as the same kind of lasersI mean, technically we have met two of the criteria for proving they are LS. A trustworthy source in universe that says they are real lasers and a reflection. Like, Atlas scientists have to know what photons are and what a laser does. Thus, when they call something a laser, they know full well what that entails. I brought up the cloaking devices not because it directly connects to Penny's lasers being LS, but because it shows that those scientists know how natural light works. Again, those descriptions are written in universe by a scientist working for the gaming company that runs Atlas Arena. And, to be fair, nowhere on the list of criteria for LS feats does it say that these statements have to have some extra proof. Just the statement is good enough if they are lightspeed. But, again, I point towards the reflection feat.
They are machine generated, as well as the thing with Velvet's camera and the cameras in scrolls using hard light dust"Rusty brought up some good points; at least 2 or 3 of those 5 points should also have evidence. Though if the lasers are machine generated I suppose that can be point 1, but we need another point or 2."
Also, to quote Meduses, if the lasers are machine generated, that could count as a point. And we already have another point with the Atlas scientist statement.
It doesn't have to be hard light dust for it to be true lasers. Lasers in the real world are powered by electricity anyway.Is it confirmed Penny’s lasers are pure hard light dust though? Has a scan for that been provided?
Its not, we just know that her weapons are powered by Dust and her lasers are considered by Atlas scientists (Scientists who pioneered the development of hard light dust based laser weapons) as being the same lasers as the ones employed by the weapons and technology of the atlas military, on top of the properties her lasers have which fall in line with the standards for lightspeedIs it confirmed Penny’s lasers are pure hard light dust though? Has a scan for that been provided?