• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Piece Discussion Thread Fourteen Marineford

Js250476

Js250476

Messages
10,752
Reaction score
4,350
Well this is it after over a generation of storytelling it appears One Piece is finally approaching the climax of this marvelous story in 5 years time. And no more fitting time to celebrate and prepare then opening with arguably one of the most legendary arcs in anime/manga history The Paramount War aka the Marineford arc.

79695D87-C004-44B7-A3D0-CCF359C382CF
188CAAE3-3527-4B19-BC67-4C410C3C8BCB
B2A8CE5C-B466-4D52-AF1D-433D4434105F
9CEFDB84-C845-44CF-9CF8-0C9410B86CD2
B6FA892E-67EE-4E17-939C-F224D45E0CC9
9E4A1AA7-3D82-4784-9AF9-E87E548D561F
Thank you for loving me.

6910081C-0E63-4C05-9E43-21C521068C68
Did not suffer a single coward's injury.

8E40ADD2-9C36-4727-869E-8A2490F14EF5
This is my era

4533C986-8CF1-45CC-AD21-066D0146D9B7
The man that ended the war that was crafted in history.
 
Also shouldn't Magellan be stronger than his inmates ? Which should put him above Jinbei
 
No, not at all. Ace was restrained in power nulling cuffs and spent time receiving the worst types of torture Impel Down had to offer. There are various reasons why Magellan was able to restrain Ace.
 
LordWhis said:
Also shouldn't Magellan be stronger than his inmates ? Which should put him above Jinbei
Click to expand...
What kind of ridiculous logic are you using?
 
What kind of ridiculous logic are you using?

He can keep them all in line. Jinbei isn't even weakened by sea stone cuffs yet Magellan walks around fearlessly in level 6 causing more fear than anything else. IIRC even Jinbei feared him.
 
The Calaca said:
DF users are rendered almost powerless when cuffed with Seastone.
Click to expand...
Marco tanked hits from Kizaru while cuffed and lived to tell the tale. It isn't that big of a power decrease.
 
Because Magellan is a walking biological threat.

He lived because Galdino freed him from the cuffs to regenerate. Kizaru lolstomped him the moment Marco got the cuffs.
 
That should at least make him rel+

If Marco was depowered down to high 7c then they would have had to pick up what was left of him with a vacuum cleaner after getting hit with Kizaru's low 6B+ attacks.
 
Speaking about scaling, i still ask myself why Fujitora is put so much low in the scaling.

Even if we don't have enough evidence that he is equal to the original admirals, he has be considered a serious threat by Doflamingo and Akainu wouldn't have sent him to Dressrosa if he wasn't sure that he has the necessary strength to win, he could had sent Kizaru instead.

Doffy even stated that he has heard many stories about him and Ryokugyu, stating that both of them are considered true beasts in terms of power, and considering the level of strength the people on the New World had, it would make sense for Fujitora to be at least be able to challenge Top Yonko Commanders, otherwise it wouldn't make much sense.

And beside that, its likely that he had also fought Jack the Drought when the latter tried to rescue Doflamingo during the Zou Arc, so technically he should scaling from him, unless someone want to argue that Sengoku and Tsuru did most of the job, but that sound unlikely.

Personally i think he should be the same tier as Doflamingo, Tsuru or Jack (At least High 7-A+, likely Low 6-B).
 
LordWhis said:
Well Sengoku is a 6B...
Click to expand...
So we must assume Sengoku was fighting Jack alone while Tsuru and Issho were cheering him like cheerleaders?

Yeah i don't think so.
 
I mean Sengoku could have just blitzed and one-shotted him like Kaido did to Luffy- Tsuru and Issho wouldn't have to do anything
 
We shouldn't really assume anything about that fight.

All we know about it is that Jack got beaten, and those three individuals (plus random Vice Admirals and other Marines) were on board the ships.
 
