DEATHBATTLE! Accuracy Scale [Part 5]

Hello everyone. In light of original creator of these threads, TitanCrusher101, being absent, I will be taking the role of general upkeep and moderation for this thread until such time as he returns. Continuing on from here, we are currently ironing out all the details of the placement for this list and prepping for the upcoming Death Battle season. These are the rules and current listing copy and pasted from Titan:

Rules:

- Non important off calculations don't count.

- If the winner of a stomp is the one who stomps, accurate!

- If the winner of a stomp is the character who gets stomped, highly inaccurate!!

- Joke Battles are ONLY placeholders. (Smokey VS McGruff is not a joke battle)

- Stomps/Blitzes and Joke Battles will be labeled.

- I will rank these each on how good I believe their animation is. (I'll rank them based on what style they're using as well, meaning 3D battles will not be rated higher than sprites just for what they are)

- ATT = At The Time

-Because of revelations from the research team for DB, all battles are to be considered as if the strongest forms of each fighter are used immediately. Because of this, certain battles have different results then when it starts at base. For these battles, the forms used will be placed alongside the fight for clarity.

Right, Good (Right Verdict + Good Research)

1. The Meta (Agent Maine) vs Agent Carolina | Reason: Word of God | Animation: 9/10

2. Thanos vs Darkseid (Infinity Gauntlet Thanos vs Godhead Darkseid) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

3. Mob vs Tornado of Terror (???% Mob vs Tatsumaki) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

4. Iron Ma vs Lex Luthor (Luthor in character would make the battle play out as it did) (Superior Iron Man vs Warsuit Lex Luthor) | Animation: 9/10

5. Balrog vs TJ Combo | Animation: 9/10

6. Samurai Jack vs Afro Samurai | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

7. Mega Man Battle Royale (Super Adaptor Classic vs Ultimate Armor X vs Volnutt vs Hub Form EXE vs Red Joker Geo) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

8. Leon S. Kennedy vs Frank West | Animation: 8/10

9. Hawkeye vs Green Arrow | Animation: 8.5/10

10. The Hulk vs Doomsday (Worldbreaker Hulk vs Doomsday) | Animation: 8/10

11. Spyro the Dragon vs Crash Bandicoot (Dark Spyro vs Crash) | Animation: 9/10

12. Aang vs Edward Elric (Avatar State Aang vs Edward) | Animation: 8/10

13. Dan Hibiki vs Hercule Satan | Animation: 8.5/10

14. RoboCop vs The Terminator (T-850) | Animation: 8.5/10

15. Ganondorf vs Dracula (Ganon vs Dracula) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

16. Solid Snake vs Sam Fisher | Animation: 9/10

17. Optimus Prime vs RX-78-2 Gundam | Animation: 8.5/10

18. Deadpool vs Deathstroke | Animation: 9/10

19. Wolverine vs Raiden (Berserker Wolverine vs Ripper Mode Raiden) | Reason: HF blade can cut through adamantium | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

20. Roronoa Zoro vs Erza Scarlet (ATT) | Animation: 8/10

21. Deadpool vs The Mask | Reason: Big Head obliterates Wade [STOMP] | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

22. All Might vs Might Guy (Prime All Might vs Eighth Gate Guy) | Reason: Guy is Mightier | Animation: 9/10

23. Darth Vader vs Doctor Doom | Animation: 8.5/10

24. Batman vs Spider-Man (no prep) | Animation: 6/10

25. Black Panther vs Batman | Reason: Batman has no way through vibranium | Animation: 7.5/10

26. TMNT Battle Royale | Animation: 8/10

27. Mike Haggar vs Zangief | Animation: 7/10

28. Metal Sonic vs Zero (Metal Overlord vs Absolute Zero) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

29. Smokey the Bear vs McGruff the Crime Dog | Animation: 9/10

30. Master Chief vs Doomguy (ATT) (Halo 3 MC vs Doomguy) | Animation: 7/10

31. Venom vs Bane | Animation: 7/10

32. The Joker vs Sweet Tooth | Animation: 8/10

33. Godzilla vs Gamera (Composite Godzilla vs Gamera) | Animation: 7/10

34. Master Roshi vs Jiraiya (Sage Mode Jiraiya vs Buff Roshi) | Animation: 8/10

35. Ultron vs Sigma | Animation: 9/10

36. Weiss Schnee vs Mitsuru Kirijo | Animation: 9/10

37. Wario vs King Dedede | Animation: 9/10

38. Johnny Cage vs Captain Falcon | Animation: 8/10

39. Doctor Strange vs Doctor Fate | Reason: Fate blitzes [BLITZ] | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

40. Captain Marvel vs Shazam | Reason: Billy has every advantage (more or less) | Animation: 8.5/10

Right, Decent (Right Verdict + Decent Research)

