Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

[Deagonx]

I agree, far too often users think a "slander thread" is some sort of carte blanche to be actually and sincerely hostile to others.

 

[Catzlaflame]

I’m not involved in this, but since it was not mentioned above, just wanted to say would this comment not be considered worse?

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

The Slander threads are back again, this time strongly endorsing offsite harassment. For now I'm still of the opinion that slander threads are in good fun and only go south when bad elements find their way in.

@StrymULTRA has been a fairly consistent report here, to the best of my knowledge this is the worst one he's blurted out so far. Wondering what the consensus is on a short ban, given the track record.

Yeah, I am going to have to agree that this is going too far. Not to mention, there have been threads that start out as fun and games, but various users have a tendency to make things go south and berate various users and the community.

 

[Mr. Bambu]

Claim is evidently false- Besides the StrymULTRA stuff of course, where my money is on Bambu's horse in the race.

^ One of the people involved.

^ My self.
It's pretty clear that Strym is an exception here. You can't judge all of us based on his actions.
I'm not trying to evaluate the case and act as if I'm staff, cause I'm not, but I felt that it was necessary to prove we definitely aren't endorsing offsite harassment, as someone who was involved in the discussion when it happened.
Only Strym even said it was deserved out of the 3 or 4 people involved in this case

I didn't mention you, dog. I even screenshotted the comment I'm reporting.

I’m not involved in this, but since it was not mentioned above, just wanted to say would this comment not be considered worse?

Not worse, but yeah, also very bad.

 

[DaMonkeMan]

I didn't mention you, dog. I even screenshotted the comment I'm reporting.


Not worse, but yeah, also very bad.

The Slander threads are back again, this time strongly endorsing offsite harassment.

This is a generalizing statement, which is what confused me.
My bad Ig.

 

[Mr. Bambu]

Right. This report was not for general behavior against Dread on the Slander thread- idrc about you and Dread having your little sparring match thing, it was harmless. The line is drawn at endorsing harassment, aye.

In any case, this is a rapid response report it seems, already three evaluating staff agree that shit's fucky. I propose a two months ban, in light of all recent behavior and the severity of the current violation. Any objections?

 

[Deagonx]

Right. This report was not for general behavior against Dread on the Slander thread- idrc about you and Dread having your little sparring match thing, it was harmless. The line is drawn at endorsing harassment, aye.

In any case, this is a rapid response report it seems, already three evaluating staff agree that shit's fucky. I propose a two months ban, in light of all recent behavior and the severity of the current violation. Any objections?

sounds good to me.

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

2 months works for me.

 

[ImmortalDread]

I am aware that the topic may be finished, but I want still to share the context to those visitors or lurkers that are still want to defend Strym.

This Strym is the one who bullied and harassed me off-site constantly before and yet has dignity to ask me for image renders after that, also telling me if I do them, he “may” consider the apology (which makes absolutely no sense)

And still talk shit about me in that slander thread and telling me I should deserve this (and there are many other hate comments in that thread; I simply ignored them). Hell, people here thinks staff members favoring me but y'all don't even see this guy in my DMs or in other servers, he just hates me and loves to insult me.
Or here or here trying to justify his bullying as normal.

And the fact is, I still remain nice to him in DMs after all of this. Almost all his previous reports (mute and official warning) are insults (mild or not) against me in the threads since he can't be respectful.

I am aware that all screenshots here are off-site; but I wanted to give a clear context regarding this user and clear up the misconception.

 

[Antvasima]

I am also fine with a 2 months ban for Strym.

 

[Agnaa]

Why is racism (N-word) banned for 3-6 months, and bad attitude towards transgender people (DarthSpiderr, no insults) is one year? Initially, he was generally banned forever, until others intervened.

I think Deagon's response is a bad explanation.

The better response is that it's because the context was very different.

If we put the targeted group aside, we can see that saying "my n-words" is a lot less of an attack on the group than Darth's swear-filled rant about how being trans is "the dumbest shit they've ever seen in their life". If the context here was as bad as Darth's, I would've advocated for a much longer ban.

Hell, he essentially said he'd delete any further comments calling him out on this.

While I do ultimately agree with not warning her, that's a wack way to represent Efi's post there. He said he'd delete further comments about it in that thread, since the thread isn't about that, and even suggested that people use other avenues to talk about it.

@LIFE_OF_KING should likely be reprimanded for this comment which is pretty egregious.

This is about the lightest infraction I could find warning-worthy. And even then, only if LOK can't demonstrate prior rapport with Perequeliri. This sorta banter's perfectly fine with friends.

I'm not sure how much this is counts as a violation, but @Peppersalt43 seems to be trigger happy liking my comments, now it's not against the rules to like someone's comments but last year the same person did it so much that it cluttered my notifications and didn't contribute anything to the threads, and their starting to do it again!

I did ask them to stop on their own page, but I think they may have ignored me.

I don't think this counts as a violation.

So for how long should we ban them? 1 year? Permanently?

I said 1 month, and would move up to 3 with the continued disregard, but it seems like I'm outvoted there.

The Slander threads are back again, this time strongly endorsing offsite harassment. For now I'm still of the opinion that slander threads are in good fun and only go south when bad elements find their way in.

@StrymULTRA has been a fairly consistent report here, to the best of my knowledge this is the worst one he's blurted out so far. Wondering what the consensus is on a short ban, given the track record.

I'm also fine with a 2 month ban.

And would wanna keep a closer eye on the slander thread, since it keeps leading to shit like this.

I’m not involved in this, but since it was not mentioned above, just wanted to say would this comment not be considered worse?

I don't care about that one. It's obviously a joke done with a friend.

 

[CloverDragon03]

While I do ultimately agree with not warning her, that's a wack way to represent Efi's post there. He said he'd delete further comments about it in that thread, since the thread isn't about that, and even suggested that people use other avenues to talk about it.

Fair enough I suppose, though something does need to be said about how Efi carries himself in that thread and multiple others, in my honest opinion

 

[Antvasima]

As far as I am aware, Eficiente has been piled on and borderline harrassed by other members considerably more than has been warranted by his own conduct, which is difficult to deal with in an entirely calm and rational manner, and he is generalla making a great effort to help out in sum total, so I do not have a problem with him.

 

[CloverDragon03]

As far as I am aware, Eficiente has been piled on and borderline harrassed by other members considerably more than has been warranted by his own conduct, which is difficult to deal with in an entirely calm and rational manner, and he is generalla making a great effort to help out in sum total, so I do not have a problem with him.

First I’m learning of any such harassment, and I haven’t seen any such thing in my experiences to begin with. Even so, that most definitely doesn’t warrant such condescending passive-aggression followed by blaming the people themselves for being offended by it, toward people that seem to have nothing to do with his past harassment. As a Thread Mod, it’s not unreasonable to expect significantly better conduct.

Being helpful is the bare minimum for a staff member. That’s not some super standout, massively praiseworthy thing. It’s what we expect from our staff.

 

[Deagonx]

Clover, you should discuss this with HR, not here.

 

[CloverDragon03]

Clover, you should discuss this with HR, not here.

I felt I should respond here given that Ant was addressing my concerns here

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

First I’m learning of any such harassment, and I haven’t seen any such thing in my experiences to begin with. Even so, that most definitely doesn’t warrant such condescending passive-aggression followed by blaming the people themselves for being offended by it, toward people that seem to have nothing to do with his past harassment. As a Thread Mod, it’s not unreasonable to expect significantly better conduct.

Being helpful is the bare minimum for a staff member. That’s not some super standout, massively praiseworthy thing. It’s what we expect from our staff.

While I do agree that Eficiente does often behave in ways unbefitting of a staff member (Especially in Undertale threads), this isn't the place to discuss it. It's better to get in contact with an HR group member such as AKM sama or Celestial Pegasus and better to compile a list of evidence.

 

[CloverDragon03]

While I do agree that Eficiente does often behave in ways unbefitting of a staff member (Especially in Undertale threads), this isn't the place to discuss it. It's better to get in contact with an HR group member such as AKM sama or Celestial Pegasus and better to compile a list of evidence.

My response to this is the same as my response to Deagonx. Still, I suppose that’s fair enough

 

[Antvasima]

Being helpful is the bare minimum for a staff member. That’s not some super standout, massively praiseworthy thing. It’s what we expect from our staff.

Quite a lot of them barely help out at all though, so I try to be appreciative towards the ones who do make an effort.

 

[Zamasu_Chan]

Hope Mikaelson

I'm not scared. I'm a Mikaelson witch.Hope. Hope Mikaelson is the daughter of the Original Hybrid Niklaus Mikaelson & the hybrid Hayley Marshall. She is the first and only hybrid of all three supernature beings in The Vampire Diaries/The Originals universe (witch, werewolf, and vampire). Due to...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Is this page vandalized?

 

[Agnaa]

Seems like it; I undid those edits and warned the culprit.

 

[ImmortalDread]

Thread/Post Violation report

• The user: @Rakih_Elyan
• Thread Link: https://vsbattles.com/threads/questions-about-qualitative-superiority-and-r-f.155909/

The offense:

• https://vsbattles.com/threads/questions-about-qualitative-superiority-and-r-f.155909/post-5908584
• https://gyazo.com/dc134a798919120a583efaeecdb2219c (in case the comment got deleted)

This is a bit going way too far. Using this word to refer to someone is completely unjustifiable, regardless of the context or location.

 

[Mr. Bambu]

It's not absurdly out there, for the average of VS Battles, but it does cross a line into outright insults about a person- in no way can it be 'guised as criticism.

@Rakih_Elyan This is a warning, tone it down.

 

[Catzlaflame]

Honestly, I have no idea if there was a CRT on this or not, but the user in question has a total of 9 edits on this wiki, and only wrote "because of Fa Jin" for a justification without linking a thread. I have refrained from undoing the edits, because, again, I'm not sure if there was a thread on this.

