Kinda both, but this also happens to get addressed on the Q&A as well:
That has nothing to do with what you said and I responded with. I was talking about durability.
I think you're confusing Kratos with Thor here. It's Thor and Jormungandr who clashed hard enough to cause the tree to splinter, which is what caused Jormi to be hurled back through time in the first place. IDK where you got the idea that it was Kratos who did the feat.
I'm sorry what
I checking the video for this.
Don’t think that apply to all verses so not always the case. Still reasonable to a extent since 3D and 4D are connected by the theory of relativity, it can been limited 4D too so not completely.
There's also a slew of Marvel and DC characters who are 3-D but have 4-D timeline-busting power. Again, not an uncommon thing, plenty of fictional characters who are 3-D but have timeline-busting power exist.
I not arguing against the feat in question so
Sorry about the abrupt cut in the comment, I was editing.
AFAIK in the game she only states that the tree's physical form that we see Atreus and Kratos use is just a mere artistic interpretation, so not sure if it would help, but scans and chapter number?
That is in regard to traveling from one location in a different realm to another location tbf so I believed it isn’t that significant I am afraid
i know, at a glance most people would think the context is only the root of yggdrasil omnipresent across time and space. But i think there is more to it.
Eh, that doesn't mean much, just a repeat of the same dialogue in the game.
i know, at a glance most people would think the context is only the root of yggdrasil omnipresent across time and space. But i think there is more to it.
Not really, no, that's not why the Yggdrasil is Low 1-C anyway.
what does it mean by this ? Do we need statement that yggdrasil is higher-dimensional object in lore stuff ?
Nah, those were just for support.
I think that's what he's asking for, yes.
well i always thought if 2-A stuff is infinitesimal part of yggdrasil (plus transcending time space statement) = yggdrasil is higher dimensional object by default = thus low 1-C tier
That's the thing, but Ultima has issues with the scan thinking they don't count as surpassing a 2-A structure and considering them infinitesimal.
That tweet is not valid evidence by any means, from what I can gather, starting from the fact that Bruno's answer itself is a big non-sequitur that makes it fairly clear he just didn't understand the question and assumed that it was about whether or not timelines exist to begin with. And then there's the problem of that whole conversation being someone baiting a writer with VS Debating-related questions. I thought we disallowed that sort of thing?
And there's nothing preventing them from being limited to a single timeline. "Yggdrasil contains the cycle of the Nine Realms and so it may contain the other timelines" doesn't follow at all.
Mimir is literally the smartest man in all the realms and his entire role in the narrative boils down to giving exposition to Kratos and Atreus when needed, so in lieu of valid evidence towards the contrary, his word can be taken for granted I'd say.
Hm. Freya does say everything eventually returns to Yggdrasil at the end of a cycle, so I suppose treating it like that is fine, yeah.
That wouldn't count as "splintering," or even as "damage" at all, in fact, since it'd involve affecting a part of a structure that's so minute it literally takes up no space relative to its bulk.
We do. Let me check on the rules for this one
I mean, that's exactly what the question is about?
We didn't ask the man the questions tho, nor is it from our wiki. Also these questions are only asking for clarification, even if at a glance they might look like they were made for answering VS Debating-related questions. Unless you want to discard all WoG for all verses, that is?
But Freya didn't say it with the context of it being contained within the 9 Realms only.
He also says Kratos can't defy fate, which we both know, is very blatantly wrong given everything that happens in GOW2.
She does indeed.
We do indeed, but the question literally just asks if the Well of Fate literally contains an infinite number of timelines or not so I'm pretty sure it's not meant to fall under that.
I know the rule, but his is remotely nowhere near the Kamiya Situation as we've seen. It's why it exists to begin with, because you never know when an author might go Kamiya on your ass.
Here is the issue. The WOG can been discarded if it is severely contradicted by what was stated in verses and even shown. I believe our statements page even made that clear as well.
And the contradiction is?
The contradiction is that whatever or not Yggdrasil truly contains infinite timelines or not.
The whole question thing immediately falls apart once you read out the true plot of the card game: STOP BALDUR FROM DYING OR BRAND NEW TIMELINES KEEP POPPING UP.
That's the issue being braught up, not a contradiction.
Just because its a card game doesn't make it any less valid, neither is WoG at fault here.
“In God of War: The Card Game, players take on the role of the Norns, powerful beings desperately seeking a way to stop Ragnarök. Looking into the well of Fate, Urðr, they can play out many different realities, seeing what possible course of action might save existence. In each of these scenarios, they’ll be facing off against different monsters and building up their own abilities, gaining more power as they progress. Let’s take a deeper look into the mechanics of the game and see just how these different elements come together to create a new take on a beloved franchise.”
Not sure how that contradicts the "endless" statement given that one can have both "infinite" and "many" in the same sentence when describing size but okay.