41. Ben 10 vs Green Lantern (Alien X vs Hal) | Reason: Pre-Crisis Green Lantern was used. | Animation: 9/10

42. Black Widow vs Widowmaker | Reason: The Widow meets her Maker, and get blitzed in the process. [BLITZ] | Animation: 8/10

43. The Flash vs Quicksilver | Flash is so much faster than Quicksilver it's not even funny. [HOLY SHIT BLITZ] | Animation: 9/10

44. Tracer vs The Scout | Reason: Accurate outcome, but iffy research. | Animation: 8/10

45. Rachet and Clank vs Jak and Daxter | Reason: Clank's resistance to Time Hax and Ratchet's amazing versatlity give them the win. | Animation: 9/10

46. Thor Odinson vs Raiden | Reason: Thor obliterates Raiden. [MASSIVE STOMP] | Animation: 7/10

47. Luke Skywalker vs Harry Potter | Animation: 7/10

48. Raven vs Twilight Sparkle | Animation: 8/10

49. Voltron vs Dino Megazord | Animation: 9/10

50. He-Man vs Lion-O | Animation: 8/10

51. Ivy Valentine vs Black Orchid | Animation: 8/10

52. Pokémon vs Digimon (aka Red & Mega Charizard X vs Tai Yagami & WarGreymon) | Animation: 9/10

53. Dante vs Bayonetta (DMC4 Devil Trigger Dante vs Bayonetta) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

54. Natsu Dragneel vs Portgas D. Ace (Dragon Force Natsu vs Ace) | Animation: 8.5/10

55. Kirby vs Majin Buu (Kid Buu vs Kirby) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

56. Fulgore vs Sektor | Animation: 8.5/10

57. Pokémon Battle Royale (purely wild versions) | Animation: 8/10

58. Luigi vs Miles "Tails" Prower | Animation: 7/10

59. Thor Odinson vs Wonder Woman (Warrior Madness Thor vs Godwave WW) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

60. Lucario vs Renamon (Generic) | Animation: 9/10

61. Shao Kahn vs M. Bison | Animation: 8.5/10

62. Ken Masters vs Terry Bogard | Animation: 8/10

63. Scrooge McDuck vs Shovel Knight | Animation: 8/10

64. Amy Rose vs Ramona Flowers | Animation:

65. Ragna the Bloodedge vs Sol Badguy (ATT) (Black Beast Ragna vs Dragon Install Sol)

66. Ryu vs Scorpion (Mu no Ken Ryu vs MK9 Scorpion) | Animation: 9/10

67. Mario vs Sonic the Hedgehog 1 (Starman Mario vs Archie Super Sonic) | Animation: 6.5/10

68. Chun-Li vs Mai Shiranui | Animation: 7.5/10

69. Mega Man vs Astro Boy (Super Adaptor Rock vs Manga, 60s-80s Adam) | Animation: 8/10

70. Zitz vs Leonardo | Animation: 7.5/10

71. Samus Aran vs Boba Fett 2 | Animation: 8/10

72. Mario vs Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (Starman Mario vs Hyper Sonic) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY SHIT AWARD)

73. Akuma vs Shang Tsung | Animation: 7/10

74. Jotaro Kujo vs Kenshiro | Animation: 8.5/10

75. Sephiroth vs Vergil (Sephiroth vs DMC3 Devil Trigger Vergil) | Animation: 8.5/10

76. Starscream vs Rainbow Dash | Animation: 7/10

77. Aquaman vs Namor | Animation: 8.5/10

78. Kratos vs Spawn | Animation: 7/10

79. Yoshi vs Riptor | Animation: 7.5/10

80. Son Goku vs Superman 1 (SSJ4 Goku vs Post Crisis Superman) | Animation: 8/10

81. Princess Zelda vs Princess Peach | Animation: 7/10

82. Samus Aran vs Boba Fett 1 | Animation: 6/10

Iffy

83. Android 18 vs Captain Marvel | Animation: 7.5/10

84-85. Felicia vs Taokaka, Fox McCloud vs Bucky O'Hare | Animation: 7/10

86. Ghost Rider vs Lobo (Zarathos vs Lobo) | Animation: 9.5/10 (HOLY FRAG AWARD)

87. Beast vs Goliath | Animation: 7/10

88. Sora vs Pit (DDD Sora vs Three Sacred Treasures Pit) | Animation: 8/10

Wrong, Decent (Wrong Verdict + Decent Research)

