Granny and Slendrina's verse should be moved to FC/OC.

[Vyfourthaccount]

They are just references.

Eh I guess it's fair (unrelated but is sesseur Jeff still possible to index on main wiki?)

 

[TheShape03]

Eh I guess it's fair (unrelated but is sesseur Jeff still possible to index on main wiki?)

Probably, although since I wasn't sure, I made a profile for him on CSAP.

 

[Vyfourthaccount]

Probably, although since I wasn't sure, I made a profile for him on CSAP.

Can I see the profile? Also I think it's possible to index him here. He have copyright and the copyrighted material within the timeline are basically just references like you said so. Doesn't affect Jeff's Story

 

[TheShape03]

Can I see the profile? Also I think it's possible to index him here. He have copyright and the copyrighted material within the timeline are basically just references like you said so. Doesn't affect Jeff's Story

Here it is.

Obviously, if Jeff had a vsbw profile, Cross-Scaling with Jason would not be allowed since vsbw does not allow that kind of thing.

 

[Vyfourthaccount]

Here it is.

Obviously, if Jeff had a vsbw profile, Cross-Scaling with Jason would not be allowed since vsbw does not allow that kind of thing.

I see and obviously it isn't allowed

 

[Monsters_fight]

In Slendrina X, Slendrina's mother is freed from her chains, turns into a giant head and destroys the castle while Slendrina is trapped in a book. In Granny, Slendrina's mother appears chained again (something I explained here, it is a direct contradiction), Slendrina is free, etc.

Wrong, wrong and wrong.
After the end of Slendrina X, Slendrina´s Mom is knocked out due to the castle's destruction. Granny arrives and traps her that room in her house. Its so simple.

As for Slendrina, she was trapped in that book, but in Granny she isn't free until you put her teddy bear in the cradle. You can argue, that she was supposed to be trapped in the book, but that doesn't really matter. There is a time skip between Slendrina X and Granny so Slendrina could have escaped, or that the teddy bear made her escape from the book. Now that I think of, it makes sense, the bear could have been what made Slendrina escape the book.

 

[Monsters_fight]

The Twins has shown us that references or appearances of characters from a certain series in a different series does not mean that both series share a universe. That is, appearances of characters from the Slendrina series in the Granny series are not evidence that they are part of the same universe, which forces you to prove otherwise with other types of evidence.

Your comparison makes no sense. The Twins only make 2 references of Granny, the guests mode was something made by DvLooper to make the game cooler, it has nothing to do with lore, unlike Slendrina. Granny has many, MANY references from Slendrina, so its self-evident its not something like The Twins.

Not to mention the fact that if they weren't part of the same universe, DvLooper would have already confirmed it like when he did with the twins. Man, Granny is literally Slendrina´s Grandmother, what type of proof do you want more?

Also, that comment asks if Granny/Slendrina are canon to the Twins says "Granny/Slendrina" and DvLooper doesn't negates that saying Slendrina, Granny and The Twins are not canon to each other, he only confirms The Twins are not canon to Granny/Slendrina, but he doesn't confirm Granny and Slendrina are not canon to each other, which proves even more my point.

In Granny games, you have the books from Slendrina, the paintings from slendrina, the items from slendrina, the spider mom from house of slendrina, the characters from slendrina, You have everything from Slendrina in Granny. What do you have in the Twins? You have a dumb mode where Granny and Grandpa appear which was confirmed to be not canon.

This is a false equivalence, saying Granny and Slendrina are not canon because The Twins are not canon to Slendrina/Granny is obviously wrong.

And at last, Occam´s Razor says Slendrina and Granny are canon to each other. End

 

[Monsters_fight]

Although it is not vitally important, it is also worth mentioning that Granny is licensed, while Slendrina is not.

It's not worth mentioning that because that is irrelevant at all.
First of all, we don't know if DvLooper counts Slendrina as a Granny character or not.
Second of all, even if it doesn't, why would DvLooper have the license of a Slenderman copy he made? See, how does it not make sense?

 

[Scourge_8]

Wrong, wrong and wrong.
After the end of Slendrina X, Slendrina´s Mom is knocked out due to the castle's destruction. Granny arrives and traps her that room in her house. Its so simple.