Damage3245 said:
All we know about it is that Jack got beaten, and those three individuals (plus random Vice Admirals and other Marines) were on board the ships.
Click to expand...
But Jack had also his pirate fleet to back up likely full of Gifters (and Headliners) to help him along.
 
LordWhis said:
I mean Sengoku could have just blitzed and one-shotted him like Kaido did to Luffy- Tsuru and Issho wouldn't have to do anything
Click to expand...
And yet this didn't happen, even that i find hard to believe that Fujitora or Tsuru would just leave all the job to Sengoku.
 
I remembered something about the data book implying Sengoku wasn't involved in the fight it was on Tsuru and Issho.
 
Damage3245 said:
We shouldn't really assume anything about that fight.
All we know about it is that Jack got beaten, and those three individuals (plus random Vice Admirals and other Marines) were on board the ships.
Click to expand...
Beaten AND we also know he wasn't killed or captured AND he took out half thier ships in the process. Sounds like at least a mid difficult fight to me if not much much higher.

Anyway, I agree with Stefano that Issho should be higher. He has more than enough reasons. It would be weird if he and Greenbull were that much weaker than Kizaru. Akainu and Kuzan maybe given they were considered for Fleet Admiral but just regular admirals should not be that far apart. Also Jinbei (I think it was him) said the Mariens were stronger than before even with the loss of Kuzan. That would mean Issho+Ryu>Kuzan which would put Issho at 1.25 teratons.

Then there was his fight with Gear 3 Luffy who should be 800 Gigatons, and his scaling to Duffy calling it a hard win putting him on the edge of Low 6-B as well.

At least Large Island level, Possibly Small country level seems appropiate.
 
Stop pulling baseless claims. We have no evidence how weakened Marco gets from Seastone.

Luffy was outright ignoring the Seastone via sheer willpower as stated by Babanuki. And it was a mixtura of metals with less Seastone in it intended to make them strong enough to do the work they do in Udon.
 
The main point is this isn't reliable scaling. It's basically like scaling Batman To Superman cause he can draw blood with a kryptonite ring.

Marco is likely an exception cause of how strong he is. So his weakened state could keep going
 
Marco shouldn't be that much weaker than Katakuri. I would be shocked if he went down so easily.
 
Do you guys think that Admirals know the Rokushiki? We could see characters far below in marine using this and the Admirals is cleary the most skilled group of the entire WG.
 
It's a possibility, but we can't say for certain until they demonstrate it or are stated to use it.
 
Js250476 said:
The main point is this isn't reliable scaling. It's basically like scaling Batman To Superman cause he can draw blood with a kryptonite ring.

Marco is likely an exception cause of how strong he is. So his weakened state could keep going
Click to expand...
But shouldn't cuffed ace be roughly equal to cuffed Marco ?
 
It's more like saying if General Zod in kryptonite chains can building bust and Batman fought evenly with superman in kryptonite chains then he should also be able to building bust.
 
LordWhis said:
But shouldn't cuffed ace be roughly equal to cuffed Marco ?
Click to expand...
Why? How? Let's please stop making stuff up.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

ByAsura
  • Locked
Minor One Piece Changes
Replies
16
Views
3K
ByAsura
ByAsura
ShinMaximillion
  • Locked
Type Moon Revival CRT relating high tiers and a few current relevant profiles - Part 1
5 6 7
Replies
246
Views
60K
ShinMaximillion
ShinMaximillion
Kachon123
  • Locked
One Piece: Edward Can Shake Stars
5 6 7
Replies
276
Views
41K
KingTempest
KingTempest
VeryGoofyToddler2
The Song of the Unsong (Revision Thread Because Nobody Wanted to Do It)
2 3
Replies
83
Views
15K
Antvasima
Antvasima
SamanPatou
  • Locked
Howard the Duck - Trapped in a revision he never made!
Replies
16
Views
2K
Antvasima
Antvasima
Back
Top