• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Piece General Discussion: Elbaph

For a long time, I've been very wrong about how this actually works. I always saw it with the simplicity as "Well Gear 4th: Boundman is 3-4x stronger than his previous limit of power", but that is very very wrong. What Doffy is referring to is that the COMPRESSION effect of Luffy's Gear 4th attacks, basically when he compresses his fist into itself, that's what specifically increases Luffy's power by several times.

I pointed this out on here several months ago btw.



Also, I don't think that the multiplier fully factors Haki into it, so I don't agree with a couple of your later points in the post, but I'll get into it when it comes to the scaling revisions.
 
I pointed this out on here several months ago.
Difference is that I do it with style
2qxiUdQ.png
 
This makes no sense. How can base CoC luffy match hybrid CoC kaido but kaido is still stronger in the same form vs gear 4 because he can keep up with gear 5 luffy?
With the amp of power that Hao Infusion provides, it makes the previous gap in power between Base Luffy and all his Gears, hence why all those versions of Luffy can be relative to Kaidou without any significant changes
 
gear 5th isn't stronger physically than g4th
Maybe not stronger than compressed g4 attacks but absolutely stronger than gear 4 itself, he is coated in both armament and conquerors and his rubber body is significantly stronger due to awakening, gear 5 is also capable of doing the compression.
With the amp of power that Hao Infusion provides, it makes the previous gap in power between Base Luffy and all his Gears, hence why all those versions of Luffy can be relative to Kaidou without any significant changes
Luffy uses conquerors with gear 4 as well as 5th gear and he is still relative to kaido. But base luffy already matched kaido, it makes no sense, basically like saying gear 5 = gear 4 = base.
 
Ok, so here's how the multiplier works

Doflamingo states that Luffy is using the tensile force to raise his power several times above it's limits
pvRkKan.jpg

For a long time, I've been very wrong about how this actually works. I always saw it with the simplicity as "Well Gear 4th: Boundman is 3-4x stronger than his previous limit of power", but that is very very wrong. What Doffy is referring to is that the COMPRESSION effect of Luffy's Gear 4th attacks, basically when he compresses his fist into itself, that's what specifically increases Luffy's power by several times. This means that the compression effect of Boundman doesn't multiply the power of Gear 2nd or Gear 3rd attacks. What it means is that it is increasing Luffy's basic Gear 4th Punches and Attacks by several times.

So we have a non-compressed Gear 4th punches and attacks, where Luffy can punch and kick without compressing his fist, and it's only when he compresses his fist, that it's power is multiplied by several times. That means every time that Luffy compresses his fist like he does in Gear 4th, he is multiplying his punches power by several times. This would be a univeral multiplier.

Now luckily for us, Luffy basically always compresses his fist and uses these attacks for scaling, so that doesn't change much in itself. But we do have one big huge factor. LUFFY USES BASIC GEAR 4TH FLEXING AND ARM MOVEMENTS TO BREAK 9 OF DOFFY'S STRINGS
eOuekvC.jpg

This means that non-compressed basic Gear 4th punches and attacks scale to 9 Doffy Strings and would therefore scale to 1.1 Gigatons (Large Mountain level). Now when Luffy compresses his fist and releases attacks like Kong Gun, Rhino Schneider, Culverin, Leo Bazooka. etc. Luffy is multiplying his power by several times beyond that basic non-compressed Gear 4th attacks that can casually break 9 of Doffy Strings. This would mean Gear 4th Boundman's AP scales to 3.3 to 4.4 Gigatons (Large Mountain level+ to Island level).

This also majorly helps solidify the gap between Gear 4th Luffy and Ulti. Luffy was gonna use basic non-compressed Gear 4th attacks to break out of Ulti's grasp and therefore would only need the non-compressed strength against Ulti, likely meaning any compressed Gear 4th attack would have clapped Ulti's cheeks.

Now as we obviously know, Hao Infusion Base Luffy's attacks clashed evenly with Hybrid Kaidou's Hao Infusion and he obviously can use Gear 2nd and Gear 3rd to hurt Kaidou with this power as well.
x27lH2b.jpg

But then he also stacks Gear 4th's compression effect on top of these effects with Over Kong Gun. This would make Over Kong Gun at bare minimun 3-4x stronger than the Base Hao Infusion attacks.
VLnVb6I.jpg

Now when Luffy clashes his Bajrang Gun with Kaidou's Blazing Bagua, throughout the entire clash, Luffy's fist has still not unleashed the compression effect.
uT6FGSW.jpg


qHtt9Vd.jpg

45K2Olh.jpg

iam7qwr.jpg

And it's only in the final blow that Luffy releases the compression effect and ultimately defeats Kaidou
pDM85Ig.jpg

This means the Bajrang Gun would also be 3-4x stronger than his regular Gear 5th attacks

So yeah, that was my essay and realization of everything
So we missed it , at this whole time?. But wait does this mean Luffy's Attack is 4x stronger than his Durability Right?
 
