-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Meltlilith vs Yuuki Kagurazaka
- Thread starter TriforcePower1
- Start date
- Status
- 16,606
- 1,789
Any servant with a luck stat of B or higher passively avoids/counters inevitable or close to inevitable out comes. They essentially overwrite fate to survive impossible to or highly unlikely to survive situations. The most famous example is that a servant with B luck or higher can survive Gae Bolg, which is a conceptual death curse that warps causality to always strike the heart; the spear literally piercing the heart before the lance is even thrust. Despite this, Servants with a high enough luck are capable of surviving it
If time stop really is that absolute or likely to land, then she will probably survive it
If time stop really is that absolute or likely to land, then she will probably survive it
- 15,763
- 7,786
I mean Yuuki has Fate Manipulation, better Causality Manipulation, Probability Manipulation so the likelyhood of his abilities hitting is high.
- 9,524
- 1,789
Pretty sure Melt should resist time manip anyway
- 15,867
- 5,780
Yuuki has Fate & Casuality Manip strong enough to boost his own stats, change the outcome on an event, and his probability manip can increase his chance of evasion or straight up nulling an opponents attack.
- 15,763
- 7,786
Tough, it is not on her profile so it is not applicable to the debate without a CRT. Even if it was there, Yuuki can used his Time Manipulation to boost his own speed which she cannot directly resist since it is not afffecting her but only Yuuki. This argument for Time Manipulation Speed Boost is something is learn for the same others thread for Medaka's Infinite Speed Boost.Paul Frank said:
- 16,606
- 1,789
I gotta double check if she has authority but if so then it was already accepted but just hasn't been added. There are several fate CRTs floating around that got accepted but just not done because of how many profiles they apply to
- 15,867
- 5,780
Yeah, same with Slime. Hey, can we please close these until both CRT's are done?
- 16,606
- 1,789
The CRT is done, it just never got added.Milly Rocking Bandit said:
- 15,867
- 5,780
Well, I'm nearly done with Slime's CRT.
- 16,606
- 1,789
Alright, authority is added to her profile. Now her resistance to time manip sets her safe
- 15,867
- 5,780
Yuuki's CRT hasn't been accepted, and Yuuki's time manipulation works on people who have resistances to it.
- 16,606
- 1,789
She resists all of those things, and anyway, they can already dodge/survive attacks that manipulate all of those things to make make attacks completely inevitableElizhaa said:
- 16,606
- 1,789
She was already able to apply time to the lack of time within the far side of the moon with her law manip.NeoSuperior said:
- 15,867
- 5,780
Can we at least like... Wait until my CRT is done, though? Jeez.
- 16,606
- 1,789
This gets countered by her authority, which grants her resistance to a cocktail of things including time manipElizhaa said:
- 2,486
- 872
I'm not super religious but Jesus Christ this is turning out bad for Yuuki.
Adding that authority was just a nail in an already closed coffin.
Adding that authority was just a nail in an already closed coffin.
- 15,867
- 5,780
Like I said, can we wait until my CRT gets accepted before this gets started up again?
- 16,606
- 1,789
What exactly his this CRT going to add?
- 15,867
- 5,780
Many things, such as resistances to Casuality Manipulation, Life & Death Manipulation, Durability Negation, etc. Just continuing on whilst there are things that are clearly missing from Yuuki's profile makes this rather unfair.
- 16,606
- 1,789
But... How will those things actually change the outcome of the match? Melt already bypasses resistance with the melt virus, her main win condition, so adding more isn't gonna help him.
- 15,867
- 5,780
There are arguments that I'd like to make, but again, they'd be a lot more credible if people could actually see these within the profile.
- 2,486
- 872
Uh, with Melt's CRT done she resists all of those.
- 2,486
- 872
Fate has been downplayed likely because of Nasu's tendency to exaggerate and overstate in his writing, as well as the fact that we simply didn't catch the things before.
- 16,606
- 1,789
Because she isn't top tier in fate, just high tier. This thread was more to prove the point of Nasu supremacy in High 3-A.GLHF22 said:
In her previous tier she was up against Masadsverse characters with 1-A hax, some of which are passive. That's the reason fate character weren't really there
- 16,606
- 1,789
It's also because in the previous tier she was in Nasu was up against things like Masadaverse, which have insane levels of 1-A haxKnightOfSunlight said:
- 21,783
- 4,826
Yes and yes.
- 2,486
- 872
I believe she has conceptually based resistance with her authority.
Not to mention that her authority granted resistance stacks with her natural servant resistance to those.
Not to mention that her authority granted resistance stacks with her natural servant resistance to those.
- 15,867
- 5,780
The entire time, I've seen that her Melt Virus is conceptual. So, why is Saraswati Meltout the only list of conceptual ability she has on her profile?
