- 31,256
- 27,479
This is an important discussion on the status of how we treat Lightning Release jutsu in Naruto and their implications on the speed ratings.
Mitsuki's Snake Lightning
In Episode 36 of Boruto, Mitsuki uses a jutsu called Lightning Release: Snake Lightning to create a snake-shaped attack that is sent flying towards Shino who dodges it pretty easily.
This dodging has been calced at Mach 6,800 by assuming that the Snake Lightning was travelling at average cloud-to-ground lightning speeds. However in the video the Snake Lightning jutsu appears to be travelling rather slowly.
The argument for this to just be flawed cinematic time is to assume that the event occurs quickly in the first place by assuming that the Snake Lightning had to travel at average lightning speeds.
This is flawed as we don't have a canon speed for the Lightning Release: Snake Lightning jutsu, or a stated timeframe for the event depicted on-screen.
The only properties this particular jutsu has in common with actual lightning is that it conducts through water to an extent.
Aside from that the jutsu takes the shape of a giant snake and travels on-screen significantly slower than an actual lightning bolt.
For anyone curious as to what an actual lightning bolt looks like in the Naruto anime, this video shows quite clearly that cloud-to-ground lightning moves significantly faster than the Snake Lightning jutsu is depicted as.
For anyone who thinks this is purely a slowed down timeframe, there is an example of that actually happening where the fight slows down to show Sarada's perception and dodging of a thrown shurike. Or when the action goes into slow motion for Minato vs. Obito.
Visually speaking there is nothing in the animation itself suggesting the scene with Shino is just flawed cinematic time.
If anyone wants to bring up other Lightning Release jutsu, bear in mind that we don't treat all elemental jutsu as being the same speed as each other. Just because one character creates a Fire Release jutsu of a certain speed, for example, doesn't mean another character's Fire Release-based jutsu is just as fast.
I also want to note for anyone who believes we should never use anime timeframes that we currently use the anime timeframes for Toneri's Golden Wheel Reincarnation Explosion speed, and for his feat of splitting the Moon apart, along with the meteor feat.
Kiri
Another important aspect of this is a jutsu that appears distinctly to travel at natural lightning speeds.
When Sasuke prepares his Kirin jutsu by creating a natural thundercloud through his own fireballs and Itachi's Amateraus; he states that his jutsu is unavoidable, it cannot be blocked and it only lasts for an instant.
Part of this is straightforward; since Sasuke is not depending on his own chakra but the ambient energy in the thundercloud the jutsu is far more powerful than what Sasuke is capable of himself. He states himself he is merely directing it towards Itachi.
In other words Sasuke's chakra nature has nothing to do with the power or speed of the jutsu. It is as fast as it is because he is taking advantage of the speed inherent to cloud-to-ground lightning.
Once Black Zetsu realizes what Sasuke is doing, he deduces the reason for why it is 'unavoidable'. Because it relies on natural lightning speed.
Sasuke at this time has shown off numerous Lightning Style jutsu; firing them as needles, as an extendable sword or emitting it from his entire body.
Yet he specifically believes that Kirin is a jutsu that is unavoidable, even to Itachi's speed.
The only logical conclusion is that the speed of cloud-to-ground lightning is far faster than any normal jutsu created through chakra nature.
Some people try to get around this by arguing that Kirin (composed of natural cloud-to-ground lightning) can just be faster than our average standard of cloud-to-ground lightning by using Black Zetsu's statement of lightning travelling in 1/1000 of a second; but applying two different standards for lightning jutsu in Naruto is contradictory.
If natural lightning in Naruto is always far faster than our average standard, and if people believe that all Lightning Release jutsu travels just as fast as natural lightning, then trying to calculate Lightning Release feats by assuming them to be as fast as our own standard of lightning is wrong.
Sage Art: Yin Release Lightning Dispatch
During the final fight between Madara against Naruto and Sasuke, Madara uses his new natural energy powers and combines it with Yin Release to create what appears to be myriad lightning bolts.
