- 43,111
- 37,253
The reputation gets bashed even more when we have a **** game on the site
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
@Antvasima ripped right from the OPGiven that the last thread was staff only, so too shall this one: STAFF ONLY. You may comment as a regular user assuming you are given permission to do so by a staff member (you may ask a staff member via their walls if needed). Given the discussion that led up to this thread's creation, I am hereby giving permission to Agnaa, DaReaperMan, and ApiesDeathByLazors, if they so choose. I'll ignore the other verse that was mentioned as this thread is solely regarding the deletion of MGQ, with the possibility to discuss deletion of similar verses (HuniePop, for example) in the future after the main discussion topic has reached its end.
You don't need to speak at all. I gave you permission because you spoke on the Profile Deletion thread and thus were, to some extent, relevant to the conversation. That said, I did address the glaring differences between violence and pornography above, as have others, even on the OG thread.I have been given permission to speak, yet I have nothing to say. I guess I could try to coble together something profound outta the nonsense in my head though.
While I don't have any stake in this, and therefore don't really care what happens, emotionally I'm against removing a verse for sexual content even if it is just ****. I kinda see it as a weird double standard that extreme violence and death is a-ok, but T&A calls out the banhammer. On the rational hand tho, I understand that it breaks some rules set down by the almighty Fandom and am all in favor of yeeting it to keep heat offa the wiki.
Anyway, all I really care about is what's best for the wiki. I have put more effort into this place then I have my last job and that's probably really sad.
Yes, because having what is considered a **** game with suggestive looking characters on the wiki makes it look good, moral gymnastics, you are right on that, does not need to happen. But the wiki already doesn't have the best reputation, we don't need a **** game to bog that down even more.The moral grandstanding is getting on my nerves.
1. Are there any descriptions or depictions of rape (or sex for that matter) in the articles and/or verse page?
2. Are there any highly NSFW images in the articles?
If the answer is “no” to either of these questions, leave the verse alone. I’m tired of having this discussion.
This is not a fandom/wikia like the Naruto, DC, Game of Thrones, etc. wikis, where nearly everything about the verse is catalogued. So all it’s content is out there.
We powerscale. That’s it. So long as we can do that without excessive levels of NSFW material being in our articles, we shouldn’t be having this discussion for the tenth time.
Consensus literally everywhere else is MGQ=**** game, not exactly good to have on the wikiNo it doesn’t. MGQ is an ecchi series, not a **** game.
Consensus literally everywhere else is MGQ=**** game, not exactly good to have on the wiki
I’m not mincing and mashing any terminology here. It’s not objectively incorrect. Please, stop saying that. It’s a “**** game” the same way Fate Stay Night, Dies irae, Senshinkan, Silvero Vendetta or Trinity, or Demonbane are “**** games”.It is objectively incorrect. Read the OP. It's a **** game. I don't care what terminology you care to mince and mash and apply to it. It's a **** game, Sera.
Clearly we do. And it isn't irrelevant in defining pornography, Sera. Unless you're missing out on what pornography actually is, in which case a simple Google search can help you, then this isn't a discussion. It doesn't matter if they classify it as eroge in Japan. Eroge can be pornographic, too. And that's what MGQ is. Pornography. Something we have rules against.Who cares what people do with/in the media? It might be used for sexual gratification but that’s in the same way one can ********** to the h-scenes of any other eroge, yes that includes rape scenes (if said eroge has them) for sexual gratification. That’s completely irrelevant here. I don’t know why you have this notion that I’m bringing up other verses as if it has no merit. It absolutely does.
Similarly, To Love Ru, which is an ecchi manga with plenty NSFW material, can also be considered a source for spank material, but that doesn’t make it inherently a **** manga.
Eh I don’t think the argument was ever about if people actively do it to a game, just in regards to how it’s classified by in largeWho cares what people do with/in the media? It might be used for sexual gratification but that’s in the same way one can ********** to the h-scenes of any other eroge, yes that includes rape scenes (if said eroge has them) for sexual gratification. That’s completely irrelevant here. I don’t know why you have this notion that I’m bringing up other verses as if it has no merit. It absolutely does.
Similarly, To Love Ru, which is an ecchi manga with plenty NSFW material, can also be considered a source for spank material, but that doesn’t make it inherently a **** manga.
The fact that they have "attacks" that are blatantly just outright sexual acts rather than physical violence is pretty telling, if you ask me. I know this is a succubus, but the succubus character isn't the only one to have attacks like this. Pretty much all characters I looked at had at least a handful of attacks like this. This isn't just "lose = rape", it's happening the entire time you fight any monster girl. Like a good portion of their attacks are literally raping the main character.
It really isn't my intent to insult your intelligence any more than it is your intent to insult my thread. If you really can't tell the difference, look into it. The game is pornographic. It being classified as eroge does not cancel its status as pornography.Stop insulting my intelligence. I know damn well what pornography is, and I’m not even using the argument “Japan says it’s an eroge!” That’s just what it is. An “erotic game”. But fine, we can scratch that entirely.
Hell, if you really want my take? No eroge that doesn’t have a non-h rerelease should be on the site, given these supposed standards (that alone actually saves Fate, Masada, and Silverio, for example).
Take it as you will, but given the that I don’t appreciate the attitudes here, don’t call me to these threads again. I can’t afford to risk my already deteriorating mental state on this shit.
I don't know much about the verse you're mentioning, but I will say there is a difference between artistic use of trauma and pornographic use of rape. I'm not sure I'm such a fan of the former, generally, but any mature individual should be capable of telling the difference. Again, unfamiliar with your example, but my suggestion isn't to ban every verse that tackles the issue of rape or includes rape somewhere in its plot.I have no clue what MGQ is like, my only stake in this conversation would be whether it gets stuff like DSP verse deleted
Technically you also get raped when you lose in Mogeko Castle and there's a lot of rape across the extended universe. But I'm pretty sure DSP's games aren't considered **** so I wouldn't want them to be deleted
All of the sex in Paradox is optional and its a JRPG.It is objectively incorrect. Read the OP. It's a **** game. I don't care what terminology you care to mince and mash and apply to it. It's a **** game, Sera.
1. Don't care, was never my point that it was optional. The existence and overall intent of getting to it is the core issue, as is the abilities listed above, of course.All of the sex in Paradox is optional and its a JRPG.
That doesn't apply to Paradox, the focus is telling the story, that the story involves sex is irrelevant.1. Don't care, was never my point that it was optional. The existence and overall intent of getting to it is the core issue, as is the abilities listed above, of course.
As if having hentai makes it bad.2. I don't care what form your favorite hentai takes. It is, at the end of the day, hentai.