89. Daredevil vs Nightwing | Reason: Even a blind person could see how Dick loses this one. | Live Action: 9/10

90. Cammy White vs Sonya Blade | Animation: 7/10

91. Sub-Zero vs Glacius | Reason: Glacius has an ICE advantage. [STOMP] | Animation: 8/10 | Pun: Pretty cold

92. Naruto Uzumaki vs Ichigo Kurosaki (Tailed Beast Six Paths Sage Mode Naruto vs True Bankai Merged Hollow Ichigo) | Reason: Due to Naruto being nerfed Ichigo stomps now [STOMP] | Animation: 9/10

93. Ryu Hayabusa vs Strider Hiryu | Animation: 7.5/10

94. Donkey Kong vs Knuckles the Echidna | Animation: 8/10

95. Batman vs Captain America | Animation: 7/10

96. The Shredder vs Silver Samurai (Super Shredder vs SS) | Animation: 8/10

97. Ryu vs Jin Kazama (Mu no Ken Ryu vs Devil Jin) | Animation: 9/10

98. Mechagodzilla (Millenium) vs Dragonzord | Animation: 9/10

99. Mewtwo vs Shadow the Hedgehog (Mega Mewtwo Y vs Super Shadow) | Shadow still resists mind hax and is much faster. [BLITZ] | Animation: 8/10

Wrong, Bad (Wrong Verdict + Bad Research)

100. Dr. Eggman vs Dr. Wily (Basically Metal Overlord vs Super Adaptor Bass)

101. Vegeta vs Shadow the Hedgehog (SSJ2 Vegeta vs Archie Super Shadow) | Reason: Archie is broken. [BIG BLITZ] | Animation: 8/10

102. Bowser vs Ganondorf (Bowser vs Ganon) | Reason: Bowser destroys him. | Animation: 8/10

103. Batman Beyond vs Spider-Man 2099 | Reason: Miguel's superior AP and durability gives him the win quite handily. | Animation: 8/10

104. Link vs Cloud Strife | Reason: Cloud would blitz and one shot him before he could Link. | Animation: 8/10 | Pun: Terrible/10

105. Tigerzord vs Gundam Epyon (Mega Tigerzord vs Epyon) | Reason: Tommy destroys Epyon. [BIG STOMP] | Animation: 6/10

106. Son Goku vs Superman 2 (SSB Goku vs Post-Crisis/New 52 Superman) | Reason: Due to Goku's "new hairstyles" as Supes puts it, he absolutely destroys Superman now, especially when using only Post-Crisis Superman. [BIG STOMP] | Animation: 7/10

107. Carnage vs Lucy (EoS "Long Horn" Lucy vs Carnage) | Reason: DB's researchers really Elfen Lied with this verdict. [BLITZ] | Animation: 8/10

108. Rogue vs Wonder Woman | Reason: Rogue is the one who Diana kisses goodbye. [STOMP] | Animation: 6/10 | Pun: Boomstick tier

107. Gaara vs Toph Bei Fong | Reason: Toph didn't sand a chance. [HOLY BLITZ] | Animation: 7/10 | Pun: 9/10

110. Pikachu vs Blanka | Reason: Pikachu blitzes [STOMP] | Animation: 5/10

111. Sasuke Uchiha vs Hiei (Six Paths Susano'o Sasuke vs Jaganshi Hiei) | Reason: The feat they used for Hiei was inflated and not actually canon. [STOMP] | Animation: 8/10

