- 4,524
- 2,242
- Thread starter
- #201
Not saying I disagree, but why wouldn't that count as 1A proof? Could that also be Low 1A or something?It wouldn't, but there's better possible 1-As proof.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Not saying I disagree, but why wouldn't that count as 1A proof? Could that also be Low 1A or something?It wouldn't, but there's better possible 1-As proof.
Because it just doesn't qualify as anything more than a single transcendence at bestNot saying I disagree, but why wouldn't that count as 1A proof? Could that also be Low 1A or something?
Does transcending an infinite amount 1-A of realms grant High 1-A?Because it just doesn't qualify as anything more than a single transcendence at best
Except your legitly seeing an infinite hierarchy of 1A+ as fiction. And seeing a 1B character as fiction can mean many things without further context.
Does transcending an infinite amount 1-A of realms grant High 1-A?
1-A+Does transcending an infinite amount 1-A of realms grant High 1-A?
oh, nvm.Because it just doesn't qualify as anything more than a single transcendence at best
I did say 1A+ bro.No. Look at The One Giver, which is quite possibly the strongest 1-A on this site. It is infinite infinities above Outerversal+
No problem bro it happens.Apologies, I didn't mean to sound angry. I was just a bit confused on what you meant.
Yeah I've been clarified but I meant 1A+ heirachyAgain, merely viewing a 1A hierarchy as fiction isn't High 1A. There are other factors that need to come in play.
From my point of view it didn't know the multiverse existed before till it found a stain or mark on it which is the DC multiverse. Then decides to itself from the seething contact with 'story' and imagines a race of beings, 'angels' or 'monitors' (another word for angel, of course) to function as an interface between its own giant eternal magnificence and this tiny, weird crawling anthill of life and significance that is the DC Multiverse.Apologies, I didn't mean to sound angry. I was just a bit confused on what you meant.
Again, merely viewing a 1A hierarchy as fiction isn't High 1A. There are other factors that need to come in play.
Again, my point had to do with the fact that Overvoid had to "protect" itself from contact with "story". It would go against High 1A to be completely disconnected from any extension of a 1A hierarchy (which technically isn't even High 1A, tbf) if one can still be affected by said hierarchy.
Yeah I've been clarified but I meant 1A+ heirachy
I know but seeing a 1A+ hierarchy as dream/fiction is high 1A easy. No one should tell me otherwise.Even then, it's a bit wonky. High 1A is an extremely strange tier to get to, ngl.
wdym?I did say 1A+ bro.
Seeing as 1A+ hierarchy as dream/fiction grants high 1A is what I mean.wdym?
Yeah and? The One Giver is literally infinite infinities beyond 1-A+, but it's still 1-A+Seeing as 1A+ hierarchy as dream/fiction grants high 1A is what I mean.
And nothing more. the one giver is infinite infinite beyond 1A and it's different from a character seeing 1A+ hierarchy as dream/fiction.Yeah and? The One Giver is literally infinite infinities beyond 1-A+, but it's still 1-A+
If that is only 1-A+ then what is High 1-A? Transcending Infinite amount of infinite 1-A?1-A+
Transcending 1-A or 1-A+ in a way that makes it unreachable.If that is only 1-A+ then what is High 1-A? Transcending Infinite amount of infinite 1-A?
It was for existing outside of the framework in which 1-A is defined. At least that’s what Ultima said.????? Wtf got Overvoid High 1A, then? Merely transcending the 1A cosmology isn't High 1A, nowhere close to it, tbf.
All it mentions is that it had 0 defenses to story spreading all over it. Although it’s not being literally physically attacked, it’s emptiness is just becoming filled with stuff.first of all, it says the exact same thing that the Overvoid felt the need to protect itself from the multiverse, so the transcendence it has over the multiverse is either not very big at all or nonexistent.
He said, “Unless there's some additional context that prevents it from being that high, which there likely is, in this case.” The problem is that your additional context or evidence against this is false.Even then, the main premise of the downgrade is that no evidence for Overvoid gives a High 1A rating. In fact, even Ultima has shown that it's extremely questionable if Overvoid would even apply for such a rating anymore.
And Overvoid doesn't...at all.It was for existing outside of the framework in which 1-A is defined. At least that’s what Ultima said.
All it mentions is that it had 0 defenses to story spreading all over it. Although it’s not being literally physically attacked, it’s emptiness is just becoming filled with stuff.
He said, “Unless there's some additional context that prevents it from being that high, which there likely is, in this case.” The problem is that your additional context or evidence against this is false.
Thing is, it’s protecting itself from the story. The multiverse being zero or whatever is great, but it’s merely another level into 1AIn the case of comic book stories, it's the war between white page and ink. And who's to say that the page might want that particular story drawn on it? [laughs] What happens if the page is a bit pissed off at the story that's drawn on it? So I thought of the page as God. The idea being that the Overvoid – as we called it in Final Crisis - of the white page as a space is sort of God. And it's condensing stories out of itself because it finds inside its own gigantic white space, self-absorbed pristine consciousness, it finds this little stain or mark, this DC Multiverse somebody has 'drawn'. And it starts investigating, and it's just shocked with what it sees, with all the crazy activity and signifying going on in there. It then tries to protect itself from the seething contact with 'story' and imagines a race of beings, 'angels' or 'monitors' (another word for angel, of course) to function as an interface between its own giant eternal magnificence and this tiny, weird crawling anthill of life and significance that is the DC Multiverse.