The Fourth Naruto Databook says this:
þäíÒüïÒéëÕ¢óÒéÆõ¢£ÒéèÕç║ÒüÖÚÖ░ÚüüÒü«Þíô Òü«õ©ÇÒüñÒÇéµëïÒü«Õ╣│ÒüïÒéëþäíµò░Òü½µ×Ø ÕêåÒüïÒéîÒüÖÒéïþ¿▓Õª╗ÒéƵö¥ÒüíÒÇüÕ╝ÁÒéè ÕÀíÒéëÒüøÒüƒÚøÀÒüºµòÁÒéƵìòþ©øÒüÖÒéïÒÇé Õà¡Úüôõ╗Öõ║║ÕîûÒüùÒüƒÒâ×ÒâÇÒâ®Òüîõ¢┐þö¿ÒÇé
Which translates to:
One of the Yin Release techniques, that create form out of nothingness. From the hands' palms, myriads of lightning bolt branches are released, capturing the enemy with the layed out lightning. Used by Madara after after transforming into the Sage of Six Paths.
Unlike the majority of actual Lightning Release jutsu, this technique actually resembles lightning bolts, is created through natural energy, and has nothing to do with transforming the user's chakra into "Lightning".
If every Lightning Release jutsu is as fast as natural lightning, why is Madara specifically creating the lightning bolts through Yin Release?
On top of that, Naruto has enough time seemingly to just move his arm and throw one of his Truth-Seeking Orbs at the lightning in order to divert it, and Madara is surprised at the possibility that Sasuke could have moved out of the way. In fact Sasuke actually teleported instinctively out of the way of the lightning, making it unlikely that he could have easily dodged it.
In case there are doubts as to why natural energy would create something that resembles natural lightning, the Juubi also created storms with lightning raining down from the sky when it unleashed a Cataclysm. The Juubi's power is based on natural energy.
TL;DR
Mitsuki's Snake Lightning
In Episode 36 of Boruto, Mitsuki uses a jutsu called Lightning Release: Snake Lightning to create a snake-shaped attack that is sent flying towards Shino who dodges it pretty easily.
This dodging has been calced at Mach 6,800 by assuming that the Snake Lightning was travelling at average cloud-to-ground lightning speeds. However in the video the Snake Lightning jutsu appears to be travelling rather slowly.
The argument for this to just be flawed cinematic time is to assume that the event occurs quickly in the first place by assuming that the Snake Lightning had to travel at average lightning speeds.
This is flawed as we don't have a canon speed for the Lightning Release: Snake Lightning jutsu, or a stated timeframe for the event depicted on-screen.
The only properties this particular jutsu has in common with actual lightning is that it conducts through water to an extent.
Aside from that the jutsu takes the shape of a giant snake and travels on-screen significantly slower than an actual lightning bolt.
For anyone curious as to what an actual lightning bolt looks like in the Naruto anime, this video shows quite clearly that cloud-to-ground lightning moves significantly faster than the Snake Lightning jutsu is depicted as.
For anyone who thinks this is purely a slowed down timeframe, there is an example of that actually happening where the fight slows down to show Sarada's perception and dodging of a thrown shurike. Or when the action goes into slow motion for Minato vs. Obito.
Visually speaking there is nothing in the animation itself suggesting the scene with Shino is just flawed cinematic time.
If anyone wants to bring up other Lightning Release jutsu, bear in mind that we don't treat all elemental jutsu as being the same speed as each other. Just because one character creates a Fire Release jutsu of a certain speed, for example, doesn't mean another character's Fire Release-based jutsu is just as fast.
I also want to note for anyone who believes we should never use anime timeframes that we currently use the anime timeframes for Toneri's Golden Wheel Reincarnation Explosion speed, and for his feat of splitting the Moon apart, along with the meteor feat.
Kiri
Another important aspect of this is a jutsu that appears distinctly to travel at natural lightning speeds.
When Sasuke prepares his Kirin jutsu by creating a natural thundercloud through his own fireballs and Itachi's Amateraus; he states that his jutsu is unavoidable, it cannot be blocked and it only lasts for an instant.