Izuku Midoriya (Deku) (Final Act)

Izuku Midoriya (緑谷出久 Midoriya Izuku), also known as Deku (デク Deku), was one of the 20 percent of people on Earth to be born without a Quirk, a natural superpower that is a basic biological function in the modern society, earning him endless amounts of torment and bullying in school. However, by...

vsbattles.fandom.com

 

[SuperStar]

Honestly, I have no idea if there was a CRT on this or not, but the user in question has a total of 9 edits on this wiki, and only wrote "because of Fa Jin" for a justification without linking a thread. I have refrained from undoing the edits, because, again, I'm not sure if there was a thread on this.

Izuku Midoriya (Deku) (Final Act)

Izuku Midoriya (緑谷出久 Midoriya Izuku), also known as Deku (デク Deku), was one of the 20 percent of people on Earth to be born without a Quirk, a natural superpower that is a basic biological function in the modern society, earning him endless amounts of torment and bullying in school. However, by...

vsbattles.fandom.com

There was no CRT for this, I reverted the edit.

 

[Catzlaflame]

A user is seemingly adding "At Least" to numerous pages as well as adding random abilities. Notably, they have already been warned about adding unaproved stuff by @Dereck03

Brain of Cthulhu

The Brain of Cthulhu is a gigantic brain found in the Crimson. It appears once three Crimson Hearts have been smashed. Tier: 8-A Name: Brain of Cthulhu Origin: Terraria Gender: Genderless Age: At least 500 years old (Should be comparable in age to the Dryad, who is over 500 years old)...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Queen Bee (Terraria)

Queen Bee is the matriarch of the jungles hives. It guards the larvas inside the hives and will viciously attack anyone who dares to damage them. Tier: 8-A Name: Queen Bee Origin: Terraria Gender: Female Age: Unknown Classification: Bee Powers and Abilities: Attack Potency: Multi-City Block...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Duke Fishron

The Duke Fishron is a bonus boss in the Terraria game. It looks like a mix between a dragon, a pig and a fish, or more exactly a mix between the "Pigron" enemy and a fish. Much like its land-dwelling brethren, it can fly in the air and turns invisible and intangible. It is summoned by fishing in...

vsbattles.fandom.com

 

[Therefir]

I have reverted the AP and ability changes and kept only the changes that I considered uncontroversial (such as bolding the abilities and adding the Large size to large creatures).

 

[Antvasima]

Thank you very much for helping out.

So should we ban the two vandals in question, and if so, for how long?

 

[Agnaa]

I prefer leaving bans until third offence, when they seem well-intentioned like this. Since only one of them has been warned for similar behaviour, and only once, I'd prefer no ban, and will leave warnings on their walls.

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

I think this user vandalized this profile. I think it's a vandalization as I couldn't find a CRT link + how badly formatted it is. And the user is seemingly new.

They don't seem malicious, but they should be informed that they need a CRT for this. I think a warning should suffice?

 

[Agnaa]

I've left a warning.

 

[Dragonite007]

I think this user vandalized this profile. I think it's a vandalization as I couldn't find a CRT link and the user is seemingly new

 

[SuperStar]

I think this user vandalized this profile. I think it's a vandalization as I couldn't find a CRT link and the user is seemingly new

Reverted.

 

[Therefir]

The user MarioFromMildex was caught vandalizing several of Dragon Ball profiles and was promptly warned, but it seems that they still haven't read it, or they ignored it.

They are still editing profiles right now.

 

[Dragonite007]

The user MarioFromMildex

This is linked to the CRT forum

 

[Agnaa]

I think this user vandalized this profile. I think it's a vandalization as I couldn't find a CRT link and the user is seemingly new

Left a warning on their wall.

The user MarioFromMildex was caught vandalizing several of Dragon Ball profiles and was promptly warned, but it seems that they still haven't read it, or they ignored it.

They are still editing profiles right now.

Left another warning on their wall, and banned them for one day to bring their attention to the ignored warning.

 

[Antvasima]

I think this user vandalized this profile. I think it's a vandalization as I couldn't find a CRT link and the user is seemingly new

I gave them a warning instruction message.

 

[Antvasima]

The user MarioFromMildex was caught vandalizing several of Dragon Ball profiles and was promptly warned, but it seems that they still haven't read it, or they ignored it.

They are still editing profiles right now.

I gave them a warning instruction message as well.

 

[Mad_Dog_of_Fujiwara]

Reporting @LordGinSama for this comment, where he calls me braindead for agreeing with someone else[?]. He was warned for earlier behavior two separate times, and obviously hasn't learned, so a threadban might be needed. Idk if he has a history if doing shit like this.

 

[LordGinSama]

I said your argument was brain dead worthy, not that you were brain dead. Attacking the argument itself is perfectly fine. Attacking the individual on the other hand is not, which I haven't done.


Also if anything is RVR worthy that'd be you throwing around accusations left and right while also forging a false report.


The very fact that you went directly to the RVR thread for something that isn't even report worthy speaks magnitudes in of itself.


Also I was warned once, not twice. Second time was literal poor judgement on Glass's part, so yet again your twisting the truth.