- 903
- 142
Gremmy's power is creating anything he wants through reality warping. If that's so why not calculate him creating the meteor instead of calculating the effects of the meteor?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Bleach Top Tiers Downgrade
- Thread starter TataHakai
- Start date
- Status
- 11,616
- 3,135
People just ignored the scan I brought up where Gremmy is so confident that he says will survive the meteor impact and the rest will die. Gremmy scales anyway since the novel puts him as the second strongest below base Yhwach who was the only who could defeat him. Which Yhwach did to seal him away.
- 31,607
- 28,097
> Gremmy scales anyway since the novel puts him as the second strongest below base Yhwach who was the only who could defeat him.
Doesn't Yhwach scale to Gremmy in the first place?
Doesn't Yhwach scale to Gremmy in the first place?
- 903
- 142
All the Sternritter powers come from Yhwach.
Except for Gerard and Pernida I think.
Except for Gerard and Pernida I think.
- 903
- 142
Also " we simply saw it a few hundred kilometers up at most when it first appeared, Gremmy had no reason to have it come from space as that would've taken longer. "
A few hundred kilometers is low-earth orbit where the satellites fly, which pretty much is space isn't it?
A few hundred kilometers is low-earth orbit where the satellites fly, which pretty much is space isn't it?
- 31,607
- 28,097
I mean Yhwach scales to Gremmy, so saying that Gremmy scales to Yhwach by being the 2nd strongest doesn't make sense.
Also, I don't see much of Yhwach doing anything there. He's just looking at it. (I find it funny that Jugram thinks that ordinary foot soldiers could protect his majesty).
Also, I don't see much of Yhwach doing anything there. He's just looking at it. (I find it funny that Jugram thinks that ordinary foot soldiers could protect his majesty).
- 10,078
- 9,397
Peter "Quicksilver" Maximoff said:
- 813
- 137
Tata said he's not open to making any actual changes right now, just a general concesus decision on this to be applied later.Peter "Quicksilver" Maximoff said:
- 11,616
- 3,135
@MetalGearRaide
Here it is.
"Gremmy Thomeaux. That was the name of the boy who was known as the strongest member of the Sternritter army. It was said that no one could win against him, with the exception of Yhwach. The body he used was that of a young boy, but the real 'container' had neither age nor gender. That was because he was, in reality, just a brain within a jar. The body of the boy was just something that was 'imagined'. Such was the ability of the one who was given the Schrift 'V', the Visionary. This ability was God-like, to transform mere imagination into reality. Even objects like meteorites could be imagined into existence. In the end, Gremmy had lost to Kenpachi as he had imagined a body for himself that was unable to contain strength matching Kenpachi's; rather, such enormous strength could be contained by no one other than Kenpachi himself. As a result, his body collapsed and he had wished to no longer imagine anything anymore. And thus, the brain stopped functioning. Liltotto had confirmed with her own eyes that the brain's reiatsu had completely stopped. She did not know what happened to the vessel afterwards and she did not dare go look for it. But for the Shinigami in front of her, the story seemed to be different from that which she felt from Gremmy. This Shinigami seemed like the sort of figure that the living Gremmy could have 'imagined'. In fact, Liltotto was contemplating whether or not to ask Hikone about something like this. But, she ended up asking anyway. Upon hearing that name, Hikone's child-like face lit up."-Source.
Conclusion:
Here it is.
"Gremmy Thomeaux. That was the name of the boy who was known as the strongest member of the Sternritter army. It was said that no one could win against him, with the exception of Yhwach. The body he used was that of a young boy, but the real 'container' had neither age nor gender. That was because he was, in reality, just a brain within a jar. The body of the boy was just something that was 'imagined'. Such was the ability of the one who was given the Schrift 'V', the Visionary. This ability was God-like, to transform mere imagination into reality. Even objects like meteorites could be imagined into existence. In the end, Gremmy had lost to Kenpachi as he had imagined a body for himself that was unable to contain strength matching Kenpachi's; rather, such enormous strength could be contained by no one other than Kenpachi himself. As a result, his body collapsed and he had wished to no longer imagine anything anymore. And thus, the brain stopped functioning. Liltotto had confirmed with her own eyes that the brain's reiatsu had completely stopped. She did not know what happened to the vessel afterwards and she did not dare go look for it. But for the Shinigami in front of her, the story seemed to be different from that which she felt from Gremmy. This Shinigami seemed like the sort of figure that the living Gremmy could have 'imagined'. In fact, Liltotto was contemplating whether or not to ask Hikone about something like this. But, she ended up asking anyway. Upon hearing that name, Hikone's child-like face lit up."-Source.
Conclusion:
- Meteor was imagined by Gremmy, not pulled from a portal.
- Gremmy was positive he could tank it while everyone else would die.
- Base Yhwach is the only one that can defeat Gremmy.
- Gremmy lost to Kenpachi because of some fan theory becoming reality.
- 2,684
- 317
Inb4 all of this is useless thanks to Madara
- 14,575
- 5,877
Gremmy's Visionary is so strong that the fan imagination became reality.
My only two cents here.
My only two cents here.
- 2,684
- 317
Wrong thread. This is about Bleach, not Naruto.
