One Punch Man - Low 5-B downgrades

[azontr]

I mean yeah, 5-B makes no sense cause the planet would pretty much get blown to bits, but the Math People still need to post an evaluation sadly or else we can't do nothin'.

 

[Bernkastelll]

i know it could be an outlier but i want to understand if the calculations are correct

Well, they didnt consider the feat as outlier when it was Low 5-B

 

[DastardlyDangerousDracoga]

i know it could be an outlier but i want to understand if the calculations are correct

It could be, but there's also the fact that it needs to be reviewed whether or not it's an outlier, in order to be accepted into the scaling.

 

[azontr]

It could be, but there's also the fact that it needs to be reviewed whether or not it's an outlier, in order to be accepted into the scaling.

It can't be accepted into the scaling either way. That much energy would literally blow up the planet. Since OPM Earth hasn't been displayed as more durable than IRL Earth, this doesn't work.

 

[Bernkastelll]

It can't be accepted into the scaling either way. That much energy would literally blow up the planet. Since OPM Earth hasn't been displayed as more durable than IRL Earth, this doesn't work.

Well, it is a proof that it is more durable even then, we have 5-A feats due moon fuckery (literally moving the moon)

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

Well, they didnt consider the feat as outlier when it was Low 5-B

Opinions can change over time ya know

 

[Kachon123]

Well, it is a proof that it is more durable

We would need more proof than that.

 

[Bernkastelll]

Opinions can change over time ya know

Its low = yeah acceptable
Its not low = NO


The feat is the same

 

[azontr]

Well, it is a proof that it is more durable even then, we have 5-A feats due moon fuckery (literally moving the moon)

Don't moon moving feats involve KE bullshit?

 

[Lightbuster30]

The core physically deforms when Orochi pulls "energy" from it. It's very obvious him "taking energy" is just a weird expression for him taking mass.

 

[Kachon123]

Opinions can change over time ya know

Unless they can prove their reasoning wrong, or have better reasoning for not using it, then why would we change?

 

[azontr]

Unless they can prove their reasoning wrong, or have better reasoning for not using it, then why would we change?

If the calc is accepted It won't be whether it's an outlier or not will be separately discussed.

 

[Bernkastelll]

I prefer the High 5-A calc

 

[azontr]

I prefer the High 5-A calc

Fancy urself a heretic, then?

 

[Qawsedf234]

we have 5-A feats due moon fuckery (literally moving the moon)

Actually moving planets and exceeding their GBE isn't that wild. Planet's have a large surface area to get rid of drag and things like that. You have IRL planets and stars thrown at near-lightspeeds and holding together because of that.

Something physically connecting with the Earth with that much energy is a different story.

 

[Bernkastelll]

Something physically connecting with the Earth with that much energy is a different story.

y

 

[Qawsedf234]

y

Because the Earth wouldn't be able to spread that force around itself. It would have to take the brunt of it, which would cause damages far beyond what was shown in the story.

 

[USklaverei]

Yeah, it doesn't make sense for this to be superior to the planet's GBE.
But about the thing, I always interpreted that Orochi used the core even with energy

 

[Bernkastelll]

Because the Earth wouldn't be able to spread that force around itself. It would have to take the brunt of it, which would cause damages far beyond what was shown in the story.

It is the same case with planets feats exceding their own GBE, despite it not being that weird

 

[ZoroNotZolo]

Actually moving planets and exceeding their GBE isn't that wild. Planet's have a large surface area to get rid of drag and things like that. You have IRL planets and stars thrown at near-lightspeeds and holding together because of that.

Something physically connecting with the Earth with that much energy is a different story.

Because the Earth wouldn't be able to spread that force around itself. It would have to take the brunt of it, which would cause damages far beyond what was shown in the story.

Yeah, it doesn't make sense for this to be superior to the planet's GBE.

^^ All this.

 

[Qawsedf234]

It is the same case with planets feats exceding their own GBE

I just explained why that isn't weird. You have legitimate in real life evidence of a planet's KE vastly outstripping its GBE, but due to surface area and how it deals with friction it can retain its form. The Earth's KE is higher than its GBE for example.

 

[Bernkastelll]

I just explained why that isn't weird. You have legitimate in real life evidence of a planet's KE vastly outstripping its GBE,

I know, i said it in that comment

but due to surface area and how it deals with friction it can retain its form. The Earth's KE is higher than its GBE for example.

I mean, if the 5-B rating is not usable due it, why wasnt low 5-B rejected due the same thing? As it didnt destroyed "half of the earth hence invalid"

 

[LordTracer]

I mean, if the 5-B rating is not usable due it, why wasnt low 5-B rejected due the same thing? As it didnt destroyed "half of the earth hence invalid"

Some of us wanted to get rid of Low 5-B before this thread so-

 

[Bernkastelll]

Some of us wanted to get rid of Low 5-B before this thread so-

I mean, in the time to accept it, yall had the chance to reject, the reasoning is the same

 

[RisingIons]

That's where we draw the line but we accept dropping literal oceans out of the sky and creating continental sized shockwaves on the moon without blowing a hole through it hmm

 

[Qawsedf234]

why wasnt low 5-B rejected due the same thing?

Low 5-B doesn't explode the planet like 5-B does.

accept dropping literal oceans out of the sky

But we also don't. The plate lift is a different version, since the original one didn't match the environmental destruction that happened right after so we had to go with PE

 

[Pepsiman25th]

honestly i feel like the planet stuff is becoming a mass division
i can see the opm god tiers being 6-A to 5-C at least

 

[Lightning_XXI]

I also support the High 6-A version

 

[Qawsedf234]

Anyways we're off topic again.

Give me your votes

 

[Bernkastelll]

Low 5-B doesn't explode the planet like 5-B does.

It would explode most of it, but it didnt

 

[Nierre]

Unless anyone is able to prove that OPM Earth =/= IRL Earth, I agree with the recalc.

 

[Kachon123]

Anyways we're off topic again

I agree with the High 6-A calc. (Hopefully true's calc gets accepted)

 

[LordTracer]

Hopefully true's calc gets accepted

And then we nuke the feat entirely UwU

 

[Kachon123]

And then we nuke the feat entirely UwU

Sad but true

 

[Lightning_XXI]

Yes, please let it be Tier 5 so we can throw the Outlier Bomb

 

[Qawsedf234]

Outlier Bomb

There's only one Outlier Bomb and its not an Outlier

 

[Migue79]

Hope I'm not too late to say that I agree with the new High 6-A calc.

 

[truelight810]

• Distance = 5155 km = 516.2 px

5155 / 516.2 = 9.98643936459 m/px

• Diameter = 47.5 px = 474.35 km (radius 237.175 km)
• Height = 54.6 px = 545.25 km

Sizing:

• Volume = 3.2119007e+16 m³
• Density = 4500 kg/m³
• Mass = 1.4453553e+20 kg

Considering 10 seconds (hahahahah)= 23717.5 m/s

• KE = (0.5) * (1.4453553e+20) * (23717.5²) = 4.0652049e+28 J or 9.7 Exatons (Multi-Continent level)

• Density = 4500 kg/m³ about what ? the earth?
• the the deformed portion is part of the outer core so you have to use the density of the outer core

 

[Qawsedf234]

the earth?

The bottom portion of the lower mantel is about that density

 

[Qawsedf234]

from what I have found it should be 12600 kg / m ^ 3

That's the density of the Earth's Inner Core.