• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Punch Man - Low 5-B downgrades

Status
Not open for further replies.
So the Orochi calc has been accepted and majority agrees to it, can changes be applied? I can do that myself
 
I'm just waiting to the point that this becomes so heated we decide to say **** the feat and this becomes a staff only topic and then proceeds to be the next moon level Roshi Fiasco and then Seth gets paid to read this thread and then we have multiple threads about this until it's been 5 years till this gets accepted
 
Emirp sumitpo said:
I'm just waiting to the point that this becomes so heated we decide to say **** the feat and this becomes a staff only topic and then proceeds to be the next moon level Roshi Fiasco and then Seth gets paid to read this thread and then we have multiple threads about this until it's been 5 years till this gets accepted
Click to expand...
Nobody actually gives a **** if a staff-only thread is staff-only lol. Regular users comment all the time, ironically.
 
Transferring thermal energy on that magnitude can cause physical movement of Earth's core? or is that ball considered thermal energy?
 
Kachon123 said:
It can't
Click to expand...
The new rating falls under the assumption that the sphere has no mass. If it did have mass we would just keep it as is. It's one way or the other, we can't mix them unless we decalre the Low 5-B rating an outlier and note it on the profiles to not use it.
 
That had mass and this is evident, it makes no sense to argue that it was just thermal energy, because it doesn't even make sense, but the current calculation is more consistent, so let's go with it.
 
Okay..first of all..I have a basic question...why cant massless energy actually interact with the ground causing earthquake? When maseless energy like photons can vibrate?

I am also seeing the comments of "energy is maseless!" and thats not entirely true. Not all energy lacks mass. Some form of energy lack mass like light energy while other form of energy does have mass however for example electrical energy which does have mass ie mass of electron but its very low.

So for the record, I agree with the CRT and I was waiting for someone to do that, the fact that calculation assumed Orochi pulled 2 quintillions of tons is something I dont understand why they did that..like Orochi himself says he is digging up energy from the Earth in order to beat Saitama,not mass, Orochi has no use for the mass.
Screenshot_20210822-035109_Drive.jpg

We only see energy being pulled up from the ground not any sort of mass
Screenshot_20210822-035026_Drive.jpg


There is Electric catfish statement of epicenter moving upward but I dont see how that proves that mass is being pulled, he just thought that since Earthquake happened, it must be due to collision of some plates or by some force which is moving upward, he doesn't know whats happening down there so he wouldn't know whats being pulled

Also the energy is not treated like your usual thermal energy, energy when it reaches Orochi is "absorbed" and then launched as an attack which is no longer thermal energy(there was no hint of external mass in the attack either) so its behaving like how energy used for powers in other series works like so either way, you can argue and say that energy does have mass, if not it can interact with physical objects the same way as energy used for power like ki,chakra,nen etc does in other series
Screenshot_20210822-035235_Drive.jpg

Screenshot_20210822-035258_Drive.jpg


So the old calculation is definitely bunk and cannot be used, its reach to say that he sucked 2 quintillion tons of mass, when there is 0 evidence for that.

As for ratings, I propose that Orochi is scaled to Earthquake as his tail does that intially, but have High 6-A with gaia canon or when its absorbed, its made very clear that he doesn't scale to it regularly otherwise he wouldn't have to go all the way to absorb energy from the Earth if he was High 6-A, this is made even more evident by the fact that gaia gun required Saitama to use serious series move to block it while Saitama just uses normal punch to one shot Orochi, makes no sense for Orochi to only have weak durability.

As for Boros, he obviously scales since Saitama acknowledged Boros as actual strong opponent, unlike with Orochi who was treated like a joke in the entire fight
 
My_area said:
Okay..first of all..I have a basic question...why cant massless energy actually interact with the ground causing earthquake? When maseless energy like photons can vibrate?

I am also seeing the comments of "energy is maseless!" and thats not entirely true. Not all energy lacks mass. Some form of energy lack mass like light energy while other form of energy does have mass however for example electrical energy which does have mass ie mass of electron but its very low.

