The List
From top to bottom...
I don't know the current opinion on Cinemassaverse and Awesomeverse. Dargoo was against their YouTube appearances, and other staff agreed with his posts in general, but I don't know the staff consensus.
Anthony Padilla and Ian Hecox need to be remade to only include Food Battle feats. I'm not sure how much of their profiles would need to be tossed out for this, but they're probably better off being deleted and remade.
The Nameless One (CalebCity) was waiting on the profile's creator, whose
argument for it staying wasn't accepted by staff. It's an unauthorized composite of unrelated characters just because they're played by the same dude, with the defense being "If TNO's deleted, Bugs Bunny should be too!" Seems accepted to delete.
Who Killed Markiplier profiles are under debate.
Oishi Kawaii and
Noodles were
agreed to be fine.
HABIT is from an ARG that spans multiple platforms. Everyone seems fine with it.
Filthy Frank (Francis of the Filth) is exclusively from the book version, and it's been around since January, facing multiple calls for deletion but always staying around. The only recent call for deletion is from Dargoo, as part of deleting all YT personas in games, books, etc. but this hasn't received a huge amount of support.
Characters from
The Big Lez Show are fine, it's an animation that happens to be on YouTube.
The Ginosaji's fine. He's from a series of comedic YouTube videos that was originally a movie pitch, and has been around for almost a year without much controversy.
Brandon Rogers (Verse) pages have had some disputes over whether they're allowed.
Balgar (Verse) is an animated series, seems fine.
Petscop needs a bit of explanation, but is fine and accepted.
Petscop Explanation |
The "Petscop" profiles are for characters in a fictional game called "Petscop". It comes from a horror/mystery series on YouTube disguised as a let's play, a let's play of this fictional game.
Since it's a horror series played straight, and the protagonist playing it isn't an actual YouTuber outside of this series, Dargoo and I (and presumably others) think it's fine.
|
Battle for Dream Island characters are another animated series, no calls to delete these.
Look-See has
been accepted to stay, as it's a horror series with continuity.
Animator vs. Animatio another animated verse with little controversy.
Small Girl has been mentioned once, but it seems fine. Not a persona, just a character in a ~9 minute video from an SFX artist.
The Observer (TribeTwelve) is apparently a part of the same series as
HABIT, so it should similarly be acceptable.
Jeff the Killer Saga is about as acceptable as other
creepypasta-inspired series. There's an argument to remove them, but it's nothing to do with being a YouTube profile.
Elo appears to be from an animated webseries, and considering
this analysis it should have continuity. I'm not familiar with it but it should be fine.
Slenderman (The Angel's Game) same as the other creepypasta-inspired profiles.
ASDF (Verse) is a series of very short animated skits with near-zero continuity and plot, along the lines of
The Lazer Collectio. There's a large consensus to delete these.
Dross (Verse) is a video game series. No clue why it's on the list and I haven't seen anyone in the threads talk about it.
Sock and
Mephistopheles (Welcome to Hell) are from a webcomic + YouTube animation series. Seems fine.
Warning, I'm biased in evaluating the next page since I made it myself recently; it's currently in my sandbox and not on the main wiki
Tao is from a 20-minute slightly
animated video that's kinda like a short story. It's made by a relatively popular YouTuber but since it doesn't contain any likeness/resemblance/insert of him, everyone I've asked about it thinks it's fine.
The Beard,
The Sweeping Ma,
Resident Enis all seem like they'd be controversial. Considering that Markiplier AND Dodger are a canon part of the series. They'd fall under similar issues to the Who Killed Markiplier pages, if not worse.
The Summary
Anthony Padilla and Ian Hecox need to be deleted and remade. The Nameless One (CalebCity) and all ASDF (Verse) profiles need to be deleted. Everything else is either accepted or still undergoing discussion.