As for Slendrina, she was trapped in that book, but in Granny she isn't free until you put her teddy bear in the cradle. You can argue, that she was supposed to be trapped in the book, but that doesn't really matter. There is a time skip between Slendrina X and Granny so Slendrina could have escaped, or that the teddy bear made her escape from the book. Now that I think of, it makes sense, the bear could have been what made Slendrina escape the book.

Dyou have any proof for what you’re suggesting?

 

[Scourge_8]

First of all, we don't know if DvLooper counts Slendrina as a Granny character or not.
Second of all, even if it doesn't, why would DvLooper have the license of a Slenderman copy he made? See, how does it not make sense?

the website only mentions licenses for granny 1 and 2

 

[Vyfourthaccount]

the website only mentions licenses for granny 1 and 2

This looks outdated due to granny 3 existing also Slendrina is also seen in granny 1

 

[Monsters_fight]

Dyou have any proof for what you’re suggesting?

I don't need to.
Its obvious Granny went to the ruins of the castle to take the body of her daughter. Her daughter didn't randomly spawn in her house.
As for the Slendrina, Its a theory, but its a hypothesis and you cant argue her coming back in Granny´s games is a contradiction to Slendrina X.

 

[Monsters_fight]

I don't need to.
Its obvious Granny went to the ruins of the castle to take the body of her daughter. Her daughter didn't randomly spawn in her house.
As for the Slendrina, Its a theory, but its a hypothesis and you cant argue her coming back in Granny´s games is a contradiction to Slendrina X.

Plus, he argued that Slendrina couldn't come back and I made a hypothesis on why she came back.
I don't need to proof this was the reason she came back, he needs to proof why she couldn't have come back.
How does he know Slendrina didn't get release after the events of Slendrina X? We don't know how long Granny takes after Slendrina X

 

[TheShape03]

The guy with bad temper has a good point, I'm not going to lie. Even if everything he said in this comment is headcanon, it's true that the rest of the things he said offer a logical argument that DVloper's statement would only decanonize the "with guests" game mode and make The Twins a separate universe from Granny's.

So, we have to decide what to do with Slendrina. Obviously DVloper avoided putting Slenderman in Granny's games because he didn't have permission to use him (something he confirmed himself) and to be able to make money off of the Granny series, which he can't do with the Slendrina series (At least not with the games where Slenderman appears).

So, the Granny series is a licensed thing, the Slendrina series is a fanfic of a licensed character. Both things are supposed to be connected/canon to each other. What do we do in these cases?

 

[Monsters_fight]

The guy with bad temper has a good point

Yes, I have a bad temper.

So, we have to decide what to do with Slendrina. Obviously DVloper avoided putting Slenderman in Granny's games because he didn't have permission to use him (something he confirmed himself) and to be able to make money off of the Granny series, which he can't do with the Slendrina series (At least not with the games where Slenderman appears).

So, the Granny series is a licensed thing, the Slendrina series is a fanfic of a licensed character. Both things are supposed to be connected/canon to each other. What do we do in these cases?

To be fair, we should put both of them in FC/OC. If Slendrina elements have an impact in Granny then that means Granny gets influenced by stuff from a fanfic of a licensed character. So Granny is bound by Slendrina which is bound by Slenderman.

 

[Vyfourthaccount]

The guy with bad temper has a good point, I'm not going to lie. Even if everything he said in this comment is headcanon, it's true that the rest of the things he said offer a logical argument that DVloper's statement would only decanonize the "with guests" game mode and make The Twins a separate universe from Granny's.

So, we have to decide what to do with Slendrina. Obviously DVloper avoided putting Slenderman in Granny's games because he didn't have permission to use him (something he confirmed himself) and to be able to make money off of the Granny series, which he can't do with the Slendrina series (At least not with the games where Slenderman appears).

So, the Granny series is a licensed thing, the Slendrina series is a fanfic of a licensed character. Both things are supposed to be connected/canon to each other. What do we do in these cases?

Option one: keep it in vsbw since Slenderman doesn't seem to affect much of the lore other than just being the father figure of Slendrina. And isn't out right named "Slenderman" unless you count that old ass mobile game as canon which I highly doubt it is. Since it doesn't connect to none of the games

Option two: throw it in FC/OC Wiki regardless if it have a licence or not

 

[Scourge_8]

Yeah the topic is rlly complicated we should have mods around