- 2,360
- 1,298
A follow-up to this thread. I eventually allowed it to become inactive in order to get a better understanding of our confusing and seemingly self-contradictory tier 1 standards. In the process, I made a Q&A thread, started discussions with staff members, and edited my blog.
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blogeptocoptr027/Understanding_Kirby's_Messy_Cosmology:_Low_1-C_vs_2-C
The conclusion remains the same, the point of this thread is still to upgrade Kirby cosmology to Low 1-C. This time, I'll do my best to present the main argument in a clear and concise way to make sure no one ignores it or misinterprets it while reading the somewhat large wall of text that is my blog.
The Main Argument
According to our standards, a realm superior to the pre-existing dimensions of a cosmology is Low 1-C as long as the dimensions in question are physical dimensional axes rather than a synonym for "universe" or "world", and as long as the cosmology is 4D without it.
In this official Tweet, Another Dimension is referred to as another world which exceeds/surpasses (超えて) time and dimensions (次元).
"超えて" always refers to a superiority, unlike "越える" which can simply mean residing outside of something
"次元" always refers to mathematical dimensions (or dimensionality as a whole). Given how the statement is worded, it's already pretty hard to see it as relating to Another Dimension as anything other than a higher-dimensional place in relation to the other dimensions in the verse but this piece of info should seal the deal if what I learned on our Wiki's standards over the last few months is any indication. Also, keep in mind that this is just the main body of the argument. For more context and back-up evidence, you'll have to read the blog.
DISCLAIMER: Now that 2-C Kirby has been accepted, it's easy to jump to the conclusion that Kirby outright scales to his entire cosmology, making him Low 1-C. It's not that simple. though. High end Kirby feats are so ambiguous that it took YEARS and loads of context clues for Magolor's feat to become 2-C to begin with. If you want to upgrade it to Low 1-C, save it for another thread. Let's keep the cosmology as the main topic of discussion in this one.
Also, I'm keeping the votes of the last thread since the pro-Low 1-C arguments technically didn't change since then.
Agreement: 32 (Ultima, CloverDragon03, Justkillme42069, DaReaperMan, Arceus0x, azontr, AbaddonTheDissappointment, Lord_JJJ, Bernkastell, M1ntyIc3CreamXZ, Guardian_Doge, Starsprite53, ThatOneMofo, Apex_PredatorX, Greenshifter, sanicspood, Pokemonfan807, The_Pink_God, Livinmeme, GilverTheProtoAngelo, Ottavio_Merluzzo, Delta333, Meganova_Stella, Eseseso, Darkz, LeSupremeKing1, Kflare63, Kirbymovies, Mephistus, XXKINGXX69, Kirbonic_Pikmin, Bobsican)
Disagreement: 4 (Gohanblanco217, ShadowWarrior1999, Everything12, Efficiente)
Neutral: 8 (y3p_owo, Brak, ElexirBlue, HammerStrikes219, Tarang123, Sus, Elizhaa, Ned_the_outer_god)
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blogeptocoptr027/Understanding_Kirby's_Messy_Cosmology:_Low_1-C_vs_2-C
The conclusion remains the same, the point of this thread is still to upgrade Kirby cosmology to Low 1-C. This time, I'll do my best to present the main argument in a clear and concise way to make sure no one ignores it or misinterprets it while reading the somewhat large wall of text that is my blog.
The Main Argument
According to our standards, a realm superior to the pre-existing dimensions of a cosmology is Low 1-C as long as the dimensions in question are physical dimensional axes rather than a synonym for "universe" or "world", and as long as the cosmology is 4D without it.
In this official Tweet, Another Dimension is referred to as another world which exceeds/surpasses (超えて) time and dimensions (次元).
"超えて" always refers to a superiority, unlike "越える" which can simply mean residing outside of something
"次元" always refers to mathematical dimensions (or dimensionality as a whole). Given how the statement is worded, it's already pretty hard to see it as relating to Another Dimension as anything other than a higher-dimensional place in relation to the other dimensions in the verse but this piece of info should seal the deal if what I learned on our Wiki's standards over the last few months is any indication. Also, keep in mind that this is just the main body of the argument. For more context and back-up evidence, you'll have to read the blog.
DISCLAIMER: Now that 2-C Kirby has been accepted, it's easy to jump to the conclusion that Kirby outright scales to his entire cosmology, making him Low 1-C. It's not that simple. though. High end Kirby feats are so ambiguous that it took YEARS and loads of context clues for Magolor's feat to become 2-C to begin with. If you want to upgrade it to Low 1-C, save it for another thread. Let's keep the cosmology as the main topic of discussion in this one.
Also, I'm keeping the votes of the last thread since the pro-Low 1-C arguments technically didn't change since then.
Agreement: 32 (Ultima, CloverDragon03, Justkillme42069, DaReaperMan, Arceus0x, azontr, AbaddonTheDissappointment, Lord_JJJ, Bernkastell, M1ntyIc3CreamXZ, Guardian_Doge, Starsprite53, ThatOneMofo, Apex_PredatorX, Greenshifter, sanicspood, Pokemonfan807, The_Pink_God, Livinmeme, GilverTheProtoAngelo, Ottavio_Merluzzo, Delta333, Meganova_Stella, Eseseso, Darkz, LeSupremeKing1, Kflare63, Kirbymovies, Mephistus, XXKINGXX69, Kirbonic_Pikmin, Bobsican)
Disagreement: 4 (Gohanblanco217, ShadowWarrior1999, Everything12, Efficiente)
Neutral: 8 (y3p_owo, Brak, ElexirBlue, HammerStrikes219, Tarang123, Sus, Elizhaa, Ned_the_outer_god)
Last edited: