Persona Protagonist Battle Royal.

[Kople700]

Came up with this idea during my 2nd playthrough of persona 5. I've only played 5 and 4 so let me know if door-kun stomps or something along those lines. This is a battle between ONLY the persona 3, 4, and 5 protagonists

Speed is NOT equalized. (Unless one clearly stomps the others) All are at their strongest. (Endgame versions of themselves)

Who wins and why?

 

[Ranzuki]

Tatsuya comes in and destroys all three of them with his motorcycle.

 

[Solacis]

Paleo-Persona stomps Neo-Persona by virtue of being infinitely stronger AP-wise. I dunno much more than that.

 

[AllanShadow78]

Paleo-Persona stomps Neo-Persona by virtue of being infinitely stronger AP-wise. I dunno much more than that.

arent all of them low 2-C? im lost now

 

[Genericstickman]

The ones getting upgraded to 2-B win

 

[ChocomilkAlex]

I thought there were only 3 persona games and all of the characters were low 2-c

 

[Genericstickman]

Their are, Persona 1, Persona 2, Persona 2 2: 3

3 Persona games

 

[AllanShadow78]

The ones getting upgraded to 2-B wi

what? 2-B persona? tats gets 2-B?

 

[Mr.Cinos15]

If I remember, the character's that are getting 2-B are only Persona 1 and 2 character's.

 

[ChocomilkAlex]

those games don't exist

 

[Mr.Cinos15]

You're right ovo.

 

[Genericstickman]

True

 

[AllanShadow78]

i want tats and maya to be in a persona q game. but now it seems the scailing would be off even worse

 

[Genericstickman]

That implies Atlus would acknowledge 2 which is highly unlikely besides small references in 3 and that's it (also Anniversary art)

 

[AllanShadow78]

That implies Atlus would acknowledge 2 which is highly unlikely besides small references in 3 and that's it (also Anniversary art)

ik that 1 and 2 are basically the bastard children and prolly wont be referenced unless some old ass p1 and p2 fan becomes a story board artist for a spin off game. Still, that doesnt change the fact that they would be nice aditions to the cast. tell, imagine the power of rumors coming back and personas being able to appear outside of specific areas. i would love to see how the current cast would be affected

 

[Genericstickman]

I just realised most of the 1 and 2 profiles need tidying up

 

[Dark_warrior_100]

those games don't exist

Le funny meme

 

[Dziga]

Tatsuya flexes.

 

[Ranzuki]

That implies Atlus would acknowledge 2 which is highly unlikely besides small references in 3 and that's it (also Anniversary art)

It was Hashino who refuses to acknowledge them and now that he no longer directs the Persona games there is a slight chance that P1 and P2 cast will appear like with all the foreshadowing with Nyarlathotep or his servants in Persona 5 Royal.

 

[MYHERO]

Okay since we all know Joker, Minato, and Yu are fodder, but between Naoya and Tatsuya, who takes it?

 

[Dziga]

Probably Tatsuya for fighting directly with Nyarla. But maybe you can argue Persona 1 Protag based of Naoya not being too far from Maki who is above Tatsuya.

 

[MYHERO]

Hmm...Maki being above Tatsuya...

 

[Kople700]

Cough only 3 4 and 5 protags Cough

 

[MYHERO]

Whoops

 

[Solacis]

If it's only Neo-Persona protags, then I have to go with Ren.

Ren has a HUGE AP advantage here with Sinful Shell, and since it isn't energy-based but physical, Makoto can't nullify it. He also has the highest Durability out of the three due to Satanael scaling to its own AP.

Makoto's Armageddon gets nulled by Satanael, and unless we turn their personalities off, it's unlikely he'll ever go for the Great Seal. Although depending on the definition of "protagonist", we could have Makoto, FeMC/Kotone and Aigis all working together, or at least being in the same battle.

Yu will last a while simply because he has a stamina feat in holding off the significantly stronger Hi-no-Kagutsuchi by himself for a notable amount of time. He can mostly keep up with the other two outside of Ultimate Personas, but once Messiah and Satanael show up, he'll go down if he hasn't already been hit by an Armageddon.

 

[Sumguyonvswiki2]

If it's only Neo-Persona protags, then I have to go with Ren.

Ren has a HUGE AP advantage here with Sinful Shell, and since it isn't energy-based but physical, Makoto can't nullify it. He also has the highest Durability out of the three due to Satanael scaling to its own AP.

Makoto's Armageddon gets nulled by Satanael, and unless we turn their personalities off, it's unlikely he'll ever go for the Great Seal. Although depending on the definition of "protagonist", we could have Makoto, FeMC/Kotone and Aigis all working together, or at least being in the same battle.


Yu will last a while simply because he has a stamina feat in holding off the significantly stronger Hi-no-Kagutsuchi by himself for a notable amount of time. He can mostly keep up with the other two outside of Ultimate Personas, but once Messiah and Satanael show up, he'll go down if he hasn't already been hit by an Armageddon.

Finslly a man of culture people are soo quick to throw joker and satanael under the bus at this rate many people on YouTube and Instagram just wank makoto because they think nyx is unbeatable and p3 is their favorite game

 

[Solacis]

Nah man new scaling chain. Don't rope me into this.