- 16,932
- 7,383
Hair would have less metal than blood anyways, though they sure did fall off in that video. Weekly you need to show her using her magnetism on stuff like that for it to be considered, intangibility or not.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Pyrrha Nikos vs Mirio Togata
- Thread starter TheRustyOne
- Start date
- Status
- 21,392
- 2,986
Except if they had years of experience of fighting and killing something that can oneshot them, then they wouldn't have run.WeeklyBattles said:
- 15,637
- 5,400
", an omniscient who's only omniscient through statements would be less smart than say, Edward Elric."
False equivalency.
I'm talking about combat skill, not intelligence.
Someone with infinite training who loses to a chinchilla shouldn't be treated better than someone who actually has skill feats.
False equivalency.
I'm talking about combat skill, not intelligence.
Someone with infinite training who loses to a chinchilla shouldn't be treated better than someone who actually has skill feats.
- 40,476
- 12,956
Vados only has statements involving her fighting prowess. Does that make her less skilled than Piccolo?
- 64,114
- 16,107
@Dragon What are you talking about? Why would they willingly fight something that can oneshot them without backup?
- 21,392
- 2,986
She's more skilled than Piccolo because she is more skilled than people who are more skilled than Piccolo. It would be different if it was just "Vados trained for 10 years, therefore she is better than Piccolo who trained for 5 years".
- 21,392
- 2,986
Because they've done it and won for years?WeeklyBattles said:
- 15,637
- 5,400
If she doesn't show anything while she's actually fighting? Yes.The real cal howard said:
And if her fighting prowess isn't referenced to people who do have skill, then yes again.
- 64,114
- 16,107
@Dragon But Vados herself has no combat or skill feats so how can you say that by this logic?
- 64,114
- 16,107
Wow okay after seeing Dargoo's post this is far worse of a situation than i thought
- 21,392
- 2,986
Her feat is being better than someone with the feats. Huntsmen only go off of words, there are no showings that all hunstmen in training are that great.WeeklyBattles said:
- 15,637
- 5,400
Vados doesn't have combat feats we can compare to her statements.WeeklyBattles said:
Cardin does, and they don't line up with his statements.
I'm not saying to disregard statements, just compare them to what they actually do in combat.
- 15,637
- 5,400
"If she doesn't show anything while she's actually fighting? Yes."Wokistan said:
That's not outright condradiction?
- 15,637
- 5,400
Thank and you.Therefir said:
I think we should honestly drop the current discussion, it's pretty pointless.
- 64,114
- 16,107
Its extremely important as its the difference between Pyrrha being the most skilled non-pro fighter in the world and pyrrha having no feats, and frankly its a reflection of threads across the wiki as a whole
- 15,637
- 5,400
Pyrrha does have feats.WeeklyBattles said:
What are you even going on about.
Just watch a fight with her in it, and watch a fight with Mirio in it, then make the call. I'm saying Mirio fares better from what I see.
- 64,114
- 16,107
Not by your logic she doesnt
By your logic the fact that she fought and stomped people with a lifetime of training means nothing because it was only stated
By your logic the fact that she fought and stomped people with a lifetime of training means nothing because it was only stated
- 15,637
- 5,400
Never in this entire thread did I say that Pyhrra had no feats. Stop putting words in my mouth.WeeklyBattles said:
I said Mirio had better feats, and that's more substantial than Pyhrra having more experience.
"By your logic the fact that she fought and stomped people with a lifetime of training means nothing because it was only stated"
If it doesn't reflect on the combat they actually show, then it shouldn't be considered as substantial.
- 16,932
- 7,383
Mirio does seem more efficient from the scenes. As opposed to Pyrrha's dancing around enemies for a while when those dudes left several openings, Mirio just turned intangible and went in on everyone. Also, his power actually works, as nobody's demonstrated Pyrrha having the level of magnetism she'd need to have to do anything with it.
- 64,114
- 16,107
@Dargoo Im not im stating exactly what youre arguing. All the people she beat have feats only via statements, nothing else. Ergo she has no skill feats by your logic.
- 15,637
- 5,400
No, you can watch how exactly they fight when they're battling Pyrrha. Those are feats.WeeklyBattles said:
And she has skill feats in every single fight she's been in.
This is beggining to just turn into a circular argument. Can we stop meandering on this and talk about the battle?
- 64,114
- 16,107
No we cannot, if this issue isnt fixed now it will only get worse
- 16,932
- 7,383
Animation limitations exist. A contradiction would be someone being notably bad, those dudes being stated to have trained for a while doesn't seem like a contradiction to me. Mirio just also wrecked a bunch of people like that and has a power to shut out Pyrrha entirely.
- 63,529
- 8,509
Anyway, discussion has gone long enough
My second favorite RWBY character loses to another favorite FRA
Now please excuse me as I cry in a corner.
My second favorite RWBY character loses to another favorite FRA
Now please excuse me as I cry in a corner.
- 15,637
- 5,400
Wok has a fair point.
They condradict what I'd picture a person with a lifetime fighting experience would act like, but that's me, I suppose.
However, keep in mind Mirio was trained under one of the most intelligent people in the verse, can just phase through Pyrrha's attacks and hit her then, and has deat with a wider variety of power-users.
And this isn't black or white. I'm not suggesting "Pyrrha has no feats". I'm just suggesting that what Mirio shows is better than what Pyrrha shows.
You can agree to disagree at that point.
They condradict what I'd picture a person with a lifetime fighting experience would act like, but that's me, I suppose.
However, keep in mind Mirio was trained under one of the most intelligent people in the verse, can just phase through Pyrrha's attacks and hit her then, and has deat with a wider variety of power-users.
And this isn't black or white. I'm not suggesting "Pyrrha has no feats". I'm just suggesting that what Mirio shows is better than what Pyrrha shows.
You can agree to disagree at that point.
- 63,529
- 8,509
Can we stop on skill already? That is not the only factor
- 16,287
- 25,040
Vault boi FRA
- 21,392
- 2,986
Mirio fra
- 519
- 94
Mirio FRA
- 12,038
- 15,578
- Thread starter
- #113
Grace starts now.
- 16,623
- 1,796
Mirio FRA
- 13,590
- 5,765
Best guy FRA
Edit: How does one kudos the reason for closing a thread?
Edit: How does one kudos the reason for closing a thread?
- 6,955
- 4,400
Fallout pip-boy/Tintin parody FRA
- 12,038
- 15,578
- Thread starter
- #117
24 hours have passed which means grace period is over.
I'll add this to their profiles in ten minutes from now.
I'll add this to their profiles in ten minutes from now.
- 12,038
- 15,578
- Thread starter
- #119
Sure.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