112. Guts vs Nightmare (Berserker Armor Guts vs Night Terror) | Reason: Nightmare stomps. [BIG STOMP] | Animation: 8/10

113. Yang Xiao Long vs Tifa Lockheart | Reason: Yang RWBY paying the price. [HUGE STOMP] | Animation: 8/10

114. Bomberman vs Dig Dug | Reason: Dig Dug gets buried quickly. [MASSIVE STOMP] | Animation: 6/10

Joke Battles

115. Chuck Norris vs Segata Sanshiro | Animation: 9/10

116. Deadpool vs Pinkie Pie | Animation: 8/10

117. Goomba vs Koopa | Animation: 7/10

118. Justin Bieber vs Rebecca Black | Animation: Baby/Friday levels of bad

Copying my last post from Part 4 to continue the discussion:

@Kingo

Calc

@Theuser

It does matter to this thread if you want to argue that Metal is way faster than Zero. Based on the staff's reaction, I'm not trusting it for now. I'll try and find an official source that describes Exception to see if the context fits.

I played Rush years ago and both Eggmans never describe how they're going to get to this new dimension other than saying they're using the Emeralds. If you go to the Eggman Nega link in the calc page and rewind back to the start of the scene, you can see for yourself. Even at the end of the fight, the area just turns white and the universes are back to normal, we never see how the two get home, so the distance traveled is extremely vague

Sweet.

Uh. Yeah. I doubt that calc's getting accepted. What's even the point? They have Immeasurable speed anyways.

Also, I should bring up that the Classic Mega Men just got upgraded to 11 Ninatons of TNT. Would that be stronger than Metal or...?

Stronger than base metal but probably not overlord

also hi Migue. Lol

Waddup?

I still feel like Shredder vs Silver Samurai should be higher up

Back

Migue79 said:

Sweet.

Uh. Yeah. I doubt that calc's getting accepted. What's even the point? They have Immeasurable speed anyways.

Click to expand...

They have a low-end speed akin to their low-end AP

Reposting and tweaking what I said.

Migue79 said:

That calculation seemed to have been rejected by 3 staff members lol

Click to expand...

Yeah, this is a no. Those 3 staff can't even refute it in the thread properly and are nowhere to be seen when one is made to discuss it. Staff say-so is mever the be-all end-all when it comes to these things if they can't back up what they say. Some of their points were also bad

Sorvoe551 said:

Copying my last post from Part 4 to continue the discussion:

@Kingo

Calc

@Theuser

It does matter to this thread if you want to argue that Metal is way faster than Zero. Based on the staff's reaction, I'm not trusting it for now. I'll try and find an official source that describes Exception to see if the context fits.

I played Rush years ago and both Eggmans never describe how they're going to get to this new dimension other than saying they're using the Emeralds. If you go to the Eggman Nega link in the calc page and rewind back to the start of the scene, you can see for yourself. Even at the end of the fight, the area just turns white and the universes are back to normal, we never see how the two get home, so the distance traveled is extremely vague

Click to expand...

Even the current calc is enough for Metal to beat Zero, the 1 4 billion C one, I just mentioned it because people mentioned another calc that wasn't put on the profiles yet

Also since we got official confirmation that Death Battle rules does not count beating before transforming we got to change the list, and no, this is not like stats or animation, we use their rules, otherwise we would have argued the validity of the arsenal, transformations, and source used in those

bump

Shouldn't we consider Yoshi vs Riptor a Joke Battle?

Bump

How do you spoiler tag something here?

We wait until the episode comes out on YouTube, we avoid spoiler tags here

I see...

I mean, we still need to update the list with the new rules

For what reasons?

Basically because the whole thing can't be taken seriously for how Riptor was basically Yoshi's punch bag the whole time

The fighting being a joke =/= the whole episode is a joke battle.

For what reasons?

Theuser789 said:

I mean, we still need to update the list with the new rules

Click to expand...

Ahem

I'll look through the list to see which battles the rule change affects later, then we can analyze those one at a time

Ok cool, thanks then, it will be probaly a good amount tho

Maybe. We'll see

Migue79 said:

For what reasons?

Click to expand...

They used composite (human) Shredder meaning he'd have the AP advantage and comparable speed to SS

Also skill

Just FYI, Balrog vs. TJ Combo currently links to Lord of the Rings!Balrog, not Street Fighter!Balrog.

Edit: Also, under Vegeta vs. Shadow, "Shadow blitzes Mewtwo" is listed. I presume that's meant to be Vegeta?