So for the record, I agree with the CRT and I was waiting for someone to do that, the fact that calculation assumed Orochi pulled 2 quintillions of tons is something I dont understand why they did that..like Orochi himself says he is digging up energy from the Earth in order to beat Saitama,not mass, Orochi has no use for the mass.
Screenshot_20210822-035109_Drive.jpg

We only see energy being pulled up from the ground not any sort of mass
Screenshot_20210822-035026_Drive.jpg


There is Electric catfish statement of epicenter moving upward but I dont see how that proves that mass is being pulled, he just thought that since Earthquake happened, it must be due to collision of some plates or by some force which is moving upward, he doesn't know whats happening down there so he wouldn't know whats being pulled

Also the energy is not treated like your usual thermal energy, energy when it reaches Orochi is "absorbed" and then launched as an attack which is no longer thermal energy(there was no hint of external mass in the attack either) so its behaving like how energy used for powers in other series works like so either way, you can argue and say that energy does have mass, if not it can interact with physical objects the same way as energy used for power like ki,chakra,nen etc does in other series
Screenshot_20210822-035235_Drive.jpg

Screenshot_20210822-035258_Drive.jpg


So the old calculation is definitely bunk and cannot be used, its reach to say that he sucked 2 quintillion tons of mass, when there is 0 evidence for that.

As for ratings, I propose that Orochi is scaled to Earthquake as his tail does that intially, but have High 6-A with gaia canon or when its absorbed, its made very clear that he doesn't scale to it regularly otherwise he wouldn't have to go all the way to absorb energy from the Earth if he was High 6-A, this is made even more evident by the fact that gaia gun required Saitama to use serious series move to block it while Saitama just uses normal punch to one shot Orochi, makes no sense for Orochi to only have weak durability.

As for Boros, he obviously scales since Saitama acknowledged Boros as actual strong opponent, unlike with Orochi who was treated like a joke in the entire fight
Click to expand...
Where did you read that? can you give me a link?
 
My_area said:
Okay..first of all..I have a basic question...why cant massless energy actually interact with the ground causing earthquake? When maseless energy like photons can vibrate?

I am also seeing the comments of "energy is maseless!" and thats not entirely true. Not all energy lacks mass. Some form of energy lack mass like light energy while other form of energy does have mass however for example electrical energy which does have mass ie mass of electron but its very low.

So for the record, I agree with the CRT and I was waiting for someone to do that, the fact that calculation assumed Orochi pulled 2 quintillions of tons is something I dont understand why they did that..like Orochi himself says he is digging up energy from the Earth in order to beat Saitama,not mass, Orochi has no use for the mass.
Screenshot_20210822-035109_Drive.jpg

We only see energy being pulled up from the ground not any sort of mass
Screenshot_20210822-035026_Drive.jpg


There is Electric catfish statement of epicenter moving upward but I dont see how that proves that mass is being pulled, he just thought that since Earthquake happened, it must be due to collision of some plates or by some force which is moving upward, he doesn't know whats happening down there so he wouldn't know whats being pulled

Also the energy is not treated like your usual thermal energy, energy when it reaches Orochi is "absorbed" and then launched as an attack which is no longer thermal energy(there was no hint of external mass in the attack either) so its behaving like how energy used for powers in other series works like so either way, you can argue and say that energy does have mass, if not it can interact with physical objects the same way as energy used for power like ki,chakra,nen etc does in other series
Screenshot_20210822-035235_Drive.jpg

Screenshot_20210822-035258_Drive.jpg


So the old calculation is definitely bunk and cannot be used, its reach to say that he sucked 2 quintillion tons of mass, when there is 0 evidence for that.

As for ratings, I propose that Orochi is scaled to Earthquake as his tail does that intially, but have High 6-A with gaia canon or when its absorbed, its made very clear that he doesn't scale to it regularly otherwise he wouldn't have to go all the way to absorb energy from the Earth if he was High 6-A, this is made even more evident by the fact that gaia gun required Saitama to use serious series move to block it while Saitama just uses normal punch to one shot Orochi, makes no sense for Orochi to only have weak durability.

As for Boros, he obviously scales since Saitama acknowledged Boros as actual strong opponent, unlike with Orochi who was treated like a joke in the entire fight
Click to expand...
So: "High 6-B, High 6-A with Gaia Cannon" is what you're proposing?
 
I think you can, but IIRC, the site does not allow for certain links (Like read comics online for example)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Farfetchedx
Psykos Revision and OPM mid tiers possibly High 6-C upgrade
2
Replies
48
Views
3K
Qawsedf234
Qawsedf234
TyranoDoom30
OPM profiles possible renaming
Replies
5
Views
2K
Recon1511
Recon1511
Farfetchedx
Tier 6 OPM Mid-Tier Upgrades
Replies
12
Views
2K
Shadow_x007x
Shadow_x007x
Damage3245
  • Locked
One-Punch Man Speed Revisions
Replies
30
Views
2K
Damage3245
Damage3245
ImposingTiger
  • Locked
Debunking Serum Psykos' "possibly High 6-A" rating
2
Replies
57
Views
3K
ByAsura
ByAsura
Back
Top