- 12,522
- 3,488
I‘ll start off by breaking down the relevant parts of the blog arguing Low 1-C. My replies will be in bold.
“In the English localizations, Another Dimension's road was stated to be extra-dimensional and beyond thespace-time continuum, along with being part of an Extra Dimension(which is a real life term to describe qualitatively higher dimensions) beyond space and time. It's also referred to as another world beyond time and dimensions, in most fan translations of this Tweet.”
The first scan is describing a machine that can provide transportation through space-time. You additionally use a Wikipedia link to argue that because the term extra-dimensional is used to describe higher dimensions above the fourth, it must apply in this particular scenario. It’s very common for fictional verses to describe dimensions as being universes, and Kirby is a clear example of this. You’re disregarding in-verse context to push for a higher tier. As for the statements of being beyond space-time, a different universe will naturally have its own space-time separate from the main universe, and therefore be outside its sphere of influence. This doesn’t necessarily imply a qualitative superiority.
“Translated (by the doc above): "An ancient swordsman who can destroy everything due to his strength. Not a clone, he was awakened from an unknown another dimensional road beyond space-time. Records remain that he has been sealed in various eras, but he has never been terminated."
The kanjis used for "space-time" are "空間"(space, as the dimension of height, depth, and width within which all things exist and move) and "時間"(time). The kanjis that ended up being translated as "beyond" are "超えよ", which means "exceeding", meaning that Another Dimension's road is outright superior to space-time along with being outside of it.”
Another website linking to a Wikipedia page. Exceeding can also mean going outside of the space-time continuum’s limits, which the road does by linking other dimensions in the Kirby verse.
“Official translation (the doc didn't have a new one): "Kumazaki: The True Arena is like another “what if” scenario, so you can’t really consider everything to be connected. Furthermore, the extra-dimensional road that opens up when Galacta Knight appears transcends space-time, so it’s difficult to give it a concrete place in the timeline. But if you consider the stages in which Galacta Knight appeared in the past three games, I think that will give you some food for thought."”
A road that links with other dimensions which have their own space-time would transcend the space-times of individual dimensions, yes.
“"ジャマハローア！！ すっごく強いパワーが集まると、別次元の なんていったかしら…そうそう！イクウカンに通じる「穴」が 開かれるって、ハイネス様が言ってたわよ！ 時も次元も超えて、別の世界に通じちゃうから キケンなんですよぉ～、って言ってたわ！！ #星のカービィスターアライズ"
Translated (by the doc above): "Bonjam! Gathering immense, strong power, we're having something to do with that other dimension... oh, I get it! Lord Hyness said he's opening a hole into another dimension! As we cross time and space, he said "Whatever danger could there be...!" in that other world!"
I'm showing this translation for maximum transparency, as I've relied on the doc for most other translations, but the truth is, this one is outright wrong. It doesn't even have a mention of dimensions like every other translation despite the fact that the term is clearly brought up.
Translated (more accurately): "Bonjam! When very strong power gathers, a hole leading to... hmm. What was it that he said? Yes, yes! Lord Hyness said that a hole leading to Another Dimension will be opened! He said it's dangerous because it leads to another world which exceeds time and dimensions!"
"時間" is "time", and more notably, 次元 (jigen) is "dimensions". As everysource will tell you, jigen always refers to mathematical dimensions. The fact that Another Dimension exceeds them means it's superior to the 4 physical dimensions that comprise Kirby's space-time continuum.”
More links that direct to Wikipedia articles, again disregarding context in-verse. ”Exceeding time and dimensions” could potentially be Low 1-C if used under the proper context but not here.
“It makes up the space between dimensions, and allows its users to travel to any point in space-time, including the distant realm of the Dream Kingdom and practically every time period as shown with Galacta-Knight and HR-D3. When Another Dimension was consumed by dimensional walls, they seemingly traveled to the past. Either that, or Kirby travelled to the future in order to stop them and restore Another Dimension. Or maybe the dimensional walls outright started to consume time like any other spatial dimension without travelling to a time period in particular. All 3 of these explanations require some assumptions but they also each strongly imply that the space of Another Dimension has a superiority over time (especially the third one, which makes more sense than its complexity might lead you to believe but is still just an interpretation). Do keep in mind that this doesn't apply to Magolor's home universe, though. The doc linked at the top of this blog firmly establishes that in its translation of Magolor's dialogue.”
First scan is just someone hypothesizing about what exists in the space between dimensions. Second and third are just dimensional travel. Now hold on a second, if AD was Low 1-C like you claim it is then why would time travel have any effect on it? Just like that you proved it isn’t 5D.
“Translated (by the doc above): "You did it, Kirby! On my ship, the right wing is back! When all the parts are equipped and the ship is ready to fly, I’ll take us to my homeland. My homeland is far away… It’s just past another dimension’s road that connects with this star. It’s a long way away, but when this ship is completed, it’s a jump away. So, look forward to it."
This also doesn't apply to the other various parallel worlds inside of Another Dimension, since the latter specifically leads to the former just like with Halcandra, as stated in numerous descriptions
Translated (by the doc above): "Another Dimension Heroes: Through the influence of Hyness’s continued prayers, a hole in another dimension was opened, leading to various dimensions. And in these dimensions, you can become the Dream Friends! However, strong bosses beyond belief are waiting. Gather hearts under another sky, and the light of hope... create it!"”
This is simply saying that AD can act as a gateway to other dimensions, you are extrapolating this to mean it physically encompasses them. So to conclude this post, I have not seen anything here that would qualify as Low 1-C.
