- 11,364
- 13,486
Therefir just made a Manga Goku page.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Are Tier 2 Smash Characters consistent?
- Thread starter The_real_cal_howard
- Start date
- Status
- 40,473
- 12,954
- Thread starter
- #322
Not even you are allowed to make edits without people agreeing, Azathoth.Azathoth the Abyssal Idiot said:
- 33,408
- 8,430
But people are agreeing. Hell, people are making these files when we have said not to and when this discussion had yet to finish.
- 7,870
- 2,806
I.... don't even know what to say, you were all blatantly told NOT to make these pages, yet they were made anyway just because "Why not?"
Hell, at least I tried asking if FEH pages were okay, and even then I still haven't actually gone through with making anyone who isn't exclusive to it
Hell, at least I tried asking if FEH pages were okay, and even then I still haven't actually gone through with making anyone who isn't exclusive to it
Mr. Bambu
Suffer-Not-Injustice Bambu
VS Battles
Joke Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
- 22,947
- 22,683
I do not advise any of this becoming a reality. I'm against a lot of things that are even somewhat related to this (for example, Arbiter having a page for his time in Killer Instinct).
It isn't consistent with in-verse activity. Adding it is asking for trouble. Methinks people know that.
It isn't consistent with in-verse activity. Adding it is asking for trouble. Methinks people know that.
- 15,614
- 7,054
Major edits were performed to multiple pages based on a faulty premise and very limited discussion, which is not okay for such a massive upgrade. If flaws are pointed out after the upgrade is performed with multiple dissenting voices, "lol too late people already agreed on it" has never been our policy. We revert the changes until things are properly sorted out.The real cal howard said:
- 40,473
- 12,954
- Thread starter
- #327
For the record, I didn't condone them to make the profiles. In fact, I said no multiple times.Dragonmasterxyz said:
- 7,870
- 2,806
The only people who approved the creation of profiles were the people who actually went ahead and made them
- 2,938
- 365
^This. Just a justification on the verse page is fine, if we adamantly refuse to add pages. We shouldn't be making pages without permission of staff, so go ahead and delete pages that weren't made with permission.TheHadouCyberspaceWitch said:
However, why can't we have non-canon profiles-- I mean, if you wanna "save space" we can just try to make composite (non-canon) profiles-- can someone actually give me an explaination behind "too much space being taken up" and "Unnecessary", because those aren't convincing arguments against non-canon profiles in general, even if they are samey. If we are against different stats being the opperative difference, fine, let's A, get rid of Dante (smt) because that's being consistent, and B make verse pages or general pages for scaling in these crossover games. Itd be exaclty as it was above.
- 2,938
- 365
Weirdo,
They shouldn't have made the pages without changing your minds. However, the reasons given for their existence not being allowed doesn't make any sense.
"Takes up space"-- So, this wiki has a finite amount of data that can be kept on it? That's weird if it is true, and irrelevant if it isn't. The reason it's irrelevant is because the wiki would operate the same if it had twice as many pages. A better argument would be, "it creates so much more pages to manage" but that argument can be used against creating any profile and adding any verse, which i don't think people do on a consistent basis, or at all.
"Redundancy"-- This is irrelevant. Published fictional works of any kind (barring extreme exceptions like Suggsverse) should be allowed on here. Otherwise, you're failing at being an Indexing site. Having different versions of the same character, while repettitive, isn't pointless. No one would know that Smash characters would be 2-c if this verse page didn't exist, to give an example. And, even if you don't want to make the pages for whatever reason, we can just make pages for the videogames explaining everyone's videogame stats or something...
"Has bad implications"-- What exactly is the problem with having Xenoverse Goku or Anime Goku or Manga Goku? Sure, there's more Goku profiles. How is that a problem inherently-- just sounds like complaining. And, hell, we can "save space" by merging profiles into different keys like the Bahamut page. We can just make it so that "crossover game Naruto" has seperate keys for his highest level of different games he is in.
Are there any real arguments?
They shouldn't have made the pages without changing your minds. However, the reasons given for their existence not being allowed doesn't make any sense.
"Takes up space"-- So, this wiki has a finite amount of data that can be kept on it? That's weird if it is true, and irrelevant if it isn't. The reason it's irrelevant is because the wiki would operate the same if it had twice as many pages. A better argument would be, "it creates so much more pages to manage" but that argument can be used against creating any profile and adding any verse, which i don't think people do on a consistent basis, or at all.
"Redundancy"-- This is irrelevant. Published fictional works of any kind (barring extreme exceptions like Suggsverse) should be allowed on here. Otherwise, you're failing at being an Indexing site. Having different versions of the same character, while repettitive, isn't pointless. No one would know that Smash characters would be 2-c if this verse page didn't exist, to give an example. And, even if you don't want to make the pages for whatever reason, we can just make pages for the videogames explaining everyone's videogame stats or something...
"Has bad implications"-- What exactly is the problem with having Xenoverse Goku or Anime Goku or Manga Goku? Sure, there's more Goku profiles. How is that a problem inherently-- just sounds like complaining. And, hell, we can "save space" by merging profiles into different keys like the Bahamut page. We can just make it so that "crossover game Naruto" has seperate keys for his highest level of different games he is in.
Are there any real arguments?
- 40,473
- 12,954
- Thread starter
- #331
@Dark. Azzy said to remove the Low 2-C statistics. Not the Smash stats altogether.
- 7,870
- 2,806
Personally, I'm indifferent when it comes to making Smash profiles, but the characters who currently have keys should have them moved to profiles, I think
- 317
- 35
i don't understand smash one bit...
first you see almost all characters (except for toon link, sonic and jigglypuff) having no chance against tabuu, then sonic (brawl counterpart) comes out of nowhere and destroys both of tabuu's wings in order to prevent him from turning everyone into trophies again and looking like he is just toying around with tabuu, and because of gameplay purposes you're allowed to play as almost any other character besides sonic to beat tabuu.
soooo consistent...
first you see almost all characters (except for toon link, sonic and jigglypuff) having no chance against tabuu, then sonic (brawl counterpart) comes out of nowhere and destroys both of tabuu's wings in order to prevent him from turning everyone into trophies again and looking like he is just toying around with tabuu, and because of gameplay purposes you're allowed to play as almost any other character besides sonic to beat tabuu.
soooo consistent...
- 7,870
- 2,806
Tabuu used an attack meant to oneshot, according to earlier in the thread
- 2,938
- 365
And yet, they fight constantly against 2-C Master Hand and Master's Core and shit, as well as the CT being relevant in the games, so they might be 2-C because of the sheer abundance of possible conflict and the lack of any other feats to have "outliers" be a legitimate argument.
- 9,738
- 1,523
64, Melee and 4 don't have a story, so it's speculation of what canonically happened in them. At best i can only allow Duck Hunt and Wii Fit since they have solid differencies. Toy R.O.B and Canon Game and Watch profiles can be restored from history informations as an another page.
- 317
- 35
but he still got hurt by freaking sonic who seemingly has been presented as the only one who can defeat tabuu.
unless there is an explanation then idk.
unless there is an explanation then idk.
- 26,336
- 3,128
smash mr. Game & watch has differences to Canon G&W, The smash one has regen, power mimicry, attack reflection and OHK. and only smash ROB is an actual character, the real one it's just a toyDark649 said:
- 2,938
- 365
You could then just say everyone in the crossover scales to Rob in this, but they can't be used in versus battles because they don't have profiles. So, I think they should have profiles if Kirby had one, and Kirby had his own feats initially, and the same goes for everyone else svcaking to Sonic and Kirby.
- 539
- 10
I still think they are 100% optional and should be restored
- 31,648
- 34,703
What's so different about Shulk's appearance? The only notable differences I know is him using Monado I; which isn't too much different, and stealing Reyn's lines. Most of his powers and abilities feel pretty much the same; albeit nerfed in Smash.
- 539
- 10
Cant we just stop this drama and have the pages restored already?
there is literally no reason they shouldnt exist.
there is literally no reason they shouldnt exist.
- 2,938
- 365
What's so different about Dante (SMT)? Tiering and that he LACKS abilities from his canon counterpart. That's it. Same with Smash Kirby. Like I said, we could just do the Sonic Smash Bros version and make a note on the Smash page about who they scale to, if "differences" are important. Though, I don't think it really matters as long as they've got significantly different tiering or something.
Shulk isn't universal anymore so, there's that.
Shulk isn't universal anymore so, there's that.
- 539
- 10
Then lets delete the Kirby, Captain Falcon and WFT pages, then.
I mean, lets not be hypocritical.
I still agree with Amexim, this is just to stop some character you dont like from getting to tier 2, admit it.
I mean, lets not be hypocritical.
I still agree with Amexim, this is just to stop some character you dont like from getting to tier 2, admit it.
- 16,963
- 4,865
This needs to honestly be closed, NOW.
Things are a mess here and nothing is getting settled.
Things are a mess here and nothing is getting settled.
- 31,648
- 34,703
@Amexim, how do you mean Shulk isn't universal? Canon Shulk still is Tier 2 as it was already discussed, but that's off topic.
@Marco, do not be rude towards the staff. They do know what they're talking about and have explained what their motives are. There is no reason to accuse people of disliking characters just because they don't agree with giving non canon characters special keys.
And I agree with Professor, we should close this before things get out of hand.
@Marco, do not be rude towards the staff. They do know what they're talking about and have explained what their motives are. There is no reason to accuse people of disliking characters just because they don't agree with giving non canon characters special keys.
And I agree with Professor, we should close this before things get out of hand.
- 11,364
- 13,486
This thread needs to be shut down.
- 33,408
- 8,430
This stuff has been argued ad nauseam. The simple fact is that these file are not allowed. Closing this.
- Status