I really really Confused now, with Mitch explanation those 4x Multiplier is From Previous Gear right? Because that statement is way before Luffy broke the Strings, Doffy implying 2 of Luffy Previous Attack which is Kong gun and Rhyno Schneider, would that be refering to Gear 3rd? If it's the Gear4th itself then I'm not gonna involve in this topic Again.
 
But then he also stacks Gear 4th's compression effect on top of these effects with Over Kong Gun. This would make Over Kong Gun at bare minimun 3-4x stronger than the Base Hao Infusion attacks.
Agreed.
This means the Bajrang Gun would also be 3-4x stronger than his regular Gear 5th attacks
Double agree.
It's flat out nonsense to say G4/G5's compression doesn't stack on Luffy's base CoC when he can take hits comparable to his own IN BASE anyway. Why would Luffy even use an attack at least x4 stronger physically to amp his COC Infused blows if there's basically no point. And the anime shows G4 physically scaling to an extent, so saying G4+Hao isn't a stack is just ignoring facts.


gear 5th isn't stronger physically than g4th
Slightly sus. Not ALWAYS stronger, I'd disagree. Upon appearing Gear Fifth's awakening was called either an "exponentional" or "far greater" increase going by the Gorosei's words. And that was used for "strength" as well.
It's definitely over Gear Fourth, but it isn't TOO far over Gear Fourth to where it eclipses it, just that he can do things at that level without having to worry about the compression like G4. Gear Fourth Previously was still doing almost as well as Awakening, but the latter just has the freedom of not worrying about a time limit. If you ignore the initial drop before the heartbeat restored it-
There's also Luffy himself saying he can do "everything he wanted to do", and we see him inflate his muscles on the spot (both to slam Kaido and return Boro Breath), so it's clear that the G4 muscle based increase is there.
 
I'm sorry, but could someone please sum up what Mitch has stated about Gear 4th? I got kinda lost (I know, I'm a pleb).
Just a re-statement of what we already accept for Gear 4 multiplier. It isn't a multiplier of Luffy's lower forms like Gear 2 or 3, but the compressive effect of his limbs enhances the power of his punches while he's in his Gear 4 (or 5) state.
 
Maybe not stronger than compressed g4 attacks but absolutely stronger than gear 4 itself, he is coated in both armament and conquerors and his rubber body is significantly stronger due to awakening, gear 5 is also capable of doing the compression.
armament and conquerors, which g4th uses
rubber body significantly stronger than base
the compression that he only uses with his strongest techniques
Slightly sus. Not ALWAYS stronger, I'd disagree. Upon appearing Gear Fifth's awakening was called either an "exponentional" or "far greater" increase going by the Gorosei's words. And that was used for "strength" as well.
It's definitely over Gear Fourth, but it isn't TOO far over Gear Fourth to where it eclipses it, just that he can do things at that level without having to worry about the compression like G4. Gear Fourth Previously was still doing almost as well as Awakening, but the latter just has the freedom of not worrying about a time limit. If you ignore the initial drop before the heartbeat restored it-
There's also Luffy himself saying he can do "everything he wanted to do", and we see him inflate his muscles on the spot (both to slam Kaido and return Boro Breath), so it's clear that the G4 muscle based increase is there.
He can amp himself up to that level, but his regular state isn't superior. The one getting smacked around by Kaidou isn't superior
 
Although I have doubts as to actually applying it as 4 * 9 strings, as he snapped the strings with his full upper body, not just with one punch.
 
He can amp himself up to that level, but his regular state isn't superior.
What I meant, yes. I mean, it's all one form. Awakening is basically Composite Luffy.
The one getting smacked around by Kaidou isn't superior
"Smacked around" is a lil' much- he was taking all the hits and either no-selling them, tanking them, or just shrugging them off. For the most part Luffy seemed to be enduring everything just fine up until the last clash where the heat was a threat.
 
Base G4 scales to 9 strings
Compressed attacks scale x4 higher
KKG scales x4 higher than that

... I think-
So compressed attacks as of Dressrosa are 4.4 gigatons and KKG is 4x that... ok then.

Wait, aren't compressed attacks "several times" G4's base? Wouldn't that only make it a 3x multiplier?
 