@Stickman'

Despite him being composite, SS being way faster and being able to negate durability makes it a loss for Shredder

Isn't it specifically metal? Also both are Massively Hypersonic+

Nope. Fastest Shredder is 4Kids, who is Hypersonic+ reactions. Also, SS's tachyon field basically lets him slice through most anything

Actually Mutants in Manhattan Shredder is MHS+

We don't have a profile for him, so he's still Hypersonic

I'm pretty sure that's not how it works

We did the same thing for Bucky O'Hare and Felicia, if there's no profiles for them with clear feats, we didn't acknowledge it since we didn't want to make bad assumptions. Also, MiM is a video game and they referenced shows only.

If you have the calc for MiM Shredder's speed, however, I will consider it

We already have profiles for other MiM characters and those are listed as MHS+ in speed

Is Hulk vs Doomsday that accurate? Hulk even before the Immortal thingy shown regen from decapitation and such

@Black

Yes, since the fight animation doesn't matter for research. Hulk has no means to really put Doomsday down, it's been all but proven that Doomsday is immune to being beaten to death.

So with the new rules, here's the matches that are affected by this. Please note that in some cases, the result won't change:

-Mob vs Tatsumaki (???% Mob vs Tornado)

-Mega Man Battle Royale (Super Adaptor (Classic) vs Ultimate Armor (X) vs Volnutt vs Hub Form (Battle Network) vs Red Joker (Star Force))

-Hulk vs Doomsday (Worldbreaker Hulk vs Doomsday)

-Spyro the Dragon vs Crash Bandicoot (Dark Spyro vs Crash)

-Aang vs Edward Elric (Avatar State Aang vs Edward)

-Ganondorf vs Dracula (Ganon vs Dracula)

-Wolverine vs Raiden (Berserker Wolverine vs Ripper Mode Raiden)

-All Might vs Might Guy (Prime All Might vs 8th Gate Guy)

-Metal Sonic vs Zero (Metal Overlord vs Absolute Zero)

-Master Roshi vs Jiraiya (Buff Roshi vs Sage Mode Jiraiya)

-Ben 10 vs Green Lantern (Alien X vs Hal)

-Ratchet & Clank vs Jak & Daxter (Light/Dark Jak vs Ratchet)

-Pokémon vs Digimon (Mega Charizard X vs WarGreymon)

-Dante vs Bayonetta (DMC4 Devil Trigger Dante vs Bayonetta)

-Natsu Dragneel vs Portgas D. Ace (Dragon Force Natsu vs Ace)

-Kirby vs Majin Buu (Kid Buu vs Kirby)

-Thor Odinson vs Wonder Woman (Warrior Madness Thor vs God Power WW)

-Ragna the Bloodedge vs Sol Badguy (Black Beast Ragna vs Dragon Install Sol)

-Ryu vs Scorpion (Mu no Ken Ryu vs Scorpion)

-Mario vs Sonic 1 (Star Mario vs Super Sonic)

-Mega Man vs Astro Boy (Super Adaptor vs Astro Boy)

-Mario vs Sonic 2 (Star Mario vs Hyper Sonic)

-Sephiroth vs Vergil (Sephiroth vs DMC3 Devil Trigger Vergil)

-Son Goku vs Superman 1 (SSJ4 Goku vs Superman)

-Ghost Rider vs Lobo (Zarathos vs Lobo)

-Sora vs Pit (DDD Sora vs Three Sacred Treasures Pit)

-Naruto Uzumaki vs Ichigo Kurosaki (Tailed Beast Six Paths Sage Mode Naruto vs True Bankai Merged Hollow Ichigo)

-The Shredder vs Silver Samurai (Super Shredder vs SS)

-Ryu vs Jin Kazama (Mu no Ken Ryu vs Devil Jin)

-Dr. Eggman vs Dr. Wily (Basically Metal Overlord vs Super Adaptor Bass)

-Vegeta vs Shadow the Hedgehog (SSJ2 Vegeta vs Super Shadow)

-Bowser vs Ganondorf (Bowser vs Ganon)

-Tigerzord vs Gundam Epyon (Mega Tigerzord vs Epyon)

-Son Goku vs Superman 2 (SSB Goku vs Superman)

-Carnage vs Lucy (Carnage vs EoS "Long Horn" Lucy)

-Sasuke Uchiha vs Hiei (Six Paths Susano'o vs Jaganshi Hiei)

-Guts vs Nightmare (Berserker Armor Guts vs Night Terror)