“In the English localizations, Another Dimension's road was stated to be extra-dimensional and beyond thespace-time continuum, along with being part of an Extra Dimension(which is a real life term to describe qualitatively higher dimensions) beyond space and time. It's also referred to as another world beyond time and dimensions, in most fan translations of this Tweet.”
The first scan is describing a machine that can provide transportation through space-time. You additionally use a Wikipedia link to argue that because the term extra-dimensional is used to describe higher dimensions above the fourth, it must apply in this particular scenario. It’s very common for fictional verses to describe dimensions as being universes, and Kirby is a clear example of this. You’re disregarding in-verse context to push for a higher tier. As for the statements of being beyond space-time, a different universe will naturally have its own space-time separate from the main universe, and therefore be outside its sphere of influence. This doesn’t necessarily imply a qualitative superiority.
“Translated (by the doc above): "An ancient swordsman who can destroy everything due to his strength. Not a clone, he was awakened from an unknown another dimensional road beyond space-time. Records remain that he has been sealed in various eras, but he has never been terminated."
The kanjis used for "space-time" are "空間"(space, as the dimension of height, depth, and width within which all things exist and move) and "時間"(time). The kanjis that ended up being translated as "beyond" are "超えよ", which means "exceeding", meaning that Another Dimension's road is outright superior to space-time along with being outside of it.”
Another website linking to a Wikipedia page. Exceeding can also mean going outside of the space-time continuum’s limits, which the road does by linking other dimensions in the Kirby verse.
“Official translation (the doc didn't have a new one): "Kumazaki: The True Arena is like another “what if” scenario, so you can’t really consider everything to be connected. Furthermore, the extra-dimensional road that opens up when Galacta Knight appears transcends space-time, so it’s difficult to give it a concrete place in the timeline. But if you consider the stages in which Galacta Knight appeared in the past three games, I think that will give you some food for thought."”
A road that links with other dimensions which have their own space-time would transcend the space-times of individual dimensions, yes.
“"ジャマハローア！！ すっごく強いパワーが集まると、別次元の なんていったかしら…そうそう！イクウカンに通じる「穴」が 開かれるって、ハイネス様が言ってたわよ！ 時も次元も超えて、別の世界に通じちゃうから キケンなんですよぉ～、って言ってたわ！！ #星のカービィスターアライズ"
Translated (by the doc above): "Bonjam! Gathering immense, strong power, we're having something to do with that other dimension... oh, I get it! Lord Hyness said he's opening a hole into another dimension! As we cross time and space, he said "Whatever danger could there be...!" in that other world!"
I'm showing this translation for maximum transparency, as I've relied on the doc for most other translations, but the truth is, this one is outright wrong. It doesn't even have a mention of dimensions like every other translation despite the fact that the term is clearly brought up.
Translated (more accurately): "Bonjam! When very strong power gathers, a hole leading to... hmm. What was it that he said? Yes, yes! Lord Hyness said that a hole leading to Another Dimension will be opened! He said it's dangerous because it leads to another world which exceeds time and dimensions!"
"時間" is "time", and more notably, 次元 (jigen) is "dimensions". As everysource will tell you, jigen always refers to mathematical dimensions. The fact that Another Dimension exceeds them means it's superior to the 4 physical dimensions that comprise Kirby's space-time continuum.”
More links that direct to Wikipedia articles, again disregarding context in-verse. ”Exceeding time and dimensions” could potentially be Low 1-C if used under the proper context but not here.
“It makes up the space between dimensions, and allows its users to travel to any point in space-time, including the distant realm of the Dream Kingdom and practically every time period as shown with Galacta-Knight and HR-D3. When Another Dimension was consumed by dimensional walls, they seemingly traveled to the past. Either that, or Kirby travelled to the future in order to stop them and restore Another Dimension. Or maybe the dimensional walls outright started to consume time like any other spatial dimension without travelling to a time period in particular. All 3 of these explanations require some assumptions but they also each strongly imply that the space of Another Dimension has a superiority over time (especially the third one, which makes more sense than its complexity might lead you to believe but is still just an interpretation). Do keep in mind that this doesn't apply to Magolor's home universe, though. The doc linked at the top of this blog firmly establishes that in its translation of Magolor's dialogue.”
First scan is just someone hypothesizing about what exists in the space between dimensions. Second and third are just dimensional travel. Now hold on a second, if AD was Low 1-C like you claim it is then why would time travel have any effect on it? Just like that you proved it isn’t 5D.
“Translated (by the doc above): "You did it, Kirby! On my ship, the right wing is back! When all the parts are equipped and the ship is ready to fly, I’ll take us to my homeland. My homeland is far away… It’s just past another dimension’s road that connects with this star. It’s a long way away, but when this ship is completed, it’s a jump away. So, look forward to it."
This also doesn't apply to the other various parallel worlds inside of Another Dimension, since the latter specifically leads to the former just like with Halcandra, as stated in numerous descriptions
Translated (by the doc above): "Another Dimension Heroes: Through the influence of Hyness’s continued prayers, a hole in another dimension was opened, leading to various dimensions. And in these dimensions, you can become the Dream Friends! However, strong bosses beyond belief are waiting. Gather hearts under another sky, and the light of hope... create it!"”
This is simply saying that AD can act as a gateway to other dimensions, you are extrapolating this to mean it physically encompasses them. So to conclude this post, I have not seen anything here that would qualify as Low 1-C.
Last edited:
