azontr
He/Him- 39,509
- 49,607
The effects aren't the same, actually.
One erases you from existence.
One damages your internals.
So uh... very different effects yeah.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Goku vs. Garou (Martial Arts Battle)
- Thread starter Kin201
- Start date
- Status
One erases you from existence.
One damages your internals.
So uh... very different effects yeah.
- 40,701
- 35,254
Why is erasing a bitch from existence or poisoning someone to death at a similar to using Vibrations to dust bones and mush organs?
And don't you dare say they both cause death.
- 7,385
- 8,175
It's not about being better. But being different. The site does not accept it as so and no amount of argumentation will change that without proof. By that logic a character who resists conceptual manipulation should be immune to almost every other offensive hax on the site even if they are normally hurt by physical blows and energy blasts.
- 85
- 55
You don't think er effects organs and bones?
- 40,701
- 35,254
I think it effects organs and bones in a W A A A A Y different way than dusting a bone or mushing an organ does.
azontr
He/Him- 39,509
- 49,607
It isn't about what it effects but about what HAPPENS. Of course existence erasure erases the bones. But that's the thing, it ERASES them. It doesn't pulverize or pulp them, it ERASES them. That means no cells, no atoms, no quarks or electrons, nothing.
- 85
- 55
that doesn't make sense to me that being the rule and being unaccepted. It could be a case by case basis between the characters being put against one another.
- 18,088
- 15,789
Are you kidding me? EHRF is Martial Arts. "A wicked style that brings total devastation" Read the Manga. Y'all are doing the most right now.
azontr
He/Him- 39,509
- 49,607
That's cool bro so make a CRT.
- 7,897
- 3,856
He's probably getting EE resistance mixed up with Mid-Godly regeneration
- 85
- 55
Exactly my point. Look at what er does compared to what garou's dura neg does. If goku can resist something that erases why would pulverization be a factor?
azontr
He/Him- 39,509
- 49,607
I am, and it does a completely different incomparable thing. It's almost as if that's what I just said.
- 18,088
- 15,789
They are two different abilities. Two different applications. Being able to resist one doesn't allow you to be able to resist the other. Stop it. Your entire argument is flawed and makes 0 logical sense.
Stop replying to this clown. He's derailing with his ignorance.
- 85
- 55
I'm arguing erasure > pulverization. And you're argument is that it's different? of course it is but why would pulverization effect goku when erasure doesn't?
- 11,192
- 2,436
Pretty much
azontr
He/Him- 39,509
- 49,607
Yeah we know erasure is better than pulverization who tf doesn't think that lmao. But it doesn't matter if it's BETTER it matters how it's DONE.
Like bro idk if your even reading the replies right you need some contact lenses or some shit bro.
- 40,701
- 35,254
Because they are done in entirely different ways, FFS
- 85
- 55
Since goku resists something stronger why would something weaker have an effect on him?
azontr
He/Him- 39,509
- 49,607
Because it's done in a completely different manner Goku doesn't resist.
- 40,701
- 35,254
Becuase that stronger thing is done in a D I F F E R E N T way
- 85
- 55
It being done in a different way doesn't change the fact that it's still the stronger of the 2. So why does it matter? shouldn't the effect matter the most? the method and how it's done shouldn't matter.
azontr
He/Him- 39,509
- 49,607
- 40,701
- 35,254
Oh my good ****..
It matters becuase one literally erases you from existence and one is Vibrations. You gonna argue Goku resists a Metal gear HF Blade's macro-Quantam cutting now?
- 85
- 55
It's like placing cause above effect. You even admitted that erasure is better.
- 85
- 55
What are the effects of the vibrations? goku cancelled out beerus shockwave which has way more range and is stronger than garou's vibrations.
- 7,897
- 3,856
Y’all still arguing with them
- 40,701
- 35,254
Oh, I don't know, maybe that's what this entire argument is about. It pulverized the bones and organs.
Your right, I shouldn't humor the Great Wall of China further.Y’all still arguing with them
- 10,296
- 17,333
1st - Existence Erasure isn't inherently "stronger" than what Garou has, it's completely dependent on the situation/fight.
Garou's Durability Negation could be better within the instance where someone resists Existence Erasure but doesn't resist their internal organs being damaged.
Just because one effect is more "devastating" compared to the other doesn't mean its actually "stronger" within every situation.
2 - Just because Goku resisted something you perceive as stronger then Garou's Durability Negation doesn't mean Goku can actually resist Garou's Durability Negation.
They're two entirely different abilities, with entirely two different functions, actions and results, they can't be compared to each other and such if Goku doesn't have feats of resisting this type of Durability Negation/his organs not scaling relative towards his physical durability then he's getting ****** up by Garou's Durability Negation.
No if, ands or buts about it.
azontr
He/Him- 39,509
- 49,607
That's cool bro but it doesn't matter.
- 85
- 55
erasure > pulverization. That's a fact. The difference is that one has a weaker effect. And I guess hakai doesn't effect organs or bones.
- 15,689
- 10,414
- 10,213
- 8,481
There is no definition of what is strong and what is weak, that is not how resistance works. All you are using is "Well, EE is much cooler than shockwaves, so it doesn't affect Goku". Such logic is not even consistent with fiction
For exemple, Mash is able to withstand a stated attack capable of return all to nothing. In the series it is also shown that Mash resists things that destroy his body and soul "without a trace". However, he is still affected by simple things like sound waves that attack the organs. Why? Because there is no correlation between one thing and another
- 40,701
- 35,254
"They're two entirely different abilities, with entirely two different functions, actions and results, they can't be compared to each other and such if Goku doesn't have feats of resisting this type of Durability Negation/his organs not scaling relative towards his physical durability then he's getting ****** up by Garou's Durability Negation."
- 15,689
- 10,414
these abilities aren't related at all
- 10,296
- 17,333
- 15,689
- 10,414
we can just show the fact that even tho goku resist hakai, Hit durability negation was still able to kill Goku xd
- 85
- 55
what proof do you have that goku's exterior doesn't scale to his interior?
- Status