Furthermore, how far into her AP is Meltlilith? After reading, Yuuki could place her into a similar situation. His Physical Attack Nullification completely negates any physical attack to those comparable to him, similar with Magic Nulity. His Aura could keep her at bay, even if it couldn't harm her to prevent absorption.
I've also seen that her Resistance Negation would negate EVERYTHING Yuuki can resist... but what I've seen from the profile, it only seems to negate the resistance of Data Manipulation, and likely absorption.
On the topic of resistances, yeah, she resists it. But Yuuki's potency of those abilities can beat people WITH that resistance.
Furthermore, how far into her AP is Meltlilith? After reading, Yuuki could place her into a similar situation. His Physical Attack Nullification completely negates any physical attack to those comparable to him, similar with Magic Nulity. His Aura could keep her at bay, even if it couldn't harm her to prevent absorption.
I've also seen that her Resistance Negation would negate EVERYTHING Yuuki can resist... but what I've seen from the profile, it only seems to negate the resistance of Data Manipulation, and likely absorption.
On the topic of resistances, yeah, she resists it. But Yuuki's potency of those abilities can beat people WITH that resistance.
- 2,486
- 872
I'm not the big guy for all this, wait for Iapitus, but I'll answer what I can:
1. From what I can tell, Melt Virus is conceptual because it can melt and absorb the Sakura Labyrinth, which is a maze constructed of imaginary numbers (abstract concepts) and based on the conceptual being of a "cute girl's heart" (yes that is the truth, yes CCC is insane).
2. Melt is vastly above baseline. She equals or slightly surpasses BB, who casually created an infinite space just because she felt like torturing the protag. She did this for each of the main cast. Again, all done casually. Melt was considered a threat to her so she's likely either equal or slightly above BB.
3. Again, from what I can tell her Resistance Negation is also conceptual enough to dig into the moon cell, past all of its various defenses, including vast conceptual defenses. She's also able to negate the res of administrative AIs, which would have the entire moon cell ensuring that they function.
And 4. She already resists the concept of all of his abilities (thanks authority!), though this is where things start to fly over my head and I don't full understand everything, so I'm gonna not say much.
This is all what I remember from CCC extrapolated here. I'm in no way the person to debate on this, but this is what came to mind for me.
Wait for Iapitus to come here and give his two cents, he's the one who seems to know this stuff.
1. From what I can tell, Melt Virus is conceptual because it can melt and absorb the Sakura Labyrinth, which is a maze constructed of imaginary numbers (abstract concepts) and based on the conceptual being of a "cute girl's heart" (yes that is the truth, yes CCC is insane).
2. Melt is vastly above baseline. She equals or slightly surpasses BB, who casually created an infinite space just because she felt like torturing the protag. She did this for each of the main cast. Again, all done casually. Melt was considered a threat to her so she's likely either equal or slightly above BB.
3. Again, from what I can tell her Resistance Negation is also conceptual enough to dig into the moon cell, past all of its various defenses, including vast conceptual defenses. She's also able to negate the res of administrative AIs, which would have the entire moon cell ensuring that they function.
And 4. She already resists the concept of all of his abilities (thanks authority!), though this is where things start to fly over my head and I don't full understand everything, so I'm gonna not say much.
This is all what I remember from CCC extrapolated here. I'm in no way the person to debate on this, but this is what came to mind for me.
Wait for Iapitus to come here and give his two cents, he's the one who seems to know this stuff.
- 15,867
- 5,780
Okay, then Melt takes this Yuuki is second fiddle, and Meltlilith is top dog.
- 2,486
- 872
4 more hours of grace then?
- 2,355
- 270
I'm not really invested into Meltlilith to know everything about her, but one slight nitpick. I would disagree on her being above BB, or even on her level. Yes, there is the statement of BB being threatened by her, but there is also the fact that BB was even more threatened by awakening of Gilgamesh even though at the time he was unable to resist her Authority and was really weakened. It's probably more her being extra careful no one destroys her work. BB is powered by the Moon Cell and at least 13 goddesses. Meltlilith was given the power of 3 goddesses, just to compare things. I think it's still a good way above baseline, but as I said, slight nitpick.
- 1,857
- 82
She was already able to apply time to the lack of time within the far side of the moon with her law manip.
"lack of time" is not quite the same as "concept of time non-existent" and concepts > laws, in general. Not to mention due to SBA it would be too late to just "come back afterwards" anyway.
How long does Melt take in-character until concept stuff gets used?
"lack of time" is not quite the same as "concept of time non-existent" and concepts > laws, in general. Not to mention due to SBA it would be too late to just "come back afterwards" anyway.
How long does Melt take in-character until concept stuff gets used?
- 7,046
- 4,415
She starts off with the conceptual absorbption.
- Status
Similar threads