That's the proposal from what I'm gathering, though personally I don't think it is as simple as that.
Honestly, seperating "base" gear fourth (so Gear Fourth naturally>9 strings), compressed Gear Fourth and "Strongest Attacks" seems like a safe bet.
The issue is less with Luffy and more when we get to scaling him to Kaido, since:
Base COC Infusion Scales to Hybrid Kaido
G2/G3 also does
G4 also does--
G5.. Also does??? Bajrang Gun is the only attack I would confidently say scales over Kaido's full value since it flat out full on overpowered him and broke his horn. Everything else seems to be teetering on Kaido's value, or-- Kaido's drunken empowered state/super hybrid just makes him scale higher-

I need mental prepping before the post-wano revisions come around
 
Honestly, seperating "base" gear fourth (so Gear Fourth naturally>9 strings), compressed Gear Fourth and "Strongest Attacks" seems like a safe bet.
The issue is less with Luffy and more when we get to scaling him to Kaido, since:
Base COC Infusion Scales to Hybrid Kaido
G2/G3 also does
G4 also does--
G5.. Also does??? Bajrang Gun is the only attack I would confidently say scales over Kaido's full value since it flat out full on overpowered him and broke his horn. Everything else seems to be teetering on Kaido's value, or-- Kaido's drunken empowered state/super hybrid just makes him scale higher-

I need mental prepping before the post-wano revisions come around
One of the reasons for that is that the Haoshoku Infusion is not a multiplier to Luffy's abilities but an additive.

Let's say that, Base Luffy = 1, G2 Luffy = 5, G3 Luffy = 10.

And adding his Haoshoku infusion is a +40 to his attacks.

So when Luffy is fighting Kaido with his Hao Infusion slapped on top of his other Gear attacks, he's hitting Kaido with with attacks varying from "45" to "50". Not a big difference between them in the grand scale of things. Obviously a Gear 3 hit with Hao Infusion is going to be more powerful than a Gear 2 hit with Hao Infusion, but the different isn't as drastic as it is between ordinary Gear 2 and ordinary Gear 3.

If that makes sense.
 
1 Doffy String Durability = 122.596 Megatons (Mountain level)

1 Doffy String<Doffy's Black Knight Durability<=Gear 2nd Luffy<=Diable Jambe Sanji<Doffy's Physicals and Durability<9 Doffy Strings<Doffy's Busoshoku Haki Durability<=Gear 4th Boundman Luffy Non-Compressed Attacks<(4x Stronger) Gear 4th Boundman Luffy Compressed Attacks
 
One of the reasons for that is that the Haoshoku Infusion is not a multiplier to Luffy's abilities but an additive.

Let's say that, Base Luffy = 1, G2 Luffy = 5, G3 Luffy = 10.

And adding his Haoshoku infusion is a +40 to his attacks.

So when Luffy is fighting Kaido with his Hao Infusion slapped on top of his other Gear attacks, he's hitting Kaido with with attacks varying from "45" to "50". Not a big difference between them in the grand scale of things. Obviously a Gear 3 hit with Hao Infusion is going to be more powerful than a Gear 2 hit with Hao Infusion, but the different isn't as drastic as it is between ordinary Gear 2 and ordinary Gear 3.

If that makes sense.
But then we'd have to also accept the fact that base Luffy still scales even without CoC Infusion, which I recall was a very controversial thing because of the G4 stack and all.
But I see where you're coming from. To me that always made the most sense, since Luffy's durability still scaled to Kaido's own attacks even though (as far as we know) CoC Infusion has very little to do with defense, and his attacks with CoC infusion seemed to be the edge, rather than an entire game changer.
 
Yeh. 3.3 to 4.4 gigatons. Not sure which, but the general idea seems to be 3 or 4. While KKG is at least x4.
But don't we always use 3x as the lowball with "several"

1 Doffy String<Doffy's Black Knight Durability<=Gear 2nd Luffy<=Diable Jambe Sanji<Doffy's Physicals and Durability<9 Doffy Strings<Doffy's Busoshoku Haki Durability<=Gear 4th Boundman Luffy Non-Compressed Attacks<(4x Stronger) Gear 4th Boundman Luffy Compressed Attacks
Ok, why are we using a 4x minimum when we almost always use the 3x lowball for "several"?
 
Thanks to those who answered my question on the multiplier.

Now, back to an earlier discussion, how come Base Post-Kata Luffy isn't considered at least somewhat comparable to Base Kata without Haki when the 2 fought each other for quite some time while both were injured?

Also, how come Post-Kata base Luffy isn't ranked as more durable than Bound Man? On his profile, only Pre-Udon Luffy is more durable than Boundman.

Lastly, when is the compression stuff gonna be added to Luffy's profile?
 
Back
Top