Can someone tell me why Saitama black hole feat or gravity manipulation feat is invalid

[Huesito88]

In episode 11 (I know it's non canon but I still want to know) one of Boros henchmen said to Saitama do you even know what a black hole is or is it because we see light still going the same speed even when light can't escape a black hole. so tell me why is it invalid, debunked or something

 

[Antoniofer]

I think that it wasn't accepted due that is a non-canon feats and/or that attack isn't relatively close to a real black hole, not sure at all

 

[Huesito88]

It could still count as durability or something

 

[WarriorWare]

The guy just randomly said "black hole" for the hell of it. Nothing in that scene even faintly resembles a black hole.

 

[Huesito88]

Yeah that is why he said "I can manipulate gravity with my powers then, you ape do you even know what a black hole is gravity its Gravity is so strong not even light can break free from it, take this".

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

This question again huh 1: the guy talked about blackholes but he never specifically said he was exerting the force of a blackhole. 2: It couldnt be a blackhole because the surrounding area including light was still intact a real black hole would have ripped the ship apart. 3: Surviving blackholes arent quantifiable.

 

[MarvelFanatic119]

1. He only talked about a black hole, he wasn't actually exerting the force of one.

2. If it was a black hole, the Earth would have been consumed in a matter of seconds, considering the ship they were on was fine, it wasn't a black hole.

3. He was only exerting force downward on Saitama, it wasn't sucking in anything just crushing the room through gravitational force.

4. Black hole feats are hard to scale considering most of them in fiction don't behave like real ones.

 

[Huesito88]

So wait if it did have the gravity of a black hole shouldn't the ship just crash down

 

[MarvelFanatic119]

No, the ship, along with the Earth, would have been consumed by it in a matter of seconds.

 

[TISSG7Redgrave]

well just regular gravity enchancement i guess but not too drastic i think only for that room having true gravity of a black hole can suck a star

 

[Antvasima]

Please read the Black Hole feats in fictio page. Thank you.

 

[WarriorWare]

Yeah that is why the I can manipulate gravity with my powers then the guy said you ape do you even know what a black hole its gravity is so strong not even light can break free from it take this.

English, please.

 

[Royhellio]

I would make the "black hole feat" still valid and here's why:

1Q: But the physics didn't even resemble a black hole! 1A: He didn't say he made a black hole, he only implied that he was manipulating gravity (downward acceleration/force) that it was like one.

2Q: He didn't specifically state he was making black hole levels of gravity's! 2A: You're either a butthurt fan that doesn't want Saitama to be stronger than your own characters, or you've never studied English 4 in high school and understood how implication works or when it's being used. It could be both. Reread the script, it's implied that the Alien was attempting to use black hole gravity on Saitama.

3Q: Hes a telekinetic, he cant even manipulate gravity like that 3A: You're right! He can't! But he never was in the first place. He was exerting downward force on Saitama to mimick the gravity you'd feel in a black hole. Consequently, light was able to move around because he wasn't exerting the force on every single damn proton in the room.

I also think the Alien was high balling himself, so I'm gonna low ball him and say he only did half of a gravity's black hole. That's still pretty damn high, and quite impressive if Saitama didn't realize what was going on.

 

[DMB_1]

You just Necro'd a 2 years old thread.