You didn't get the joke
You didn't get the joke
- 31,607
- 28,097
> In the end, Gremmy had lost to Kenpachi as he had imagined a body for himself that was unable to contain strength matching Kenpachi's; rather, such enormous strength could be contained by no one other than Kenpachi himself.
So, Kenpachi > Yhwach?
So, Kenpachi > Yhwach?
- 2,519
- 1,364
- Thread starter
- #99
And thank you, this pretty much proves my point.AppleLord said:
As for Kenpachi, he completely destroyed the meteor without it pushing back against him
Which means his Shikai form still scales to the KE of it, though i don't know how Gremmy would scale to that, that's for the Bleach experts to decide i suppose.
- 7,069
- 1,457
FTFYCalaca Vs said:
- 8,171
- 2,205
Not really, it's pretty ambiguous because of his power. He has knowledge of meteorites meaning it's perfectly reasonable he imagined a meteorite similar to one coming from space not just a falling rock because his imaginations are specific.
Your argument is "we didn't see it come from literal space" but we knows how The Visionary works.
Your argument is "we didn't see it come from literal space" but we knows how The Visionary works.
- 2,684
- 317
M/S as in Meters per second or miles per second ?
- 31,607
- 28,097
@AppleLord, why 7,900?
Tata quoted this in the opening post: the values range from 2000-4000 m/s.
Tata quoted this in the opening post: the values range from 2000-4000 m/s.
- 2,684
- 317
Please which one of the two it is ? Meters or Miles ?
- 5,462
- 1,862
Meters
- 2,519
- 1,364
- Thread starter
- #111
But why would he? It logically makes no sense for him to imagine it coming from space when all that would do is make it take longer for it to dropSigurd Snake in The Eye said:
What we see is the meteor at most a few hundred kilometers up, this is the first time we see it, and anything else is an unfound assumption.
- 8,171
- 2,205
Because he's a reality warper that can turn his imagination into reality, it doesn't have to take long because again it's his imagination which is whatever he wants it to be.
It's completely logical over your interpretation which is pretty much just an argument from tradition, you don't need to see everything to believe it.
What we know is it's a meteor, and meteors come from space. If you were imagining a meteor into existence why would you think that it would come down slower then one from space? I'm not saying your interpretation is baseless but I think this one is much more likely simply due to his power.
It's completely logical over your interpretation which is pretty much just an argument from tradition, you don't need to see everything to believe it.
What we know is it's a meteor, and meteors come from space. If you were imagining a meteor into existence why would you think that it would come down slower then one from space? I'm not saying your interpretation is baseless but I think this one is much more likely simply due to his power.
- 10,545
- 12,389
Yeah, after everything that was said, I agree with the op.
- 2,519
- 1,364
- Thread starter
- #117
Actually no, it's called occam's razor, my interpretation is more accurate because it assumes less than yours, mine is also backed by the fact that there's no visual evidence whilst yours NEEDS visual evidence to support itSigurd Snake in The Eye said:
With that logic we shouldn't even have meteor rules, everything that's called a meteor or not even shown to come from space should just be 11.2 km/s because well, meteors HAVE to come from space right? not like we're dealing with a character who can imagine things into existence in any location whatsoever
- 8,171
- 2,205
Except not everyone who has meteorite based attack's reality warps them into existence. You're literally ignoring how his power works to further your argument.
Occam's razor is on my side in this context because I'm using his actual power. Meteors only come from space so I don't understand your last part about location.
Which is more likely
1. Gremmy imagines a meteor above Seireitei, and seeing that he knows about space and what not he'd know they come from space which is a basic thing for someone to know regardless of their background. So he'd imagined a meteor that is from space perfectly simulated.
2. Gremmy summoned a Meteor but since we didn't see it come from space, he imagined just a flaming big rock in the sky because why not. Even though he specifically calls it a meteorite which a rock from space.
Occam's razor is on my side in this context because I'm using his actual power. Meteors only come from space so I don't understand your last part about location.
Which is more likely
1. Gremmy imagines a meteor above Seireitei, and seeing that he knows about space and what not he'd know they come from space which is a basic thing for someone to know regardless of their background. So he'd imagined a meteor that is from space perfectly simulated.
2. Gremmy summoned a Meteor but since we didn't see it come from space, he imagined just a flaming big rock in the sky because why not. Even though he specifically calls it a meteorite which a rock from space.
- 7,677
- 1,373
You're jumping from he "he knows space is a thing" to "his mind can create perfect meteor entry simulations, including the affects of Earth's gravity on an approaching meteor that cause them to reach typical entry speeds". That is a big assumption.
- 2,519
- 1,364
- Thread starter
- #120
Except that simply makes it LESS obvious that gremmy brought it downSigurd Snake in The Eye said:
Since we know it's possible for him to imagine meteors inside the atmosphere whereas it isn't for most others, so Gremmy being able to do that is just more towards the assumption that he did imagine it inside the atmosphere.
Meteors do only come from space, but Gremmy can imagine ANYTHING into existence at any point, this is the equivalent of saying Gremmy didn't imagine a pocket of space around Kenpachi he moved it towards him because Outer space only exists in outer space. We know Gremmy is able to imagine things into existence outside of their usual locations so this point makes no sense.
Again, Occam's razor is that the answer with the least assumptions is most likely the correct one.
You assume more than i do, which makes my point correct.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