This can literally mean many things but it's best to look at the best logical explanation.
This is from my own point of view.
This could Just could mean that the multiverse is just a flaw in it's magnificence and decides to use story to protect itself from seething contact.
The Overvoid literally can contain all things and all possibilities even Lucifer stated all things could be 0 in the Overvoid. And from the explaination the entire DC is just a speck from it's perspective. Just a stain/mark.
And the monitor sphere is also inaccessible except you were taken their by a monitor. Besides I don't see what the Overvoid is trying to protect itself( apart from the writer who drew on it or the source which I believe was the stain/mark that was shown in JL/doom patrol).
Just my opinion as I stated above I can be wrong.
Besides I still need context of this. As in what aspect it's protecting itself from the story cause it could mean many things.Thing is, it’s protecting itself from the story
Being "dimensional" doesnt mean much tho.The problem is that a reality-fiction difference can be treated different ways by different universes. In DC's case IIRC a reality-fiction difference is Dimensional.
Like 3D and 5D doesn't mean much?Being "dimensional" doesnt mean much tho.
In DC, no it doesn't. Best example of this is when you have guys like Superman, who should be spatially flat for 5D imps, punching said imps through time (I don't remember the exact details of what happened, but I know that he did shit like that). DC's dimensions and whatnot aren't really that solid, tbf.Like 3D and 5D doesn't mean much?
dc downgraded to 2-A!!!!!!!In DC, no it doesn't. Best example of this is when you have guys like Superman, who should be spatially flat for 5D imps, punching said imps through time (I don't remember the exact details of what happened, but I know that he did shit like that). DC's dimensions and whatnot aren't really that solid, tbf.
You could probably make a fair argument for it...dc downgraded to 2-A!!!!!!!
You're editorializing the evidence. It says "they're reading our story." Likewise, that evidence is both incredibly vague and outdated. Modern evidence proves that there's no R>F difference between Perpetua and the Justice League, and Perpetua is above Limbo.It's shown to us that beings in comic book limbo are reading the lower beings of reality like a story.
And I watch the Super Bowl on a TV Screen. That doesn't mean it's fictional to me.The Cathexis see the world across flat screens from their realm.
The eonymous see the world across a tv screen.
And universes appear as screens from Bleed space.
Since DC and Marvel are getting downgraded as shown in this thread: https://vsbattles.com/threads/thanos-with-the-heart-of-the-universe-downgrade.121545/. What tier would you put Overvoid at?You're editorializing the evidence. It says "they're reading our story." Likewise, that evidence is both incredibly vague and outdated. Modern evidence proves that there's no R>F difference between Perpetua and the Justice League, and Perpetua is above Limbo.
And I watch the Super Bowl on a TV Screen. That doesn't mean it's fictional to me.
In modern DC canon I don't even think it'd be appropriate to give Overvoid it's own profile. The handful of feats that Overvoid had were retconned. It's no longer the progenitor of the Monitor race, it didn't create the Orrery, etc. It doesn't seem to be sentient in any of it's appearances that weren't written by Morrison, so essentially Final Crisis and Multiversity only.What tier would you put Overvoid at?
With all that has been retconned, is the Overvoid more of a location rather than an actual entity?In modern DC canon I don't even think it'd be appropriate to give Overvoid it's own profile. The handful of feats that Overvoid had were retconned. It's no longer the progenitor of the Monitor race, it didn't create the Orrery, etc. It doesn't seem to be sentient in any of it's appearances that weren't written by Morrison, so essentially Final Crisis and Multiversity only.
However within those it's feats are pretty limited. So the main question is "Do we consider it appropriate to tier a sentient void based on what exists within it, even if it hasn't demonstrated an ability to destroy, manipulate, or create on the scale of what's within it?"
Aside from it's origin story offered in Final Crisis: Superman Beyond (and re-hashed in Multiversity), it has only ever been a location.With all that has been retconned, is the Overvoid more of a location rather than an actual entity?
Also, why are the staffs ignoring the fact that Mandrakk could not one shot 52 universes and needed preparation and servants to do it. That makes him 2-C at best ignoring the small star level feat from CAS.Aside from it's origin story offered in Final Crisis: Superman Beyond (and re-hashed in Multiversity), it has only ever been a location.
Link?Probably cause this nonsense you keep repeating has been addressed forever ago.
Every time you bring it up. Seriously, can you stay on topic.l?Link?
lemme seeEvery time you bring it up. Seriously, can you stay on topic.l?
I didn't specify DC and neither did he refrence DC comics. Yes 3D characters are spatially flat to 5D characters same way 3D characters see 2D characters as spatially flat. Can I see the scan and book where superman punched an imp through time. The fact the use R-F shows it's solid and most platforms use DC and umineko to refrence standard dimensionality. Cause I know every book gives context on how and why lower-D beings affect higher-D beings.In DC, no it doesn't. Best example of this is when you have guys like Superman, who should be spatially flat for 5D imps, punching said imps through time (I don't remember the exact details of what happened, but I know that he did shit like that). DC's dimensions and whatnot aren't really that solid, tbf.
It's actually an entity, it's seen as a being where all DC multiverses are in.With all that has been retconned, is the Overvoid more of a location rather than an actual entity?
Really bro, you always do something like this. You can simply make a downgrade thread bro. No one's stopping you.Also, why are the staffs ignoring the fact that Mandrakk could not one shot 52 universes and needed preparation and servants to do it. That makes him 2-C at best ignoring the small star level feat from CAS.