Part of this is straightforward; since Sasuke is not depending on his own chakra but the ambient energy in the thundercloud the jutsu is far more powerful than what Sasuke is capable of himself. He states himself he is merely directing it towards Itachi.
In other words Sasuke's chakra nature has nothing to do with the power or speed of the jutsu. It is as fast as it is because he is taking advantage of the speed inherent to cloud-to-ground lightning.
Once Black Zetsu realizes what Sasuke is doing, he deduces the reason for why it is 'unavoidable'. Because it relies on natural lightning speed.
Sasuke at this time has shown off numerous Lightning Style jutsu; firing them as needles, as an extendable sword or emitting it from his entire body.
Yet he specifically believes that Kirin is a jutsu that is unavoidable, even to Itachi's speed.
The only logical conclusion is that the speed of cloud-to-ground lightning is far faster than any normal jutsu created through chakra nature.
Some people try to get around this by arguing that Kirin (composed of natural cloud-to-ground lightning) can just be faster than our average standard of cloud-to-ground lightning by using Black Zetsu's statement of lightning travelling in 1/1000 of a second; but applying two different standards for lightning jutsu in Naruto is contradictory.
If natural lightning in Naruto is always far faster than our average standard, and if people believe that all Lightning Release jutsu travels just as fast as natural lightning, then trying to calculate Lightning Release feats by assuming them to be as fast as our own standard of lightning is wrong.
Sage Art: Yin Release Lightning Dispatch
During the final fight between Madara against Naruto and Sasuke, Madara uses his new natural energy powers and combines it with Yin Release to create what appears to be myriad lightning bolts.
The Fourth Naruto Databook says this:
þäíÒüïÒéëÕ¢óÒéÆõ¢£ÒéèÕç║ÒüÖÚÖ░ÚüüÒü«Þíô Òü«õ©ÇÒüñÒÇéµëïÒü«Õ╣│ÒüïÒéëþäíµò░Òü½µ×Ø ÕêåÒüïÒéîÒüÖÒéïþ¿▓Õª╗ÒéƵö¥ÒüíÒÇüÕ╝ÁÒéè ÕÀíÒéëÒüøÒüƒÚøÀÒüºµòÁÒéƵìòþ©øÒüÖÒéïÒÇé Õà¡Úüôõ╗Öõ║║ÕîûÒüùÒüƒÒâ×ÒâÇÒâ®Òüîõ¢┐þö¿ÒÇé
Which translates to:
One of the Yin Release techniques, that create form out of nothingness. From the hands' palms, myriads of lightning bolt branches are released, capturing the enemy with the layed out lightning. Used by Madara after after transforming into the Sage of Six Paths.
Unlike the majority of actual Lightning Release jutsu, this technique actually resembles lightning bolts, is created through natural energy, and has nothing to do with transforming the user's chakra into "Lightning".
If every Lightning Release jutsu is as fast as natural lightning, why is Madara specifically creating the lightning bolts through Yin Release?
On top of that, Naruto has enough time seemingly to just move his arm and throw one of his Truth-Seeking Orbs at the lightning in order to divert it, and Madara is surprised at the possibility that Sasuke could have moved out of the way. In fact Sasuke actually teleported instinctively out of the way of the lightning, making it unlikely that he could have easily dodged it.
In case there are doubts as to why natural energy would create something that resembles natural lightning, the Juubi also created storms with lightning raining down from the sky when it unleashed a Cataclysm. The Juubi's power is based on natural energy.
TL;DR
- Natural cloud-to-ground lightning is shown to be much faster than certain Lightning Release jutsu such as Mitsuki's Snake Lightning.
- There is no visual indication of the animation being deliberately slow when Shino dodges the Snake Lightning.
- Anime timeframes are currently being used to support significant calcs in the verse, but are being ignored when it comes to certain Lightning Release jutsu.
- If every Lightning Release jutsu was as fast as cloud-to-ground lightning, then Sasuke's and Black Zetsu's statements would make no sense.
- Madara distinctly creates what appears to be natural lightning bolts but without using Lightning Release.