- 31,574
- 28,025
Dual Binoculars does raise a good point.
In the panel of the crater we can see the hole that Tomura made at the bottom of it. It would not be visible if the crater actually was 10 kilometers across.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
My Hero Academia: America Brings Upgrades/Revisions
- Thread starter TheRustyOne
- Start date
- Status
In the panel of the crater we can see the hole that Tomura made at the bottom of it. It would not be visible if the crater actually was 10 kilometers across.
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #242
If the calc has problems, the entire thread becomes bunk.
Might be best to wait and see what Therefir has to say.
Might be best to wait and see what Therefir has to say.
- 31,574
- 28,025
This is another calc point (not necessarily a debunk, just a question) but when Star and Stripe makes her avatar that is "1000 times bigger" how do we know that she means it is 1000 times taller than her? Couldn't bigger also refer to overall volume?
I was thinking about this after we have the comparison panel between the missiles, Star and Stripe and the avatar's hand.
I was thinking about this after we have the comparison panel between the missiles, Star and Stripe and the avatar's hand.
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #244
I think we'd need another translation in that case, if that becomes a problem as well. Another translation had it be 1000X her own size.
Though 1000X bigger does make me think of taller, not volume wise. But I guess it isn't impossible?
Though 1000X bigger does make me think of taller, not volume wise. But I guess it isn't impossible?
- 1,617
- 1,597
If the volume is 1000x bigger, that would include her size as well. The definition for volume incorporates height, width, and length into the equation. Just looking at Star makes it obvious her height is increased immensely.
- 31,574
- 28,025
Yes, I'm obviously not denying that the avatar is immensely taller than her, but a 1000 x increase in volume would not mean a 1000 x increase in height.
- 11,559
- 10,996
Star's ability is based on the common sense of the people around her. It is more likely to be 1000 times greater in terms of height than volume, based on the fact that when you compared your size to someone else's no one thinks about body volume
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #248
Did just that and the hole is far too small, a diameter around 50 meters. (And I was highballing, the actual size would be less than that)
The crater shouldn't be any smaller than this. The explosion is bigger than the giant, which is 1000X bigger than Star. A 50 meter crater would be far smaller than the giant. Using the hole is pointless, but the ocean depth being used also seems incorrect. So I don't think it is possible to truly calc the size of the crater using that shot.
Best bet would be to just calc the explosion, and use the explosion formula. Though the current calc assumes SaS is All Might size, which I believe is incorrect, for safety I'd put her at 6 FT or 1.82 m. Doing that gets me 29.96 MT for the explosion, divided by 10 and we get 2.99 MT for a single missile.
Which is... Low 7-B. Consistent?
- 31,574
- 28,025
50 meters? I got the diameter of the crater to be roughly 200 meters across.
Although... Is just calcing the explosion alone an option? Because that result seems a lot less out there than High 7-A.
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
I Feel 200 would be more consistent with the sheer size we saw from the Tiamat Missile Explosion
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #251
How? What are you doing to make that tiny hole that big, it doesn't appear to be any larger than Shigaraki's width.
Should only be slightly bigger than his shoulder to shoulder width right?
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
Also Looking at the panel again the doesn't seem to be shigaraki but the hole he fled through, meaning that star's height from her giant form and Therefir's method may still work
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
some issues may have come with the scaling for Star's missile explosion, lowering it's rating
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
I took a look at 332 again, and it doesn't seem to give any indicator for the hole being the size of shigaraki, only showing shigaraki later jumping out of his with enough for to cause more cracks
- 31,574
- 28,025
I used the height of Shigaraki as the diameter of it, as the diagram showed up lying across the top of the hole at the top at first.
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #257
Using the Ocean depth is incorrect, since 50 km isn't even off the continental shelf, which is somewhere around 200 km.
We can't really measure the hole, but Shigaraki's position coming out of the hole means there was enough room for him to stand. I don't remember any other way to calc that hole size, so at best I can say it is slightly more than Shigaraki's width.
I highly doubt we should talk that picture seriously, also in that picture his height was bigger than the hole's diameter.
We can't really measure the hole, but Shigaraki's position coming out of the hole means there was enough room for him to stand. I don't remember any other way to calc that hole size, so at best I can say it is slightly more than Shigaraki's width.
I highly doubt we should talk that picture seriously, also in that picture his height was bigger than the hole's diameter.
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
if this does cause issues dies this mean we need another supporting feat for High 7-A/6-C My Hero?
Baken384
He/Him- 3,655
- 3,796
I think that's the case unfortunately.
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #260
If this feat isn't High 7-A, than the Heroes Rising feat is back to being an outlier. There might still be an upgrade, but not up to High 7-A.
Baken384
He/Him- 3,655
- 3,796
Dammit.. we were so close.
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
Ah Ok, I looked at Therefir's again, and how he got the depth, he used a scientific article as a source for the ocean depth being 3.7 km on average, meaning that while lofty, it may still be correct
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #263
That depth is highballed, since the big drops in the oceans don't really start until they're off the continental shelf.
The average ocean depth of 3.7 km wouldn't be that close to Japan, usually. It might be possible, but it's likely very rare.
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
do we know the distance from the shore to where the fight is taking place?
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #265
50 KM, it is stated that's where Shigaraki was waiting for her.
Chapter 329. "Along her flight path, 50 km ahead of the landing point... Is him!"
Chapter 329. "Along her flight path, 50 km ahead of the landing point... Is him!"
- 31,574
- 28,025
Assuming the landing point is somewhere on the coast, the fight is taking place 50 km off-shore.
- 937
- 333
Wasn't it stated they're outside of Japan's Airspace?
- 1,617
- 1,597
Yes, it would? I mean, it's obvious that this is a general increase in terms of volume. And if you know how mathematics works, you would know that an increase in volume would be an increase in several other dimensions, such as; width, height, and length.
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
Ah, ok thank 3.7 would be the most likely, as at that point it's reaching into the pacific plate (we know because we're nowhere near any other landmasses, which the Philippine plate would give us at least in the distance and not the Eurasian plate because well, we're not going into China and stuff), which after 3.7 km can reach 6km normally and 9km to 10km in the trenches (it's from the same article you provided)
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #270
Did they? Also what distance would that be if they did?
- 937
- 333
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
if they were than we'd have to assume 3.7km as the depth , as by that point they are very far into the pacific which means that it's likely, unless we want to take it to outlier territory with 6km depths
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #273
What distance is that though, how far out is Japanese airspace? They stated Shigaraki was waiting for her 50 km ahead of her landing point.
- 31,574
- 28,025
I think you're mistaken. Changing the volume by a certain amount doesn't mean that all of the dimensions change by the same amount. Look here.
Quoted relevant part:
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
(https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/1a/Air_Defense_Identification_Zone_of_Japan3.png) here's a link of the Japanese airspace, don't have a distance for it but we can atleast assume they are somewhere out there
- 11,363
- 13,481
- Thread starter
- #276
I'm just wait for what Therefir has to say, I'm out of my element here.
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
Fair enough, I can't really do this either
Mapl3Sy4up
Username Only- 5,483
- 3,177
though if we could find another High 7-A feat would posting it here work? (I don't have any ideas for those outside of the Cube, but I'm just wondering)
- 1,617
- 1,597
Ok, then. I've read somewhere that ocean depth on average is around 1500 meters.
Fair point.
- 1,617
- 1,597
Honestly wouldn't be hard to find, like, at all. In fact, there are a few High 7-A feats that are just ight under our noses, people just haven't realized it yet. I'll eventually elaborate once I finish looking into it.
- Status
